Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Elderly rural ILs - is a hybrid phone or battery backup unit enough?

26 replies

trainedopossum · 15/11/2026 16:31

ILs live in a hamlet, can only get a mobile signal upstairs. MiL very disabled, uses a zimmer frame slowly and with difficulty, has a stairlift, can’t stand for any period of time. FiL very hearty and active but cracks starting to show with endless care, cooking, cleaning etc.

It occurred to us that they need some insurance (wind up radio, power packs etc) in case of extended power problems but we have never considered the phone issue until today. If the power goes off the landline will not work and if MiL needed to use the mobile to ring emergency services she’dhave to get herself upstairs, unless 999 will work without a signal?

BT haven’t offered anything despite ILs being on the vulnerable list.

We’ll make sure they have a way to use the landline but should something else be in place? I can’t work out if pendant alarms would be of any use if there’s no power.

OP posts:
Robertsmithsnan · 15/11/2026 16:33

How far away is family?
Given their exceptional care needs should you be looking at a more permanent solution, like a nursing home?

Hadalifeonce · 15/11/2026 16:33

If going digital, BT should supply a battery back up unit.

hellsbells99 · 15/11/2026 16:37

if it’s a modern pendant alarm then it should work as the base units have a SIM card in I think and this could be upstairs if the signal is better - I am sure this is what they said when they put my mums in.

Musicaltheatremum · 15/11/2026 16:38

My dad has a battery from BT for when his line went digital.

omz · 15/11/2026 16:42

999 usually works without a signal - there's another number too, 112, as an alternative to 999

If they have a personal alarm, that usually works on its own SIM card

It sounds like a tough situation but are they actually safe in their home?

trainedopossum · 15/11/2026 17:52

Thanks for quick replies ❤️
Closest family 2.5hrs away, although frequent visitors to the area so they’re around about a weekend every fortnight or so, often for long weekends and holidays.
Are they safe? Well it’s not an ideal situation and has evolved since MiL had a fall and serious injury. She is not safe as such, certainly at risk for falls. Will engage as little as possible with HCPs but occupational therapist has been and advised.
Both are very mentally sharp and very private. We have offered help but they have always refused.
Eta: Maybe I’m misunderstanding what is meant by safe. House is well maintained, clean and up to date, fresh food purchased and prepared regularly etc.

OP posts:
trainedopossum · 15/11/2026 17:56

Thanks for phone info, going to discuss with DH.

OP posts:
Apricothairy · 15/11/2026 21:09

The emergency cords are good, the best ones are mobile signal based but there a range that only rely on basic phone line

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 16/11/2026 08:19

I've not looked into the current situation, but I know when the digital switchover started the battery backups provided by BT were ridiculously low powered and only lasted something like an hour.

FortyFacedFuckers · 16/11/2026 08:23

Does your area provide an alert alarm pendant, the one provided has a roaming sim so looks for the strongest signal and a 48 hour battery back up

Pachycephalosaurus · 16/11/2026 08:28

In extended power cuts no standard comms are reliable anyway. We had a couple of 3-5 day power cuts last year and the mobile phone masts died both times (despite having extended battery capacity because they are part of the emergency services network). Nobody had any way to contact anyone EXCEPT if you still had a copper landline. The ones they are switching off next year.

So I would focus on getting your ILs some method of comms which will last a couple of days. Longer than that and nobody will be making any emergency calls so they'll be in the same boat as everyone else anyway.

trainedopossum · 16/11/2026 14:20

This is all super helpful, we don’t know what we don’t know and we’re concerned about rushing into a partial solution.
Also good for ILs to know what they’re up against, maybe it will shift their thinking around their current living situation.

OP posts:
Diddledeedo · 16/11/2026 14:38

I bought a wind up or solar powered radio with both USB and USB C ports so we can change phones, ipad and computer in the event of an extended outage. About £40 from Amazon.

Bandbros · 16/11/2026 14:41

I think most of us would be in trouble if we had an emergency during a power failure, especially anyone who lives alone. You can try and have things in place to mitigate risk, but you'll never remove them altogether.

Pachycephalosaurus · 16/11/2026 16:48

Diddledeedo · 16/11/2026 14:38

I bought a wind up or solar powered radio with both USB and USB C ports so we can change phones, ipad and computer in the event of an extended outage. About £40 from Amazon.

After a couple of days (at best) there won't be any power at the comms hubs anyway, so your wind up thingy can charge your devices all it likes but there won't be anything for them to connect to. Phone masts go down, and no power to fibre cabinets means your router won't work either, even if you can power it (and you'd need more oomph than a wind up device for that).
You'd have to do a lot of winding just to charge your phone enough for it to turn on anyway - I suppose you could probably get enough to send a text to 999 if you've signed up for that service?

alteredimage · 17/11/2026 08:56

There is a dodgy signal where we live, even though it is on the outskirts of a large town, and our newly installed fibre (fttc) broadband is very up and down. On the local WhatsApp it was surprising how many people had Starlink. A window I know, who I keep up with in part because she is increasingly vulnerable, told me she also has Starlink. Apparently all her neighbours on Dartmoor do and they helped her get it set up.

I know nothing about it, though have noticed prices are falling to a point where it starts to compete with other suppliers. The mobile set up would presumably come with batteries.

alteredimage · 17/11/2026 08:57

There is a dodgy signal where we live, even though it is on the outskirts of a large town, and our newly installed fibre (fttc) broadband is very up and down. On the local WhatsApp it was surprising how many people had Starlink. A window I know, who I keep up with in part because she is increasingly vulnerable, told me she also has Starlink. Apparently all her neighbours on Dartmoor do and they helped her get it set up.

I know nothing about it, though have noticed prices are falling to a point where it starts to compete with other suppliers. The mobile set up would presumably come with batteries.

trainedopossum · 17/11/2026 14:10

Thanks all.

DH had already ordered a wind up radio and charger for ILs and was going in circles with whether the signal issue will scupper all efforts with mobile devices. This is all very helpful.

To be clear I know I can’t eliminate risk, just as no one can eliminate risk in their life. The world has changed and ILs might not be aware of how vulnerable they are with limited phone access, I’m just trying to make sure we have appropriate measures in place. I live in a city and can reach dozens of people and services on foot if need be, ILs are in a very different situation.

OP posts:
Commonsenseisnotsocommon · 17/11/2026 14:23

Make sure they are registered on the priority services register with their electricity supplier. Won't do much but they'll be listed as vulnerable.

WhosGotTheKeysToMyBimma · 17/11/2026 14:48

This might be a bit overkill but you could consider battery storage and a gateway/switchover.

It would not be cheap, but people do save money on electric as they charge the battery overnight on cheap rate and then use the battery during the day.

Obviously most people would install solar as well, but battery only is totally valid and much cheaper (scaff is really expensive).

It would help to keep them safe in an extended power cut if they are careful with use.

trainedopossum · 17/11/2026 15:20

Commonsenseisnotsocommon · 17/11/2026 14:23

Make sure they are registered on the priority services register with their electricity supplier. Won't do much but they'll be listed as vulnerable.

Yes they’re already registered as vulnerable but afaik they haven’t been offered anything (battery etc) so when we’re next there we need to get in touch with BT.
They used to be notified if there was going to be interruption in the service but that seems to have stopped and I was wondering if that has failed somehow, if they’ve fallen off the list or something.

OP posts:
trainedopossum · 17/11/2026 15:22

WhosGotTheKeysToMyBimma · 17/11/2026 14:48

This might be a bit overkill but you could consider battery storage and a gateway/switchover.

It would not be cheap, but people do save money on electric as they charge the battery overnight on cheap rate and then use the battery during the day.

Obviously most people would install solar as well, but battery only is totally valid and much cheaper (scaff is really expensive).

It would help to keep them safe in an extended power cut if they are careful with use.

Thank you, will bring this up to DH. I suspect they won’t want to do that but again they need to know if they don’t want to change anything they’ll be at greater risk.

OP posts:
Diddledeedo · 17/11/2026 17:37

Pachycephalosaurus · 16/11/2026 16:48

After a couple of days (at best) there won't be any power at the comms hubs anyway, so your wind up thingy can charge your devices all it likes but there won't be anything for them to connect to. Phone masts go down, and no power to fibre cabinets means your router won't work either, even if you can power it (and you'd need more oomph than a wind up device for that).
You'd have to do a lot of winding just to charge your phone enough for it to turn on anyway - I suppose you could probably get enough to send a text to 999 if you've signed up for that service?

And your evidence is??
The main thing is to have a radio and anything that adds to phone battery life has to be a positive. Governments will continue to broadcast via radio even in the worst case scenario

Pachycephalosaurus · 17/11/2026 19:15

Diddledeedo · 17/11/2026 17:37

And your evidence is??
The main thing is to have a radio and anything that adds to phone battery life has to be a positive. Governments will continue to broadcast via radio even in the worst case scenario

My evidence for what?

For how much power wind up devices can generate in terms of actually charging a mobile phone? Just Google it.

Or for how long mobile phone masts keep working in a power cut? My evidence is two recent 3-5 day power cuts. The phone mast failed both times, and the phone masts in this area have much better battery back ups than many places because they have the emergency services contract. Other places will likely fail faster.

And yes, I know having a chargeable FM radio is very useful for knowing what's going on. But it won't help you make a 999 call, which was OP's question.