Shrewsbury or Rugby Schools?

[AVY3]

We have visited both schools and are really stuck over which one to choose for our boy and girl.
Both provide co-ed, full boarding which is what we are looking for.
We have some pros and cons for both schools. Anyone have any recent experience with either school?

This might get more replies in secondary education.

I don’t have first hand experience, but my friend has had 2 DC go to Rugby and was very happy and so were the DC. One academic and one less so. It catered for both.