Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

What does the blue wave mean for the relationship between the US and Israel?

28 replies

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2026 01:45

Progressives everywhere in the US since the midterms. Most of whom have a very different view of the relationship than the old guard. Trump was signalling the end of the flow of money possibly in a last ditch attempt to stop the wave.

They are getting ready to oust Chuck Schumer who is very pro Israel. The democratic voters feel very differently to the democratic party as was.

Interesting times.

OP posts:
RedTagAlan · 08/11/2026 03:25

Not sure if I would say that it is Progressives everywhere. It's too early to tell I think if there is a shift in the Democratic Party towards such things as Universal Health etc.

Was this not more of a vote against Trumpism ?

mids2019 · 08/11/2026 05:26

I agree that this was a massive protest vote against Trump primarily due to cost of living and perception of corruption . Trumps bizarre announcement about military funding to Israel was done out of a for of pique and I do not think suddenly the USA has become a sea of pro Palestinians.

RedTagAlan · 08/11/2026 05:47

mids2019 · 08/11/2026 05:26

I agree that this was a massive protest vote against Trump primarily due to cost of living and perception of corruption . Trumps bizarre announcement about military funding to Israel was done out of a for of pique and I do not think suddenly the USA has become a sea of pro Palestinians.

There will be loads of pro Palastinians. Many, if not most of them will also be pro Israel too, at the same time. Same as I am.

Being against the actions of Netanyahu does not make one automatically anti Israel/pro Palastinian.

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 05:55

A lot of people seem to be complaining about cost of living etc more than anything else tbh. I did see a some stuff about cutting “aid” to Israel (spent in the USA so more of a sub to arms manufacturers about 4 billion) but then saw El-Sayyed say he wants to being back USAID which is about 40 billion (which I doubt will be popular because he just told a bunch of people they can’t afford their weekly shop because of aid to israel).

Also the Israelis and the USA have already said they are planning to be completely independent of the USA military aid by the end of this year. So I don’t know why people are campaigning on it. perhaps if they manage to ban arms sales full stop in the short term there may be a significant impact. I believe they already have orders for israeli made military hardware from a few countries though and managed to keep up production throughout the last few years. Economy is actually doing pretty well.

I think a lot of people need to remember the reason why Israel is an american ally. It’s not because america loves Jews it’s because they are a reliable, trusted partner with excellent intelligence and military capabilities given their size. They have joint research projects (including on arms) they do things like design microchips for american companies develop drugs and medications and so on and they are culturally more similar (I’m not talking western culture I’m talking about a culture of improvement).

If you have to choose a partner in the middle east there is literally no-one else who is going to be close to any of that. So I guess they could but from a pragmatic strategic point of view it would not be useful for the americans.

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 05:59

Agree it was votes against Trump more than votes towards the more liberal policies of the other party.

The Iran war is unpopular, largely it seems because of the rising cost of petrol/diesel.

Trump’s weird ramblings and pronouncements must surely have become an embarrassment, even to many of those that voted for him. He’s too old - like Biden before him - and no longer up to the job (assuming he ever was which is debatable).

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 06:14

It’s a clear signal to the Republican Party that the Iran war needs to be ended well before the next elections.

Think this is the key takeaway from the mid terms - along with Trump’s fall in personal popularity- rather than changes to the relationship between the US and Israel. Those two countries will continue to be allies because they both benefit from being allies.

Martymcfly24 · 08/11/2026 07:26

I think while it was definitely a factor (among gas prices/ICE)/Trump himself) the biggest takeaway is the freedom of many candidates to openly criticize Israel (as well as demanding reduction of aid) and subsequently win their seats. In a country where criticism of Israel has been massively subdued by the administration it was quite surprising.
Polls are showing there has been a change in attitudes towards Palestinians and Israel. For the first time ever the polls are showing more sympathy towards Palestinians in America.

Plus it was hopefully a rejection of the disgusted Islamophobia that has been parroted by the Trump government over the past few weeks.

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 07:55

Martymcfly24 · 08/11/2026 07:26

I think while it was definitely a factor (among gas prices/ICE)/Trump himself) the biggest takeaway is the freedom of many candidates to openly criticize Israel (as well as demanding reduction of aid) and subsequently win their seats. In a country where criticism of Israel has been massively subdued by the administration it was quite surprising.
Polls are showing there has been a change in attitudes towards Palestinians and Israel. For the first time ever the polls are showing more sympathy towards Palestinians in America.

Plus it was hopefully a rejection of the disgusted Islamophobia that has been parroted by the Trump government over the past few weeks.

People have always had the freedom to criticise Israel. That is very apparent from all the criticism of Israel.

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 08:40

I’m not actually sure what people think will happen? Clearly having american backing is important for israel. BUT the war in Lebanon basically has nothing to do with the USA, the war in Gaza doesn’t involve the USA, they took out loads of Irans air defences in whats called the 12 day war without USA providing substantive military support.

I understand why some Americans may feel its a moral position to take (in which case I hope they also cut ties with every single other country in the middle east for things like ethnic cleansing, oppression of women and minorities as well).

But I see people who I think what Israel to disappear really egging this on but the evidence suggest that Israel is competent enough to manage conflict with it’s neighbours and not get squished. I actually think an Israel not tempered by American interference would be much more dangerous to it’s enemies. Wonder if its a lack of critical reasoning skills.

Look how they actually fight in the middle east, it’s fucking brutal, can’t think of a single arab leader who have ever been remotely bothered by civilian casualties, their own or other peoples really. It’s why the houthis are killing people on umrah, they just don’t give a shit. The iranians are a bit more careful because if theres a mass casualty event in a gulf country the governments will be obliged to take a much harder stance against them. Jordan literally dropped a bomb on a village in Syria because of a terrorist attack on Jordanian civilians. Totally oar for course.

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 08:41

Martymcfly24 · 08/11/2026 07:26

I think while it was definitely a factor (among gas prices/ICE)/Trump himself) the biggest takeaway is the freedom of many candidates to openly criticize Israel (as well as demanding reduction of aid) and subsequently win their seats. In a country where criticism of Israel has been massively subdued by the administration it was quite surprising.
Polls are showing there has been a change in attitudes towards Palestinians and Israel. For the first time ever the polls are showing more sympathy towards Palestinians in America.

Plus it was hopefully a rejection of the disgusted Islamophobia that has been parroted by the Trump government over the past few weeks.

This is just a silly thing to say, it’s quite clearly not true,

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 09:03

Also in terms of the senate elections the dems that won with the largest margins were not from the progressive side of the dems. The more left wing candidates actually had much smaller margins. So I’d be careful of assuming too much about the blue wave. The moderates performed well.

Martymcfly24 · 08/11/2026 09:38

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 08:41

This is just a silly thing to say, it’s quite clearly not true,

Could you explain what i said was "silly"?

Squeezingwildoranges · 08/11/2026 11:47

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2026 01:45

Progressives everywhere in the US since the midterms. Most of whom have a very different view of the relationship than the old guard. Trump was signalling the end of the flow of money possibly in a last ditch attempt to stop the wave.

They are getting ready to oust Chuck Schumer who is very pro Israel. The democratic voters feel very differently to the democratic party as was.

Interesting times.

Hopefully a shift from total unconditional military, economic and diplomatic support to a complete freeze on funding and international isolation. It might be a distant hope, but it would certainly be refreshing to see.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2026 14:48

Martymcfly24 · 08/11/2026 09:38

Could you explain what i said was "silly"?

I’d like an explanation too. When something like 88% of the Democratic politicians have expressed support for Israel (pretty unconditional support - including arms and lots of money) and Chuck Schumer has said it’s one of his main functions 🙄 it’s clear that there was a culture. BTW ‘support’ in this context is very specific.

Also, AIPAC was a theme, as were other superPACs. But AIPAC threw millions (31 roughly in Michigan) at the campaign, at even the primaries. Losing about 2/3 of the money they spent, on losing candidates. Michigan was a very interesting one with Stevens backing Rogers who had two registered foreign agents in his team. And is a really quite dreadful Republican. That’s quite strange.

The gas prices are linked to the war in Iran which is intrinsically linked to Trump’s relationship with Netanyahu so I’d say the whole thing is a mess. There are larger themes with Trump. Loving Netanyahu, Putin, amongst others but hating Carney and others.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2026 14:49

Squeezingwildoranges · 08/11/2026 11:47

Hopefully a shift from total unconditional military, economic and diplomatic support to a complete freeze on funding and international isolation. It might be a distant hope, but it would certainly be refreshing to see.

Yes! Close to an overhaul of rampant American interventionism that has plagued the world for decades.

OP posts:
Martymcfly24 · 08/11/2026 19:04

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2026 14:48

I’d like an explanation too. When something like 88% of the Democratic politicians have expressed support for Israel (pretty unconditional support - including arms and lots of money) and Chuck Schumer has said it’s one of his main functions 🙄 it’s clear that there was a culture. BTW ‘support’ in this context is very specific.

Also, AIPAC was a theme, as were other superPACs. But AIPAC threw millions (31 roughly in Michigan) at the campaign, at even the primaries. Losing about 2/3 of the money they spent, on losing candidates. Michigan was a very interesting one with Stevens backing Rogers who had two registered foreign agents in his team. And is a really quite dreadful Republican. That’s quite strange.

The gas prices are linked to the war in Iran which is intrinsically linked to Trump’s relationship with Netanyahu so I’d say the whole thing is a mess. There are larger themes with Trump. Loving Netanyahu, Putin, amongst others but hating Carney and others.

Agree I think if you are going to call a post "silly" and "untrue" you should really be able to back this up.

In my post I spoke about the government of the USA (nobody else before I'm misquoted) subduing criticism of Israel. This is a fact. Two examples:
-A number of states recently passed laws that require state contractors — including teachers, lawyers, newspapers and journalists, and even students who want to judge high school debate tournaments — to certify that they are not participating in politically motivated boycotts against Israel.
-internal guidance from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has directed officers to review and potentially deny green card applications for individuals engaging in anti-Israel protests or posting anti-Israel sentiment online

And I know nobody would even try and deny the Islamophobia of the POTUS and his team. Social media about metal detectors for Abdul El Sayad as well as the constant refrain of "jihadist" is a vile narrative from anyone not to mind a head of state.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2026 19:21

The Muslim Brotherhood nonsense is another dog whistle.

OP posts:
Martymcfly24 · 08/11/2026 19:53

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2026 19:21

The Muslim Brotherhood nonsense is another dog whistle.

Absolutely.
But is Stokes the fear in the uneducated. Especially with phrases like jihadist.It's like Trump and Obama's birth certificate again.

Funny he has no problem accepting jets from Muslims.

Bringemout · 09/11/2026 05:12

The usa has free speech, people literally did a bike ride hounding Jews yesterday. In no way is criticism of Israel suppressed in public or by the news. Anyone who actually reads american papers can quite clearly see that. The fact that politicians are publicly able to criticise israel is evidence that there is no suppression of debate. The fact that campus disruptions have been ongoing is evidence that people can criticise Israel. It is reasonable to ask that people who are providing services to the public are not going to be unhinged activists.

Greencard holders are not US citizens, it’s perfectly reasonable to say that if you wish to live in a country that you are not going to be disruptive.

RedTagAlan · 09/11/2026 05:53

Bringemout · 09/11/2026 05:12

The usa has free speech, people literally did a bike ride hounding Jews yesterday. In no way is criticism of Israel suppressed in public or by the news. Anyone who actually reads american papers can quite clearly see that. The fact that politicians are publicly able to criticise israel is evidence that there is no suppression of debate. The fact that campus disruptions have been ongoing is evidence that people can criticise Israel. It is reasonable to ask that people who are providing services to the public are not going to be unhinged activists.

Greencard holders are not US citizens, it’s perfectly reasonable to say that if you wish to live in a country that you are not going to be disruptive.

Edited

I will link your bike ride story, as you have not.

3 arrested as pro-Palestinian bike ride, counterprotest draw hundreds to Philadelphia - CBS Philadelphia (cbsnews.com)

I would say it is a daft thing to do. Reading both sides as in the news article, I do sort of see what the bike riders are saying, but I totally disagree with them doing it. It reminds me of the Orange March that has been in the news. And of course what happened in Germany. The organisers need to go do a "self criticism" and wear a dunce cap in the stocks for a while I would say.

Re freedom of speech and debate however. Hmm. I would say it is suppressed. Proscription and all that. Going to that article: "The statement from organizers said any "suggestions about the timing of our ride are simply false."
"All of these businesses have either fundraised in support of the Israeli military, hosted parties for Israeli soldiers who were deployed to Gaza, or expressed support for the genocide of Gaza," organizers said in a statement. "That is the reason we listed them." "

My reasoning is, that for there to be no supression of speech, there would be places hosting parties for Hamas perhaps ? Does this old saying not apply ?

“I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”

But in this case, one side is suppressed by law.

And no, I am not a HAMAS supporter. I am just objectively considering oppression of speech.

Oh, this bit of your post. Quote " Greencard holders are not US citizens, it’s perfectly reasonable to say that if you wish to live in a country that you are not going to be disruptive."

Hmm. Nah. That is going into the world of ideological testing, in a free country. I would say.

3 arrested as pro-Palestinian bike ride, counterprotest draw hundreds to Philadelphia

The bike ride boycott was organized by Philly Bike On Your Left. Organizers say they targeted businesses over their alleged support of Israel.

https://www.cbsnews.com/philadelphia/news/bicycle-boycott-ride-rittenhouse-square-philadelphia/#:~:text=Three%20people%20were%20arrested%20Sunday%20as%20hundreds%20of,ride%20boycott%20targeting%20several%20Jewish-owned%20businesses%20in%20Philadelphia.

Twiglets1 · 09/11/2026 06:16

I think the Mayor Cherelle Parker has it right.

”Everyone has the right to peacefully protest and express their political views. But singling out businesses because their owners are Jewish is unacceptable and has no place in our city”.

Or Attorney General Dave Sunday who pointed out, “this is not simply a protest aimed at the policies of Israel, rather it singles out our fellow Pennsylvanians based on their Jewish identity”.

KatiePricesKnickers · 09/11/2026 06:52

There may be a slight cooling of relations between the US and Israel, but that will be the sum of it.

PeachOctopus · 09/11/2026 06:56

I think it’s inevitable because the USA has basically lost the war with Iran. The Straights of Hormuz have been taken by Iran and they now control them .The Iranian leadership still stands. All the gulf states that thought they were protected by the US now see them as weak. Without a huge ground invasion of troops there is no way to topple Iran and even Trump will balk at that.
Israel overplayed their hand and lost. The Abraham accords were meant to side Gulf countries against Iran but the USA can no longer protect their oil so they will have to make deals with Iran. Drones have changed the battlefield forever and it’s the end of American international hegemony over shipping lanes, the end of globalisation. Supply chains worldwide will continue to break down.
Trump promised ‘no more wars’ and ‘drain the swamp’ he has done the opposite and taken the Republican Party away from winning elections possibly for the next 8 years, the anti Israel younger Republicans will probably take over what’s left of the Party, in the end Isreal massively overplayed its hand and has lost its base of support in the West.

Twiglets1 · 09/11/2026 07:54

PeachOctopus · 09/11/2026 06:56

I think it’s inevitable because the USA has basically lost the war with Iran. The Straights of Hormuz have been taken by Iran and they now control them .The Iranian leadership still stands. All the gulf states that thought they were protected by the US now see them as weak. Without a huge ground invasion of troops there is no way to topple Iran and even Trump will balk at that.
Israel overplayed their hand and lost. The Abraham accords were meant to side Gulf countries against Iran but the USA can no longer protect their oil so they will have to make deals with Iran. Drones have changed the battlefield forever and it’s the end of American international hegemony over shipping lanes, the end of globalisation. Supply chains worldwide will continue to break down.
Trump promised ‘no more wars’ and ‘drain the swamp’ he has done the opposite and taken the Republican Party away from winning elections possibly for the next 8 years, the anti Israel younger Republicans will probably take over what’s left of the Party, in the end Isreal massively overplayed its hand and has lost its base of support in the West.

If Iran has won the war, how come their economy has gone into free fall?

If they control the SoH, why are they losing so much oil revenue?

Centcom estimates that its naval blockade of Iran's ports has prevented the country from exporting more than $25bn in crude oil.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6d091ev3p0jo

golosh · 09/11/2026 12:27

KatiePricesKnickers · 09/11/2026 06:52

There may be a slight cooling of relations between the US and Israel, but that will be the sum of it.

A lot of young democracts rejecting AIPAC money and I think that might start to catch on, it’s popular with blue voters.