Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Divorce/separation

Here you'll find divorce help and support from other Mners. For legal advice, you may find Advice Now guides useful.

Should I consider separation or try harder to fix our marriage?

9 replies

Piggel · 03/09/2026 12:12

Sorry in advance for the long post!

I have no idea where to begin with divorce. My parents were two people who absolutely should have separated but didn’t, and my childhood was miserable because of it. I’m terrified of making the wrong decision for my own children.

I’ve been with my husband since 2017 and married since 2021. We have a 4-year-old about to start school and a 2.5-year-old. We’ve been under huge strain for the past few years. Introducing a second child has been particularly challenging, and although he’s doing well developmentally (we’ve had health visitor and Toddler Talk assessments and they have no concerns), the exhaustion of parenting two young children has really affected our relationship.

We also moved closer to my husband’s parents when I was pregnant with DS2, expecting more support. They do pick the children up from nursery once a week and help in emergencies, but otherwise the support is limited. FIL is very hands-off and most of the childcare falls on MIL, which my husband himself finds frustrating.

His parents have also made various passive-aggressive comments over the years which I’ve largely ignored. However, something happened on Monday which has really tipped me over the edge.
DS2 had been overtired and was crying. FIL put on his noise-cancelling headphones and carried on playing his Switch. Later, he started asking my husband whether we had compared DS2’s development to DS1’s and whether we had videos/photos to benchmark them against each other.

This really upset me because his parents know we’ve already sought professional advice about DS2’s speech and that everyone is happy with his progress. It felt less like genuine concern and more like frustration that DS2 isn’t where FIL thinks he should be.

What hurt me most was that my husband didn’t shut the conversation down. Instead, he engaged with it and then brought me into it by asking whether I had any videos. I eventually said, quite bluntly, that we had discussed this extensively, that we had sought professional advice and that there was no point comparing the two children.
It resulted in an argument between me and my husband afterwards. I was trying to explain that I felt unsupported and, once again, put in a position where I’m made to look rude for setting a boundary with his parents. He thinks I’m being overly sensitive and that there was nothing wrong with the conversation.

This has happened several times now. I feel like I’m constantly being put in situations where I feel undermined by his parents, and my husband won’t stand beside me. I’m not asking him to cut them off or choose between us. I just want him to recognise when something is inappropriate, redirect the conversation and support me.

I’ve been incredibly unhappy for a while. My husband wants us to work on our relationship, and I’ve wanted that too, but the actual work never seems to happen. Something has changed in me over the past couple of days. I’m exhausted from pretending everything is fine and sweeping things under the carpet.

I know this incident sounds insignificant in isolation, but it genuinely feels like the straw that broke the camel’s back. Pre-kids we had a wonderful relationship, and even after DS1 things were good. DS2 pushed us both to our limits, and I think we’re now at the point where we’re surviving rather than actually being a couple.

I’m just so tired. I don’t want my children growing up watching two unhappy people stay together because they’re scared to leave. I would much rather they had two happy parents in two homes than two miserable parents under one roof.
But equally, this doesn’t feel like a “good enough” reason to end a marriage, and I don’t know whether I’m throwing away something that could still be fixed.

Has anyone been in a similar situation? Did you manage to turn things around, or did you ultimately call it a day? I honestly don’t know what to do anymore. I just want to be happy again.

OP posts:
AbzMoz · 03/09/2026 13:59

It sounds like the pils are more hassle than benefit so put that on pause now nursery etc has resumed?
Your relationship with DH is separate and need to be addressed separately. I think either working on it and counselling, or distance and separation are both valid options, but I’d give yourself the distance and perspective on your specific relationship first. Youve both (but especially you?) been under a lot of stress with the uncertainty around dc2 in particular. You don’t have to decide on the outcome before you address the coparenting/support challenges.

Livingmagicallyagain · 03/09/2026 14:04

Seek out an Emptionally Focussed Therapy counsellor (not Emotion Focusssd Therapy). Work on your marriage. I won’t say more but what you’re going through is very common.

DallasMajor · 03/09/2026 14:12

Pre-kids we had a wonderful relationship, and even after DS1 things were good. DS2 pushed us both to our limits

I would much rather they had two happy parents in two homes than two miserable parents under one roof.

Why do you think you would be less exhausted being a single parent with two children and all the responsibility (I'm sure your husband would have them- but when with you there would be no other help, everything would be down to you)

Wanting support from parents is double edged, you get the help they want to give, plus their thoughts and opinions - it isn't always worth it.

Just grey rock them- why do you let it bother you so much- I'm not saying it is easy to grey rock, but when you really think about it, does it matter what they are saying?

There is a reason why things are difficult, you are still in the trenches- I think it would be a shame to leave what was a wonderful relationship - based on what you have posted.

FloydPink · 03/09/2026 16:30

At the risk of sounding blunt, this is why so many marriages fail - because people think the grass in greener and they dont want to work at something.

If you want to lose 5 stone you have to work hard and be disciplined. Same to learn a language. To have a good marriage you need to work at it too. It sounds like you have said you both would but not actually done anything about it. Separating will just increase your workload and think your kids would resent you more.

You need to speak to relate. Work on this together, and make effort to help each other out, give time for and to each other and have time together yourselves - so you can go out for drinks or film and forget you have a couple of kids.

The IL - I tried the confrontational approach and didnt work - so just ignored them. FIL was a complete arse anyway so just ignored everything he said.

Endoadnowarrior · 06/09/2026 23:33

Is FIL coming from the angle that he maybe thinks he himself might be ND, therefore DS2 might be?
Just thinking, the impolite questions/bluntness, the noise cancelling headphones?

Maybe I am being generous though and he's just your garden variety, old fashioned selfish bloke of a certain age!?

Personally, i think you need to give yourselves a break, metaphorically speaking at least if literally isnt possible. 2 kids under 5 had a massive impact on my physical and mh and the relationship with my then DH really struggled until they were both at school to be honest.

You do BOTH need to be aware of this though and be committed to keep working together as a team, and making time for caring/showing appreciation and affection for each other in even the smallest of ways. The spark and the fun doesnt have to be lost forever, just on pause for now.

Me and ex didnt do this unfortunately, or rather we took it in turns of being unable or unwilling to for another 10 years before splitting and divorcing

That said, we are NOW great friends and cop-arents (ive just commented about this on the positive separation stories post) so there you go!

Hall84 · 06/09/2026 23:40

FloydPink · 03/09/2026 16:30

At the risk of sounding blunt, this is why so many marriages fail - because people think the grass in greener and they dont want to work at something.

If you want to lose 5 stone you have to work hard and be disciplined. Same to learn a language. To have a good marriage you need to work at it too. It sounds like you have said you both would but not actually done anything about it. Separating will just increase your workload and think your kids would resent you more.

You need to speak to relate. Work on this together, and make effort to help each other out, give time for and to each other and have time together yourselves - so you can go out for drinks or film and forget you have a couple of kids.

The IL - I tried the confrontational approach and didnt work - so just ignored them. FIL was a complete arse anyway so just ignored everything he said.

Separating doesn't always increase your workload.
Good luck OP.

FloydPink · 07/09/2026 12:16

Hall84 · 06/09/2026 23:40

Separating doesn't always increase your workload.
Good luck OP.

For me - at 50/50 it does.

I have a house to maintain all by myself - in a relationship that is halved (or one may do cooking, one washing up etc...).

You also have the fact that your bills will go up, it really doesn't change the gas/electric having a partner, nor the insurances etc..

Hall84 · 07/09/2026 17:42

FloydPink · 07/09/2026 12:16

For me - at 50/50 it does.

I have a house to maintain all by myself - in a relationship that is halved (or one may do cooking, one washing up etc...).

You also have the fact that your bills will go up, it really doesn't change the gas/electric having a partner, nor the insurances etc..

In an ideal world domestic labour/childcare is split 50/50.
The only things XH did for the house were empty the bins and put petrol in the car. I maintain that I have less to do without him in the house because whilst I am still looking after it I am not cooking/cleaning after another grown adult.

FloydPink · 07/09/2026 19:10

Hall84 · 07/09/2026 17:42

In an ideal world domestic labour/childcare is split 50/50.
The only things XH did for the house were empty the bins and put petrol in the car. I maintain that I have less to do without him in the house because whilst I am still looking after it I am not cooking/cleaning after another grown adult.

Ah, for me it was 50/50 ish. Although more specific jobs like I did all food shop, cooking, gardening, she did all bathrooms, most housework & laundry. So yeah, guess it depends what you are coming from.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread