Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

DD didn't get the qualifying score but did better at HBS exam

12 replies

SRKMC · 17/10/2026 19:08

Hello all a bit stuck my DD didn't get the right marks to get through the grammar schools but is achieving greater depth at school in maths and English. Is it worth to put on the CAF and then lodge an appeal? We have evidence of her not being well on that day and head teachers letter she also did better scoring 220 at HBS exam although didn't get through but is it worth it and will it help her secure a place before September 2027? She has independent exams coming up and this has been stressful. Any tips guidance will be great and also does anyone know how London Consortium school cut off marks are for each school, what marks are needed for each school? Same as Highgate, St Paul's, NLCS, Habs and STAGS and Queenswood and St Edmunds, these are all the ones she chose as she likes them. Any advise, guidance will be so appreciated. Just so I'm mentally prepared if she doesn't make it through.

OP posts:
MarchingFrogs · 17/10/2026 20:35

There's nothing to stop you naming the school as a preference and appealing when inevitably turned down, but tbh if nothing else, your appeal will likely get stuck at the statement We have evidence of her not being well on that day, especially if, like many / most selective schools, HBS tells parents that by allowing their DC to sit the exam on the day, they are stating that they are 'fit and well'.
Eta the FAQs do address this issue
https://henrietta-barnett.ams3.digitaloceanspaces.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/29122129/Admission-FAQs-2026.pdf

https://henrietta-barnett.ams3.digitaloceanspaces.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/29122129/Admission-FAQs-2026.pdf

LIZS · 17/10/2026 21:08

If she wasn’t well there would have been a process for you to follow at the time of the exam sitting, not after the event. HT appeals are normally resolved before results are released. All those passing are likely to be relatively high achievers so not sure your argument will stand up to scrutiny at appeal on its own.

Minorie · 21/10/2026 03:57

@SRKMC do you mean your DD got those scores for round 1? The cut off was around 346 I believe. You could try but I didnt find HB that responsive generally for any of my questions. I just think they have such a high volume of applicants that they dont need to be flexible/understanding.

NLCS and SPGS are some of the top girls schools in the country, then the others which are much more doable. I would have thought Habs and Queenswood are a bit easier to get into these days as have a big intake. I dont think that they discuss pass marks though, and put a lot of focus on the whole process including the interview.

Id just draw a line under HB and focus on the indies. You can only try your best and hope your DD gets into the right school for her.

dizzydizzydizzy · 21/10/2026 12:58

I know it stings but it’s most probably best to put it behind you. DC1 failed the 11+ and was not even close to a pass. I knew at the time that this was wrong. Anyway DC1 went to the local
comprehensive, was very happy there and only had
a 10-minute journey. Academically, they did brilliantly- mostly 9s at GCSE and 4 x Astar at A-Level. Did spectacularly well at uni too and now working full time in a good job.

PinkMicrowave · 21/10/2026 13:03

I'm confused by your post, do you mean is it worth naming/appealing HBS even though she didn't get the qualifying mark, or appealing for a different grammar on the grounds that she did well in the HBS exam?

If it's the first then no, it would be a waste of time as the school is extremely competitive to get into and the illness process would have needed to be followed at the time.

SRKMC · 21/10/2026 16:15

@Minorie yes she got 316 so much far away from 344 which was the cut off mark. I just wondering whether it is worth even putting on the CAF form or not. She also missed the South West Herts exam by 17 marks as she is outer area and wondering whether to put the watford girls grammar school down on the caf and then appeal later or if it will be a waste of CAF space? Any guidance, input will be great to know.

OP posts:
SRKMC · 21/10/2026 16:18

@PinkMicrowave Yes she missed both HBS and SWHerts, but SWHerts by 17 marks as she is an outer area applicant. Just wanted to get an idea if it is worth putting on the CAF and then appealing or not. She has good outstanding comprehensives but again we are not in the catchment or priority area.

OP posts:
MyPoisedRedFatball · 21/10/2026 17:00

I think that using up spaces on the CAF with schools she has little chance of getting means you will be restricting your options for other schools. You need to put one that you are certain to get in to on distance because otherwise you could end up being offered an equally undesirable school on the other side if town or borough.

clary · 21/10/2026 19:57

How many spaces do you have on the CAF @SRKMC ? If it's six then I guess nothing much lost by putting one of the grammar schools on.I can't see what your appeal grounds are though. Also you might want to consider that if she is well below the pass score, whether the grammar school is the best place for her. What are your most local options like?

SRKMC · 21/10/2026 20:28

@clary have 4 spaces and local schools are goffs academy, the broxbourne but other side she scored on the aptitude 39 so not sure if she would get a place there but she scored 75 on the goffs aptitude. She does like Presdales but again we are not in priority area. We have until 1st december which is the absolute final deadline to move in any priority area for the HCC to consider as main address for march offers.

OP posts:
Sheshares · 24/10/2026 18:24

I'm sorry, that's a hard one after all her work. 316 is still a strong score and shows she's very capable. If you're looking at independents, most look at the whole picture (written test, interview and school reference) rather than one cut-off, so a near miss on a grammar test doesn't rule her out. The jump from grammar papers to independent tests is mostly in the extended writing and in being able to talk through her thinking at interview, and both improve quickly with practice. Feel free to message if you'd like to talk through options.

SRKMC · 24/10/2026 21:32

@Sheshares thank you, yes we decided to forget the grammar route not worth appealing. She will be sitting exams at Queenswood school, London Consortium (one exam and there's 14 day schools to choose from but based on the ones I registered) Highgate, Habs girls, St Alban's girls and NLCS. Please PM me for any info, tips and guidance would greatly appreciate it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page