Active discussions

Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Original poster

So apparently dd (6.5) is starting piano lessons and I have to buy a piano !

45 replies

LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 20:46

And although I did have lessons back when I was at school, and although technically I own a Bentley, I am now going to have to buy a piano !!

Have been looking on ebay and have contacted a local chap - who has suggested 3 to me, costing £900, £750 and £450 - whilst I was thinking of more like £150 !!!

So the question is - how does a non musical person like me find a cheap but good piano (that also goes with the decor !) and not get ripped off ?

(PS. The thing about the Bentley - my mother supposedly bought it me for Xmas when I was about 15 - but now she says its hers as I never paid any interest - and she occasionally plays it !)

OP posts:
christywhisty · 04/07/2007 20:49

You don't need to buy a paino to start with. I good touch sensitive organ with 61 keys (i think) is all you need.

fingerwoman · 04/07/2007 20:49

ok well why not talk to your mum and see if you can have the bentley for your dd?
we have a ymca furniture charity shop thingy near here and it always seems to have pianos in for around £150-£200

moo · 04/07/2007 20:49

There is no way I would buy a piano for a 6 year old who (have I got this right?) hasn't even started lessons yet. She might hate it!

christywhisty · 04/07/2007 20:49

I need to read what I write first

that should be "piano" and A not I

Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 20:51

Well - school says she can only have lessons if she has a piano at home - and I have to sign to say she will do 15 mins practice every day.

To be honest I don't see how you can start lessons without a piano - but anyway that's not the question is it.

OP posts:
Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 20:52

Mother has already said I can't have it until she is dead - don't tempt me eh ?

OP posts:
slondonmum · 04/07/2007 20:52

Be careful don't get an old Joanna get something decent. Anything really cheap, be careful! You may have to pay to get someone to take it away. We got one from a woman a couple of streets away (she stuck a notice in the local newsagents) paid about £400 for it. I searched the make on google and found I got a good deal the piano tuner said it was worth twice that. If you really want to be sure, you could pay a piano tuner to give it the once over.

Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 20:55

That's what I'm worried about really. The local chap said he could keep an eye out for an old one for me - and he is a tuner/restorer etc of good reputation - so maybe via him will be the safest way to go ?

OP posts:
slondonmum · 04/07/2007 20:57

He sounds a good bet in my opinion. I personally think you need a piano - keyboards just don't sound the same. I am sure your child will enjoy playing it. My DD plays both the violin and piano, and we found she picked the piano up much quicker. Also doesn't take long to sound quite good!

MorocconOil · 04/07/2007 21:00

You can hire pianos from some piano shops, then if you decide to buy one they will knock the amount you rented it for off price if you buy one.

Our DS started at 6. He's now 7 and wants to give up, but we are making him carry on. I wish we'd waited a year or so before starting him.

Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 21:00

She always makes a beeline for everyone elses piano - so I am sure she will be enthusiastic - just not convinced she will keep it up ! Hence I really don't want to spend a lot !

Yes - I will ask local chap to keep an eye out for an old and cheap one for me ! He at least will know what he is looking at and also he delivers and tunes - whereas with ebay it's pot luck and you have to organise someone to collect as well !

Thanks for your advice !

OP posts:
fannyannie · 04/07/2007 21:01

definitely get a piano rather than a keyboard (although a touch sensitive electric piano would be just as good).

fannyannie · 04/07/2007 21:04

where abouts are you in the country Lucy??

Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 21:04

School said that if we get electric one the keys must be weighted - not too sure what I'd be looking for though.

OP posts:
Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 21:05

Hampshire/Berkshire borders

OP posts:
fannyannie · 04/07/2007 21:10

ahh - a bit too far from me - otherwise I would have sold you my upright - it's a lovely piano, badly needs tuning (been moved - house - twice and not done yet) and has a few scratched in "hyroglyphics" courtesy of DS2 along the front but nothing major that needs doing to it.....

If you go for Electric basically what you need is one that plays notes quietlly if you press gently, and loudly if you press hard - whereas most keyboards it's the same volume no matter how hard you press

cheechymunchy · 04/07/2007 21:11

Hi LucyLamb, I'm a degree-trained pianist that used to sell them too. Please don't go down the route of 61 note keyboard. Go for the local gentleman's advice. The worst thing is picking up a £100 "bargain" from the local paper to find that it's an iron-framed hunk of junk that's been left for so long that the tuning frame will need a complete rehaul. Many pianos are just beyond repair. This man should be able to locate an old piano that will need some, but not too much work. Besides, they look so much nicer than keyboards to put your photos on!

Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 21:13

Oh thanks fanny - that would have been good ! Never mind - I will brief the local chappie to find me a very cheap one ! Problem is I am so picky about furniture etc !

OP posts:
potoroo · 04/07/2007 21:13

LL - there's a few places that will let you hire first. Then if you decide to purchase they take off the amount you have already paid (even if it is on a different piano).

There's definitely a place in Reading that I have been too.

Also, if you get a digital piano, be aware that unless you fork out for a touch sensitive/weighted keys one, they will have a different feel to a real piano.

The AMEB (Australian Music Exam Board) website has a list of digital pianos that they allow for the first few exams - good starting reference.

Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 21:14

Thanks cheechy - I'll do that !

I am sure I would land myself with a complete dinosaur if I tried to find one independently !

OP posts:
Original poster
LucyLamb · 04/07/2007 21:17

thanks potoroo - are the hire places selling just new pianos though ? I am horrified how expensive new ones are - so even if they take the rental off I probably still couldn't afford a new one !

OP posts:
littlefrog · 06/07/2007 12:45

how about looking on freecycle? there have been a lot of pianos on our local one - no idea about the quality though, and of course you need to transport it...

ib · 06/07/2007 12:59

dh plays a lot and says a keyboard weighted electric is fine for practising, plus has the advantage that you can use it with headphones so don't need to drive everyone nuts when you are working on a particular passage, and they can be stored in a cupboard when not in use. The yamaha dcx series are keyboard weighted I believe.

Then, if she gets really into it, you can buy her a good one.

portonovo · 06/07/2007 14:06

We bought this digital piano from this Ebay seller.
Excellent service, arrived within a few days. It is fully-weighted, touch-sensitive etc. My daughter gets on really well with it - she is used to playing different pianos in her lessons etc and says it doesn't feel too different.

We got it because of lack of space, and yes, so she could practise with headphones on!

singingmum · 06/07/2007 14:10

LucyLamb a keyboard will do for the first year or 2.My son plays and has only had a piano for about 2/3 yrs and has been learning for about 6.You can pick up a pretty decent keyboard second hand these days and then buy a piano only when you know that your dc will continue and is serious.This was the advice we were given by the piano teacher.