Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

How to stop exchanging gifts?

18 replies

DaffodilsandSnowdrops · Today 22:03

I’m not a grinch, honest, I love Christmas but I really feel this needs to change.

Long story short (I hope).

DH and I married for 35 years. No kids. He has two sisters, both married with kids and grandkids. We’re all retired, early sixties. They live in home town. We’ve moved around a bit and settled about 3 hours away.

Over the years we’ve done all the travelling to keep in touch. We’ve always exchanged adult gifts and kids till they got to 18 ish.

Id thought now we’re retired, sisters might make a bit of effort to visit us occasionally, but no. We’ve happily carried on making the trips to them, been to all the family weddings, done 6 hour drives for family meals etc.
The bit that upsets us a bit is that they don’t make any effort with phone calls, texts etc.On the rare message they’ve let slip that they’ve had dinners and family event/stuff together that we weren’t invited to. There’s been no fall out, just no inclusion. We’re almost NC really.

However, they still do birthday and Christmas gifts, quite expensive ones too. Every year, we get stuck in this cycle of exchanging “stuff” and I’m done. It’s all so false and if I’m honest I grudge sending gifts to people who never ask how we are or think to say “hey, we’re planning a dinner out on x date, you fancy coming?”.

Has anyone dealt with this? Any advice on how to tactfully message and say let’s stop the gifts thing?

Although it’s a nice fantasy, an honest convo with them just isn’t going to happen. We’ve stopped making the first move and predictably haven’t heard from either of them in months.

OP posts:
TheBers · Today 22:09

So what would actually happen if you just stopped? I mean actually told them now you weren’t giving any and didn’t?

You hardly see them. Would they not invite you at all because of this Christmas?

I stopped giving to (ungrateful) nephews and neices after it being a thing. It’s fine. We still hardly talk but no one has fallen out and we still make plans to see each other.

icantfindmyphone · Today 22:12

i totally understand this , it’s like the last thread holding you together though isn’t it ? but at the same time , just money spent for what gain. i don’t really want their presents , an invitation or some effort would be way better.

ExitPursuedByABare · Today 22:13

Do you see them to give the gifts or post them?

icantfindmyphone · Today 22:13

i suppose, it’s an unwritten, i’ll always be here for you .

icantfindmyphone · Today 22:15

yes , we host them every year . never get a return invitation or a suggestion to meet . used to invite them several times a year . slowed down on that … and so hardly ever see them

tinyspiny · Today 22:15

We are in the process of stopping gifts with my husbands brother and his family . This year my husband told them we were going to stop with birthdays after both of theirs but before mine and we are doing Christmas presents this year but hopefully will ditch it after New year . We still do birthdays with my family but then we actually get together with them .

underthehawthorntree · Today 22:16

I know this isn't the point of the post but if they live 3 hours away from you of course they won't invite you to dinner. It wouldn't even occur to me to invite people who live 3 hours away for dinner?! They probably also quite rightly assume that it's easier for you to visit both of them in their home town than all of them travel to you. And I wonder if you ever actually invite them to you or whether you just visit them because it's now the established pattern. Two sides to every story

DaffodilsandSnowdrops · Today 22:25

underthehawthorntree · Today 22:16

I know this isn't the point of the post but if they live 3 hours away from you of course they won't invite you to dinner. It wouldn't even occur to me to invite people who live 3 hours away for dinner?! They probably also quite rightly assume that it's easier for you to visit both of them in their home town than all of them travel to you. And I wonder if you ever actually invite them to you or whether you just visit them because it's now the established pattern. Two sides to every story

Maybe I’ve not explained.
Yes, we have gone there for the day/ evening/overnight many times over the years for dinners, lunches etc
The pattern was for us to go to them as it was easier when their kids were little.
We have invited them many times. We all drive. We’re all retired.
But you’re right, not the point.

OP posts:
Lapidariam · Today 22:25
  1. Timing: long enough before Christmas/your birthdays that they won't have bought you a present yet. If possible, after their birthdays, so that you don't look tight (obviously it depends when all your birthdays are).
  1. Announcement: going forward: we're not doing gifts for adults any more (or: reducing the number of people we exchange gifts with), so please don't get us anything. Probably dress it up in softer language.
  1. Rationale: lots of possible reasons you could give. Budget, environment, consumerism, simplifying life and focusing on quality time instead, whatever. Probably not "we never see you because you never bother."
Haveigotshoesforyou · Today 22:29

Just send a message saying you aren’t doing gifts, it’s an announcement not a negotiation so if they try to protest just stay firm

DaffodilsandSnowdrops · Today 22:30

@ExitPursuedByABare
We post gifts, usually they have things sent direct. It’s like a task being ticked off sadly.
@tinyspiny How did your DH word it?
@icantfindmyphone Good points. For all they don’t contact or seem to care, it feels like we’d be the bad guys if we stop the gifts thing.

OP posts:
DaffodilsandSnowdrops · Today 22:34

@Haveigotshoesforyou
tempting but I feel I need a “because” but I know I can stay firm once I’ve bitten the bullet. I’ve thought of saying something like we don’t want or need anything so please use your money on your kids.

OP posts:
Pedant61 · Today 22:39

We just said to my in laws- - "it's ridiculous to keep giving each other presents we neither want nor need - can we spend the money some other way?". So now we go for dinner and an overnight stay in a good hotel once a year, somewhere between our 2 towns. Just send cards for Xmas and birthdays. It's so much better

DaffodilsandSnowdrops · Today 22:39

@Lapidariam
Thank you!
Every birthday is done this year and they won’t do Christmas till early December so I need to just do this ASAP and get it over with.

OP posts:
DaffodilsandSnowdrops · Today 22:43

@Pedant61
Im glad you did this. Sounds lovely and sensible.
I think what’s held me back is that like a pp said, it’s like the last thread and I know they’ll just stop bothering with us at all.

OP posts:
ExitPursuedByABare · Today 22:53

Just don’t send then. See if they ask 🤔

DaffodilsandSnowdrops · Today 22:58

@ExitPursuedByABare
Tempting but they’ll have sent stupid expensive hampers or suchlike!
Last year a birthday gift I sent didn’t arrive and there was much drama while I got it sorted. Then back to tumbleweed. Yep, I’m done 😀

OP posts:
Travelfairy · Today 23:03

Similar situation here, sort of. DSis is difficult all year around, toxic really, we are very low contact but she still 'expects' expensive gifts for her and kids. This year I have taken a stance and said we are not buying for her and her DH but will buy for the children who are under 10. She wasnt happy bit I dont really care. She is inviting others to hers for Christmas but told us to make our own arrangements. I really hear you on the fakeness. I just cant do the pantomime of it all anymore!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page