coffee machines - again!

[jeangenie]

this one or this one?

both look ok, the second has come up tops in which magazines coffee machines under £200 apparently - but reviews say it is very noisy

I have reserved the first from argos, but wonder if should go for the latter after all

anyone have any experience of either?

No but I have found all the cappucino makers I have had have been noisy and if you do find a quiet one let me know

reviews say the firse one IS quiet, which is kind of why I chose it (as well as being £40 cheaper) but I am distracted by the fact that the second gets such high plaudits from Which

want to pick it up today so need to decide fast

would I care if it's noisy when it'll only be used once or twice a day and not for every long (and normally by DH while I am out at work)

suppose I wonder is the second one actually worth £40 more, or are you just paying for fancier styling and a bloomin' cup warmer (which will never use)

Well I don't mind the noise - but it drives my other half mad.