Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Has anyone delt with being the only stable sibling but the furtherest away and tricky family dynamics with dealing with elderly parents

14 replies

walker1211 · 16/11/2026 11:06

Any advice on how to get through this stage where everything is new, people are scared and things feel overwhelming.

My MIL has being showing signed of cognitive decline for some years however this year her short-term memory has become non-existent. She is waiting for formal diagnosis but seems clear that she has dementia. She has also had a few falls. She is actually a fit and healthy 80+ year-old in many ways with lots of friends, social life and cooks and can take care of her home. She lives very close by two adult grandchildren and her DD and DS (he does travel for work). So in many ways a very strong step up.

Myself and my DH live over 3 hours away.

However, her adult children for various reasons don’t really have the emotional maturity or stability to be strong carers for her. There are more used to going round to hers for Sunday lunch etc and have had a very inter meshed, slightly toxic relationship and are now finding the changes in her and the changes in their relationship really hard to cope with, often being annoyed and angry about the situation. They can’t be in charge of sorting out better care for her as the years go on as they can’t deal with any complexity, one can’t use computers.

This leaves my DH who works full-time has to be in office for three days and we have much younger children than any of the other others.

His mother is also adamant that she won’t take any next stage support like a call alarm and certainly wouldn’t consider living a more suitable house.

Now the pattern seems to be that my BIL is very annoyed with my DH which mainly seems to just be about him living far away and not having to deal with the day-to-day reality. I guess my concerns are she’s not even really dependent now and actually overall the only thing is she’s a bit forgetful and I’m really concerned what this means for everything going forward when things inevitably get a lot more challenging and difficult as she just ages but also whatever she has progresses.

Has anyone delt with being the only stable sibling but the furtherest away and tricky family dynamics with dealing with elderly parents. I also worry about my SIL moving in her her as she is really unsuitable and has a drinking problem.

OP posts:
redfishcat · 16/11/2026 15:36

Who has POA, as that will be vital going forward.
And has she made a will, or does intestacy work in this case.

we have the sibling furthest away with POA and the nearest one does more of the day to day practical one. It works for us. It’s also important to remember there is no right or wrong way to do a task, as long as it gets done.

tooldforicy · 17/11/2026 11:34

I am also the 'further away sensible child' with a mother with dementia and brother/SIL who live closer but are struggling to come to terms with the reality of the situation. We're a bit further down the line and my advice to you is:

  • Try to have a sensible discussion with all the siblings about what care your MIL is likely to need and how this can realistically be provided. Do it now, before the need arises and if your MIL still has a reasonable level of understanding include her. I know this seems really obvious but my brother and mum buried their heads in the sand before we got a formal diagnosis and at the time I thought we'd be able to have that conversation when later. In reality Mum's needs increased significantly before we had any formal diagnosis, which made her/brother even more emotionally reactive and less willing to have any sensible discussion.
  • Set your own boundaries. There will, almost inevitably, come a time where your mum is not coping and siblings expect that you and your DH will come to the rescue but do things on their terms (eg no care alarm/no change in accommodation etc). I'd recommend being clear at this stage about how much you are realistically willing to do. Siblings will probably be angry with you but it will be easier to deal with now than in a crisis.
  • Get a social care needs assessment and ask siblings to all attend, even if she would be self funding for any care, and be completely honest with them. I arranged this for Mum, but brother just said he was doing everything and 'we' would sort everything so no need for any external help. At the time I felt uncomfortable challenging this (knowing brother would react badly and Mum would be upset) but I think it would have been far better to get it all out in the open. Be calm, but if be prepared to ask questions about how siblings plan to do anything they claim they will do, and how they will manage the challenges you can see (eg not using a computer/drinking)
  • Sort out power of attorney if you haven't already, provided your mum has capacity (it sounds like she currently does). I would recommend taking legal advice on this- particularly if your siblings/mum suggest all having joint finance POA. Ask that everyone considers how it will work and check they understand the legal obligations.
Lifesabowlofcherries · 17/11/2026 11:39

I am the sensible one, but also the closest. The problem is my sister thinks I'm going to steal stuff and manipulate things to suit myself and doesn't trust me at all , so undermines everything I do. My mother is not nice to me at all so it's an uphill battle trying to do anything for her. She will be sweet as pie and then turn into a rottweiler with no provocation. I find her really upsetting and unpleasant to be around. It's a very difficult situation. Predictably I have a brother who does very little and he's only 20 miles away.

SpainToday · 17/11/2026 11:43

DH was the sensible child - but his father was on the south coast (and living in the same town as DH's sister, who is retired) and we're in the north east. There were often things like doctors appointments, where FIL would need help. but it would have been a whole day off work for DH, and 6 hours approx drive each way.

At one point, it was suggested that FIL spend each weekend with either DH or his sister. I don't think would have worked, even if both had been nearby, as FIL's needs were too great, but the initial plan was for DH to 'pop over' and collect his Dad on alternate Friday nights, 'nip him back' to ours (so 12 hour round trip with a dementia patient) provide 24/7 dementia care over the weekend, and the 'pop him back' on a Sunday night.

We got him into a home as soon as we could, which I know sounds awful but we were just too far away to be much help. I'm not saying that DH's sister should have done everything, but logistics were a nightmare.

HorseandHeron · 17/11/2026 11:48

OP, be careful making assumptions about the nearest siblings. It may not be 'much' right now, but if it is regular, it's tiresome. I was the nearest child to my elderly parents for ages - but not that near - an hour away. I am self employed and once worked out that I lost a month's income a year simply from being at their beck and call once or twice a week. Even small, not very taxing responsibilities add up. As does managing the increasingly troubling behaviour.

I can see both sides. They may be less competent, but they are there and it's only fair that everyone shares out the responsibility of her care. you all need to get together to discuss the next stage.

Casualuser · 17/11/2026 11:54

POA needs to be completed. How serious were the falls?

tooldforicy · 17/11/2026 12:41

HorseandHeron · 17/11/2026 11:48

OP, be careful making assumptions about the nearest siblings. It may not be 'much' right now, but if it is regular, it's tiresome. I was the nearest child to my elderly parents for ages - but not that near - an hour away. I am self employed and once worked out that I lost a month's income a year simply from being at their beck and call once or twice a week. Even small, not very taxing responsibilities add up. As does managing the increasingly troubling behaviour.

I can see both sides. They may be less competent, but they are there and it's only fair that everyone shares out the responsibility of her care. you all need to get together to discuss the next stage.

I agree that the small but frequent amounts of help are often very disruptive and underestimated.

OP- I suppose the big question really is whether your DHs siblings are willing/able to be sensible about your MILs needs and how they can be managed. If they are, and you can show a united front when MIL refuses things that would make her life easier then perhaps all that's needed is some time and information to get to grips with what she needs. In this case, the key will be to all discuss what's needed and for OP to do more of the tasks that can be done remotely.
If not, it's very difficult. I have a sibling living near to Mum who refuses to accept that she will ever need paid care and so is very angry that I can't/won't be there to physically help Mum more than I do (given than even 'just' popping in to help with something small always takes almost a full day including travel) and doesn't see any of the work done remotely (organising appointments, managing finances, household admin, multiple phone calls a day etc) as actually doing anything.

JadziaD · 17/11/2026 12:47

Mmm, if one can't use a computer then yes, I can see why you see him/her as less competent, but if they're the ones dealing with her day to day, I'm no tsure you can honestly say that their responses are not right. It can be very difficult to be the one dealing with an eldery and ill parent and often decisions you're making day to day are informed by a lot of emotional aspects that you, miles away, aren't necessarily experiencing.

DH sometimes come home from dealing with some issue with MIL and make some pronouncement about what is happening next that has me going "WTAF?" But with a bit of time on my part to understand, almost always, he has got himself into a bit of a situation because while these decisions were being made, he was also trying to help MIL practically, physically and emotionally. The benefit of course, is that he comes home to me and I don't have that emotional connection or the trauma of trying to ake decisions while she's literally unable to walk and I've just spent 45 minutes getting her into the doctor's surgery, but I'm also his wife, not his sibling, so we can have a sensible conversation and he might come up with a slightly new proposal and take it to his mum at the right time to get a good response.

TraitorOrFaithful · 17/11/2026 12:49

It's so frustrating isn't it OP. If she's already had a few falls, why on earth would she refuse to have a call alarm? Would she prefer the possibility of lying on the floor for hours until someone finds her?!

JadziaD · 17/11/2026 12:51

As an example for the above. MIL doesn't want the next step in medical care that she needs for her current medical condition. It's a no brainer - she absolutely, 100% has to have it because a) her condition has advanced and b) she doesn't look after herself. DH was in the appointment discussing it with her and doctor. She got upset, she was crying. They left. She was adamant. She got very upset. And as a result, her usual frailty got even worse. DH basically had to carry her into the house. And by the end of it, he's saying, "we're not goign to do this thing that the doctor says she absolutely must do" and he's saying it as if it's a completely obvious and acceptable choice. But he's been traumatised by the last 3 hours of his life and the drama and the crying and the physical response. Plus, she's his mother. she tells him she doesn't need the treatment because of x and y, and he believes her. She tells him it's NOT good treatment becuase of A and B and he doesn't know enough about it and he's used to believing her, so he does.

It's complicated.

MIL WILl be having the new treatment plan. She's not happy. But it will be happening. It's just taken a lot longer to get her to agree than I would have liked! Grin

walker1211 · 17/11/2026 16:40

DH has POA and is will trustee alongside another family member. Non sibling. I am not sure if other siblings are even aware of that but they are not capable of doing those roles.

how does this help now though?

the falls have not resulted in anything but a bit of bruising. She is generally strong and fit and certainly seems to have strong bones. But has has balance issues.

she also has fainted / collapsed once and went for a head scan. As DH was not there very difficult to know exactly what was discussed or seen on scan there other than she was released with no follow up.

OP posts:
catofglory · 17/11/2026 17:17

I think your last comment - that it is very difficult to know what is going on as you/your husband are not there - is extremely important.

If your MIL has had cognitive decline for years and now her short term memory is non-existent, it is very unlikely she is still able to live independently with little input. So either things are (unknown to you) falling apart, or other relatives are stepping in. My mother seemed to be coping 'okay' but if you spent a few days with her it was soon apparent she wasn't. Possibly BIL is 'angry' because things are a lot worse than DH realises.

Your DH has POA - both types? What he can do now depends on how they are set up, but he will be the one arranging care when the time comes. Nowadays it is easy to do this remotely, you don't need to live nearby. I didn't live near my mother but I arranged all her financial stuff online and organised carers for her. But what your husband does need is to know exactly what is going on, he can take BIL's word for it or he can visit and find out for himself.

tooldforicy · 18/11/2026 14:35

walker1211 · 17/11/2026 16:40

DH has POA and is will trustee alongside another family member. Non sibling. I am not sure if other siblings are even aware of that but they are not capable of doing those roles.

how does this help now though?

the falls have not resulted in anything but a bit of bruising. She is generally strong and fit and certainly seems to have strong bones. But has has balance issues.

she also has fainted / collapsed once and went for a head scan. As DH was not there very difficult to know exactly what was discussed or seen on scan there other than she was released with no follow up.

I'm sorry to say it, but as you've also mentioned cognitive decline this sounds very similar to how my DM was not long before her diagnosis of alzheimers and vascular dementia. In her case the balance issues are linked to these diseases. I think also sometimes reported 'falls' when in fact she just didn't feel right and/or couldn't remember what she was doing. I think this because there were absolutely no signs of any fall (not even a mark on her skin or knocked over items) in a situation where I can't see how someone could possibly fall without hitting something. The falls were certainly real to her, but I think they were 'confabulations'- where the patient's mind invents something to explain the situation. Mum also refused to have a falls alarm- I think simply because it was something new that she felt she wouldn't understand. Mum also had a head scan in A&E and we didn't receive any report from that directly but I now that it was reported on to her GP and used as part of the dementia assessment.

walker1211 · 18/11/2026 18:19

Thank you all. I do think she will be diagnosed with something similar to vascular dementia as her walking and balance has been off what a couple of years. I also think you are quite right that there is more going on. I think the lack of being able to talk it through well between the siblings is an issue also knowing my husband is probably a little in denial about what’s going on too. We

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page