Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

How to tell if grammar school will suit a child

17 replies

Reluctantadult · 08/11/2026 17:13

I'm finding it really difficult to tell whether my dc would be better suited to a grammar school or a secondary modern. Dc has generally been Greater depth at school, with a few meeting expectations. Has a willing attitude and is putting in the work for the 11+, and is currently scoring 80%+ across the work done. So stands a decent chance. What I'm stuck on is working out whether they would be better in a school where all the kids are academically high, or one where they are more towards top of the class. Or a school where there are lots of opportunities but you need to put yourself forward, or one where there's less on offer but the teachers might give you a nudge. Or a school where learning pace is faster, versus one that makes sure you're grounded before moving on. How do you tell at age 9/10/11?! Feel like I need a crystal ball.

OP posts:
MaggieGlover · 08/11/2026 17:39

Bright children can thrive anywhere. My dd was greater depth all the way through primary, super bright. Studied for the 11+ all fine and just missed it on exam day. I felt confused and worried for her… as everything told me that was the right environment for her.
She went to the local good comprehensive, and is now in year 11. She’s flying; her self esteem is so high and her predicted grads are amazing.

She had a friend at primary school of similar academic level, who did go to grammar school and she’s getting similar grades to DD but instead of feeling great, she’s comparing herself to those getting A* and is struggling mentally.

overall, I’d say to not worry, DC can do so well in either place really. I’m sharing as I really worried when DD didn’t pass the 11+ and if I could go back I’d tell myself not to worry… so I’m passing this to you too.

Saturdaysfairies · 08/11/2026 17:41

MaggieGlover · 08/11/2026 17:39

Bright children can thrive anywhere. My dd was greater depth all the way through primary, super bright. Studied for the 11+ all fine and just missed it on exam day. I felt confused and worried for her… as everything told me that was the right environment for her.
She went to the local good comprehensive, and is now in year 11. She’s flying; her self esteem is so high and her predicted grads are amazing.

She had a friend at primary school of similar academic level, who did go to grammar school and she’s getting similar grades to DD but instead of feeling great, she’s comparing herself to those getting A* and is struggling mentally.

overall, I’d say to not worry, DC can do so well in either place really. I’m sharing as I really worried when DD didn’t pass the 11+ and if I could go back I’d tell myself not to worry… so I’m passing this to you too.

Some bright children thrieve everywhere. Not all.

Rocknrollstar · 08/11/2026 17:52

Ask the teacher. They will know.

Reluctantadult · 08/11/2026 17:59

Rocknrollstar · 08/11/2026 17:52

Ask the teacher. They will know.

They really don't offer an opinion, here.

OP posts:
thisismeithinkorisit · 08/11/2026 18:02

what kind of child are they?
are they competitive or do they struggle not being best? self motivated or need constant nudging? will they be happy in a single sex environment? how does the travel compare? the extra curriculars?

ThisNiftyMember · 08/11/2026 18:07

Some children really do better where they are near rhe top of the academic ability. Being in thr lower sets of a Grammar school can be very dispiriting. My aunt was initially devastated when her daughter just missed a Grammar place. Now the child is thriving in the top sets. The child's friend at Grammar is hating being in the lower sets. I suspect my cousin may end up with the higher GCSE results.

PrincessOfPreschool · 08/11/2026 18:21

I think it very much depends on the child. My DC went to a low achieving school where they were amongst the highest achievers (did vv well) and it was wonderful for their confidence. That type of school also meant teaching was very good - it has to be just to engage the kids, though classroom behaviour not great so it's swings and roundabouts. One of them has now moved to a v academically competitive sixth form and that's also been v good for him. It would have been terrible for my other DC who has stayed at the school.

My eldest DS1 went to a more academic school all the way through. He was always in the lower middle and had v low confidence. I wish I had sent him to my younger DC's school but his school had such a good reputation, higher achieving, better behaved children. He was basically overlooked for 6 years and teachers were not great, relying on parents getting tutoring, didn't do much to engage the kids. DS1 would have been close to the top at the lower attaining school and also his good behaviour and attitude of trying hard would have been noticed and celebrated, which would have done wonders for his self esteem.

Only you know your child well, how sensitive they are, how competitive etc. Some kids need a kick up the bum (DS2) and others need nurturing and encouragement (DS1).

Reluctantadult · 08/11/2026 18:30

I agree with posters saying it depends on the child. It's quite ridiculous to me that as the mother, I can't tell!

Dc is generally quite chill, can take a back seat, sometimes gets upset at getting things wrong, is prepared to put work in, does a range of clubs, also likes to chill at home, has interesting interests, like history, gaming, myths, has a broad and deep knowledge of things they are into... generally pretty amenable and nice.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 08/11/2026 19:04

If your child is happy within himself, has a curious and open mind, and willingness to work without being prodded, I'd choose the grammar.

Has your son visited the schools you're considering?

Pigsmightfly31 · 08/11/2026 19:09

mathanxiety · 08/11/2026 19:04

If your child is happy within himself, has a curious and open mind, and willingness to work without being prodded, I'd choose the grammar.

Has your son visited the schools you're considering?

This… I was typing the same thing.. if your child is a self starter and keen to learn then he’ll likely do well at grammar. Both my DC went to grammar and loved the “energy” of school… something always happening somewhere (clubs etc), being pushed (and expected to) always achieve highly and get stuck in.

LetItGoToRuin · 11/11/2026 16:00

When you say Grammar vs Secondary Modern, I assume you mean you're in a fully grammar area where pretty much all children take the 11 plus (eg Kent or Bucks.) A few other areas have some grammars but there are fewer of them relative to the other secondaries so they have less impact on the intake at the other schools. Eg Birmingham, where most children don't take the 11 plus and ~95% go to non-grammars which are therefore considered to be Comprehensives.

If you're in Kent or Bucks, it does sound as though your DC would suit a grammar. Elsewhere, it doesn't matter so much as long as their secondary school is decent.

Lbcde · 11/11/2026 16:03

Isn’t that what the 11+ selection process is for? If she passes then I would assume that grammar school is the right fit for her.

Besidemyselfwithworry · 11/11/2026 16:07

Lbcde · 11/11/2026 16:03

Isn’t that what the 11+ selection process is for? If she passes then I would assume that grammar school is the right fit for her.

My daughter did the 11+ for the experience really as she had friends doing it but although she passed it isn’t right for her at all!

it’s very very pressured at our local grammar and the volume of homework and stuff is beyond mental - I’ve known afew start and then leave to go to a comprehensive!

bingoringos · 11/11/2026 16:10

I think it depends where you are, my dc would suit some grammars but the not the London ones

Reluctantadult · 11/11/2026 16:42

@LetItGoToRuin

No, it's not a full grammar area and most kids will not take the 11+.

I've been 'told off' on here before for saying comprehensive, when apparently I meant secondary modern. Possibly i was right the first time then!

OP posts:
OffTheMap · 11/11/2026 21:41

Check what’s on offer at the ‘high school’.

Can they do full triple science? What MFL?

LostMySocks · 11/11/2026 21:52

Visit both the comps and Grammars and see which you and she prefer.
There are grammars and super selective grammars.
DS is at a grammar and loving it. He loves learning and is bright but not super clever. Grammar means that he has a wider range of subjects than our local comp which suits him.
Younger DS is very clever but more keen on playing with his friends. Im hoping he passes 11+ as he's also very competitive as I think in a big comp the risk is that he'll coast and mess around. I dont want him in a super selective as he'd prefer his clubs to the work for a couple of extra gcses.
Maybe continue with a sensible level of prep, register for the exams amd see how you feel after the exams. Present it as another option giving more choice rather than the be all and end all

New posts on this thread. Refresh page