Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Has anyone else got a "difficult" parent who has gone quite sweet and gentle in very old age?

45 replies

CatLady476 · 10/11/2026 15:44

Here's a weird one: I have a historically very difficult parent - dominant, needy, neglectful, volatile, and sometimes emotionally abusive. A bit of a mess in other words. In their very old age, and with quite pronounced cognitive decline, they have gone quite sweet and gentle.

In some ways, I'm thankful - any more of the same would have made caring for them extremely difficult. But in another way, it's just...weird. I get left with the burden of all those unresolved issues, which they have now completely forgotten about.

They also want lots of hand holding and cuddling which, frankly, makes me very uncomfortable. This person left me in no doubt that I was not wanted in the slightest - and in fact, was bitterly resented. And now they want to be treated as if we have always had this super close loving relationship? It feels false and a bit creepy.

OP posts:
Redbags · 10/11/2026 15:47

CatLady476 · 10/11/2026 15:44

Here's a weird one: I have a historically very difficult parent - dominant, needy, neglectful, volatile, and sometimes emotionally abusive. A bit of a mess in other words. In their very old age, and with quite pronounced cognitive decline, they have gone quite sweet and gentle.

In some ways, I'm thankful - any more of the same would have made caring for them extremely difficult. But in another way, it's just...weird. I get left with the burden of all those unresolved issues, which they have now completely forgotten about.

They also want lots of hand holding and cuddling which, frankly, makes me very uncomfortable. This person left me in no doubt that I was not wanted in the slightest - and in fact, was bitterly resented. And now they want to be treated as if we have always had this super close loving relationship? It feels false and a bit creepy.

Interesting, but no. IME the nasty ones get nastier and the ones who were always lovely stay that way.

Ifyounevergiveup · 10/11/2026 16:05

Oh God, me too. I absolutely have this with my mother. Desperate for kids until she got some then realised it was my dad she loved and not us. Neglectful childhood of her own but repeated it with us (like “it’s my turn now” rather than trying to do any better). Turned me into a terribly anxious child, teenager, then adult, desperate to be “good” in the hope that affection would be forthcoming. My teen years were ok as she saw my friends and me as her friends rather than children with children’s needs, then she hit menopause and turned REALLY mean. Therapy in my late 50s helped me realise I was striving for the unattainable, she doesn’t know how to (and has no wish to) show affection for anyone except my dad. It was a whole new world for me.

Then she gets Alzheimer’s and turns nice.

I hate it. She asks for hugs and I have an almost physical reaction. I want to scream at her “what? You want affection between us now? The affection I desperately sought from you for decades? Too fucking late!” But what would be the point? She’d forget two seconds later. Her behaviour wouldn’t change. And I’d feel like I was the bully.

I have no answers. I desperately hope she dies before my dad but other than the Alzheimer’s she appears to be in rude health. She’s 86 now and I’m 60, the only sibling in the UK, but I refuse to get pulled closer to a woman whom I deeply dislike. I just hope I can keep up the good daughter pretence until she dies, if only for my dad’s sake. I see them once every six weeks and that’s it. Needless to say, however, she lives rent free in my head much of the time.

I have written this in as unvarnished a fashion as I can, to reassure you. You are not alone. It’s hideous. Thanks for reading what has turned into more of a vent than a post but I hope it helps. Hugs.

Ifyounevergiveup · 10/11/2026 16:06

PS thank you for posting this. I really am extremely grateful to know it’s not just me (although I’m sorry that it has to be anyone else!)

MotherOfCatBoy · 10/11/2026 16:09

Hm. Mine has been vile to me most of my life (little put downs, insults, never interested in my life, pretty much destroyed my confidence as a young girl, etc etc) and now (90) comes out with “I don’t know what we’d do without you” and a few other things like that. Not nice exactly (also told me she hated me recently during a meltdown over hoarding food waste) but more.. measured? Maybe she feels more dependent. Anyway, it feels weird so I know what you mean. Why couldn’t she have been nicer years ago?

CatLady476 · 10/11/2026 16:19

Mm - not just me then. YY to "Why couldn't you have been nicer years ago?" But honestly, I don't think it's some big change of heart, just cognitive decline and a kind of instinctive, childlike realisation of dependency. My heart goes out to you @Ifyounevergiveup - that sounds really tough. With therapy, my own strong physical reactions are now down to more manageable unease and discomfort. Kind of ewww rather than arrrgh! But I started off exactly the same as you. Big unMumsnetty hug - it's not easy whichever way this plays out, is it?

OP posts:
user99337611 · 10/11/2026 16:46

Interesting. My dad has always been difficult, demanding and needy, and in old age he still is, but the neediness is really affecting my life now. He is constantly on at me and won’t take no for an answer, playing the victim if I’m not available whenever he wants. He has no concept of the fact I’m busy and have my life, work, family, responsibilities. I hate it. It makes me furious because he was so neglectful towards me, and now that he suddenly wants me in his life he is constantly on at me.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 10/11/2026 16:52

Happened to my mum. Judgemental and very down on me, my brother was the golden child. But after she'd had a stroke and developed dementia she became a lot fonder of me; softer and far more approachable. I gave her the reassurance that I thought she needed but I kept my distance a little.

But it does mean that my last memories of her are more pleasant than the memories I have of her while I was growing up.

OneZanyMintQuoter · 10/11/2026 16:53

Yes it can definitely happen. Doubtful they will revert to their previous character. Its tricky but doubtful you can get closure, this is the new normal.

CatLady476 · 10/11/2026 17:15

If I could be sure that this was the "new normal" I think that would help. Part of me is waiting for the other shoe to drop.

OP posts:
BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 11/11/2026 16:10

Not to quite that extent, but yes.

My dad spent a lifetime complaining - about everything. My childhood was a constant refrain of muttered 'typical' and 'just my luck'. Hurricanes, cancelled flights, broken biscuits, aluminium foil that didn't tear properly, all were personal slights against him from a malign universe, and usually the trigger for a letter of complaint and demand for compensation. He was emotionally closed off. And then he got old, and ill, and became sweetness and light to all. Grateful for everything. Gushingly proud of me.

It was nice in a way, but profoundly disconcerting.

Lastknownaddress · 11/11/2026 16:28

CatLady476 · 10/11/2026 15:44

Here's a weird one: I have a historically very difficult parent - dominant, needy, neglectful, volatile, and sometimes emotionally abusive. A bit of a mess in other words. In their very old age, and with quite pronounced cognitive decline, they have gone quite sweet and gentle.

In some ways, I'm thankful - any more of the same would have made caring for them extremely difficult. But in another way, it's just...weird. I get left with the burden of all those unresolved issues, which they have now completely forgotten about.

They also want lots of hand holding and cuddling which, frankly, makes me very uncomfortable. This person left me in no doubt that I was not wanted in the slightest - and in fact, was bitterly resented. And now they want to be treated as if we have always had this super close loving relationship? It feels false and a bit creepy.

I was about to post and laugh, and say "if only", but your post made me stop and think.

My parent remains fractious and awful, even in advanced dementia. But at least there is an honesty in that. And when the world wants/seems to think I should be holding hands, sharing parent daughter moments, I can honestly say it isn't possible and know I am telling the truth.

It was harder with the other parent before they died. We reconciled and they had changed (addiction issues rather than dementia). I loved them deeply. But it didn't remove decades of hurt, and when they got closer to the end they wanted something more from me than I could give. They went knowing they were loved, but nothing could make up for the gap.

Sending 💐

GreenhouseSnail · 11/11/2026 18:00

This happened to my mother who died two weeks ago.
The way everyone talks about her makes me feel like they're talking about someone else.

She was NOT the sweet lovely old lady that everyone is telling me. I feel like screaming

Lastknownaddress · 11/11/2026 19:27

GreenhouseSnail · 11/11/2026 18:00

This happened to my mother who died two weeks ago.
The way everyone talks about her makes me feel like they're talking about someone else.

She was NOT the sweet lovely old lady that everyone is telling me. I feel like screaming

Someone said to me (might have been here to be fair) that people are like books.

Some folks only ever dip into a chapter, skip chapters or read the online synopsis. They can come away with a snapshot of the story, or jump to the wrong conclusion. Others read the whole book from cover to cover.

With a parent/child relationship you read the whole book - the good and the bad bits. You don't get chance to skip to end.

It won't stop you wanting to scream, but it does help me keep things in a little more perspective.

NattyKnitter116 · 11/11/2026 22:48

Yes my father was like this after his stroke but it only lasted two years then he reverted back to his old self. Now in cognitive decline and it’s started again. I can’t pretend so I just respond to him in a practical professional manner and avoid physical contact with an excuse like I’ve got a cold or something.

sadly my body remembers even if his brain doesn’t. If it wasn’t for my mum I’d be no contact and leave my sister to her delusion about who he is. I just keep it to low levels now and visit and take them out for lunch every 6-8 weeks. Text with mum most days. It’s sad but it has to be that way otherwise I get ill and I’ve got my own family to worry about.

Don’t feel guilty about how this affects you. It’s not your fault. Find a way to get through it that keeps you sane and healthy.

NattyKnitter116 · 11/11/2026 22:56

CatLady476 · 10/11/2026 16:19

Mm - not just me then. YY to "Why couldn't you have been nicer years ago?" But honestly, I don't think it's some big change of heart, just cognitive decline and a kind of instinctive, childlike realisation of dependency. My heart goes out to you @Ifyounevergiveup - that sounds really tough. With therapy, my own strong physical reactions are now down to more manageable unease and discomfort. Kind of ewww rather than arrrgh! But I started off exactly the same as you. Big unMumsnetty hug - it's not easy whichever way this plays out, is it?

That’s interesting. I had therapy and it helped me understand that I didn’t owe my father physical affection at the expense of my own health. Up to then I felt I was being unreasonable. Have to say I’m in a far better place mentally. I don’t think he’s noticed really as I always make sure I see him when my mum and OH are there so he’s distracted and entertained. My OH really does take one for the team in terms of keeping my dad separate from me. Means I can chat to my mum

oldmums · 11/11/2026 23:02

Yes my mother-in -law she was a very hard woman she made sure everyone did things her way or else there was hell to pay. Ignored some of her grandchildren fell out with most of her family at one time it another.
she got dementia and turned in to a little sweet woman, holding hands stroking you. What a change

JustaSongAboutPingPong · 12/11/2026 02:43

GreenhouseSnail · 11/11/2026 18:00

This happened to my mother who died two weeks ago.
The way everyone talks about her makes me feel like they're talking about someone else.

She was NOT the sweet lovely old lady that everyone is telling me. I feel like screaming

I totally get what you are talking about. My “D”M is still alive and my DDis lives quite close to her. She often has people tell her how lovely our Mum is. DSis usually says something like “Really? Well she does behave differ in public I suppose..”.

Totally get what you’re going through. Our M has now started to develop Dementia and the PP who mentioned an instinctive sense of being vulnerable struck me. It’s just a shake that she didn’t recognise they her own DC needed love and support when we were younger. We had food, when DF was around, a warm home and clothes but she was often angry, sometimes violent and has always bad-mouthed me to anyone who would listen.

It’s pretty hard to see her now fawning over me because she realises that ache needs me.

JustaSongAboutPingPong · 12/11/2026 02:51

NattyKnitter116 · 11/11/2026 22:48

Yes my father was like this after his stroke but it only lasted two years then he reverted back to his old self. Now in cognitive decline and it’s started again. I can’t pretend so I just respond to him in a practical professional manner and avoid physical contact with an excuse like I’ve got a cold or something.

sadly my body remembers even if his brain doesn’t. If it wasn’t for my mum I’d be no contact and leave my sister to her delusion about who he is. I just keep it to low levels now and visit and take them out for lunch every 6-8 weeks. Text with mum most days. It’s sad but it has to be that way otherwise I get ill and I’ve got my own family to worry about.

Don’t feel guilty about how this affects you. It’s not your fault. Find a way to get through it that keeps you sane and healthy.

It must be super hard if you and your DSis have a different view on your DF and his behaviour. That must be really tough.

My M has always had the Golden Child/Scapegoat dynamic with us and has enjoyed playing us off against each other for decades.

When our DF was dying we sat with him and talked a lot, realised what had been going on, she had basically been feeding us lies for as long as we can remember. We now shut her down if she starts to criticise the other Sister. She gets frustrated that her lies don’t have any effect and rants at her one DFriend but they are also beginning to distance themselves as her true nature becomes more apparent to them.

Reallynigel · 12/11/2026 03:15

@CatLady476 i’m sorry you’re going through this, I went through the same but also complicated by similar familial dynamics as others on this thread of the scapegoat/golden child (I was not the golden child). It was indeed the onset of dementia at the time and my exchange with the doctor about her cognitive decline was :
Dr - ‘why are you concerned?’
Me- ‘because she’s suddenly become nice’
The doctor was 🫤

Ironically I wanted to get dementia recorded on her notes to help her because the golden child at the time was helping themselves to her money…

It is very frustrating when you have unresolved issues but take comfort in the thought that if you are dealing with a narcissist they were never going to apologise for their behaviour ever. But the narcissist in them does mean they’ll play any role to get what they want- and right now your parent wants you to look after them. I opted to ‘do the right thing’ and help even though she didn’t deserve it and I did recognise the manipulation but it did mean my own conscience was clear. Do whatever makes it easy for you at this point - no one would blame you for walking away and anyone who would doesn’t know your full history.

Sending strength at this time. Caring is hard enough without this extra layer of complexity 💐

JustaSongAboutPingPong · 12/11/2026 03:26

Reallynigel · 12/11/2026 03:15

@CatLady476 i’m sorry you’re going through this, I went through the same but also complicated by similar familial dynamics as others on this thread of the scapegoat/golden child (I was not the golden child). It was indeed the onset of dementia at the time and my exchange with the doctor about her cognitive decline was :
Dr - ‘why are you concerned?’
Me- ‘because she’s suddenly become nice’
The doctor was 🫤

Ironically I wanted to get dementia recorded on her notes to help her because the golden child at the time was helping themselves to her money…

It is very frustrating when you have unresolved issues but take comfort in the thought that if you are dealing with a narcissist they were never going to apologise for their behaviour ever. But the narcissist in them does mean they’ll play any role to get what they want- and right now your parent wants you to look after them. I opted to ‘do the right thing’ and help even though she didn’t deserve it and I did recognise the manipulation but it did mean my own conscience was clear. Do whatever makes it easy for you at this point - no one would blame you for walking away and anyone who would doesn’t know your full history.

Sending strength at this time. Caring is hard enough without this extra layer of complexity 💐

This is exactly how I deal with it too @Reallynigel. It took me a long time to realise that whatever I did would be wrong and she has zero ability to reflect and alter her behaviour.

Like you say though, my conscience is clear.

Reallynigel · 12/11/2026 04:03

JustaSongAboutPingPong · 12/11/2026 03:26

This is exactly how I deal with it too @Reallynigel. It took me a long time to realise that whatever I did would be wrong and she has zero ability to reflect and alter her behaviour.

Like you say though, my conscience is clear.

Sending strength to you also 💐. My mother died over 4 years ago. These past 4 years have been the happiest I’ve had. I spent a lot of time grieving for the mother I should’ve had years ago so I only felt immense relief when she died - and satisfaction that my prediction that I would be the one at her bedside when she died (her worst nightmare). I correctly predicted the golden child would prioritise themselves over coming to sit with her became true. She always maintained this would never happen. Lo and behold, on the actual day, the golden child stopped for breakfast in the hospital before going to her bedside (we had both been told to come as soon as possible) and so wasn’t there.

On the upside, having a crap mother meant I became a better one myself. I often thought ‘what would my mother do in this situation?’ And then did the opposite. Every cloud and all that…!

notspringingback · 12/11/2026 04:35

Yes. My dad. He still drove me up the wall because he was forever asking me to do things for him to avoid a minuscule amount of inconvenience for himself but he became very sweet and grateful. It was odd really. More odd that he was drinking himself to death which obviously usually makes people very difficult.

I was grateful - he wasn’t bad enough in life for me to have cut all contact with him so it made the last few years of his life easier for me. I felt a lot of empathy for him and a lot of sadness. It was a pitiful end to life not well lived.

hattie43 · 12/11/2026 05:33

Mine is the same . She has been absent for most of my childhood preferring to abandon us and chase men . The times she was around she was the most hysterical volatile bully and made everyone’s lives a misery . Now she is old and frailer she still has a nasty tongue when she doesn’t get her own way or you say something she doesn’t like but outside of that and to others she’s mastered the sweet old lady routine . I think it’s manipulative so she gets the help she needs , more so in the future .

Artemis130 · 12/11/2026 06:14

Yes OP (and PPs) same with my mother. I really wasn't expecting it. I thought ageing might make the mask slip and people outside the immediate family would experience the person I'd been experiencing my whole life. I was quite looking forward to the validation of this tbh. But it's like illness has left her without the energy to manipulate and scheme and attack and I'm meeting the person underneath.

I won't ever fully trust this and let my guard down and be authentic with her but it's nice to just have a break from constant hyper-vigilance and trying to be ready to fend off attacks.It's nice to have a mother showing warmth towards me. It is sad I didn't meet this version earlier. I don't live near her so that makes it easier - I would find it very hard if she started wanting hugs. It's hard because I don't want her to be ill and in pain, I hope she can feel better again. But I'm worried the old her will resurface.

EleanorRigbyhat · 12/11/2026 06:29

My mother tries to be sweet and gentle because she knows she's vulnerable, but has become much nastier and more spiteful. I've never got on with her but she needs me as I'm the one living closest with the most free time. It's difficult for me as I dislike her intensely but feel an obligation to do something to help her. She veers from fake syrupy and false to downright horrible.