I think for a start off a child doesn't have to have problems to be a bully. It's just as likely they're spoilt rotten by parents and never heard the word "no".
So I don't think automatically going to mental support classes for the bully should be the default. There may be times when there is some background knowledge makes it an appropriate way to go, but not a lot of the time.
It is a tough one to deal with - especially now crying "bully" is very emotive and can be used in bullying itself. You've also got children/parents accusing others of bullying because they haven't got their own way, or when actions have been mutual.
But also bullies can be very manipulative. Sometimes a teacher nods away "I'm not surprised" when told; other times their jaw drops open and they say "really? But they're so nice!" Because even quite young children are capable of changing their behaviour if they know they may be picked up on it. In a lot of ways, I think this is worse because it shows without a doubt that they know what they're doing is wrong - but it can be very hard to actually deal with because if they're never seen doing it by anyone with authority/will pick they up on it, then you are having to take someone's word for it, and see the previous paragraph!
I think the other issue, perhaps more at secondary age, is the "be kind". I wonder how often consequences are held back because we "have to give the benefit of the doubt" or "they didn't mean to" or even "they're just so upset"? I suspect a lot of the time.
So you have everything from the victim comes forward after a minor dispute which was mutual and says they're deeply traumatised, through to the situation where the victim has come forward after months of really nasty stuff and what they tell is the tip of the iceberg. But you can't tell the difference unless you have witnessed it.
And there is a crux of the issue. A child accused wrongly is very damaging to them. A child who is bullied is equally damaged. It can be impossible to tell if the bullying is very underground which it is.
For me the important things are:
- Listen to the child and what they're saying. Let them talk rather than asking leading questions. See if there are witnesses (but be aware that people don't always stand up when it matters) or evidence. Is there a pattern to it? How are others reacting round them?
- Watch with an open mind. I was in a situation last year (adults) where I asked someone to watch out for what I believed was a bullying situation. The person told me that I'd imagined it, and they "hadn't a malicious bone in their body". The following week they came back to me and said I was right.
- If you can make out to the bully that they have been seen and reported by another, then it's much better. Because that takes the "you told on me" away. It also means that they're aware that others may report them in future so they have to watch their actions.
- Yes, the bully needs to have consequences. Yes, they may be uncomfortable, or upset, but letting them get away only teaches them that they can do it and it doesn't matter.
- And follow up. Check in with the child regularly. Make sure they feel they can come back to you, they have a safe space or if anything is said, then you want to know. And keep on checking in, be it a month later. Keep watching - is the child playing nicely with the bully now, is the bully making a bee line for them when they're on their own, are other children playing with them. Just little things that can show how things are going.
- And overall compliment kind behaviour as a general thing. "I liked watching you clear up because I saw Jane helping Harry with the paper, and thank you Mark for picking up Tom's paper when he spilt the water."