Real vs faux tree: how can i convince DP that I'm right?

[beaniebaby25]

OK. I want a real tree this year and DP thinks its better to get a plastic one. I'd miss the smell, and the lovely feeling of a real one - plastic ones dont really do it for me (no offense if you have one - they can look very lovely indeed).

His main argument is the fact that its a real tree and will have to be composted etc (and he'll be the one carrying it ) whereas a plastic tree will last longer and he reckons is better for the environment.

So, wise mumsnetters, who is right? which is best from an ecological perspective, and is the enough to override the glory of a real tree? x

update: DP has just come back from the flower market with... a real tree!!!!! Excellent I knew he would!!

so it's resting in the front room, looking glorious and smelling divine. It's got roots in a lovely red pot so we'll try and keep it alive for next year.

Thanks for all the great arguments, looked like they worked. although v scary - the fire clip - will be extra extra careful.

ooh I am so pleased for you beanie - what a lovely DP you have!

Mine smells sooo good to - it just makes it feel like christmas is upon us now!