Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

First world problem (small rant)

44 replies

poppymango · Today 07:20

One of the things I love about Christmas and buying gifts for people is spending time thinking of something they would really love; something personal.

My mum used to be a great gift giver, but over the past 10 years she has started asking me (in September, usually, and then weekly until I give her an answer) what I would like for Christmas. Of course you can't ask for anything expensive, so I'll say a scarf or slippers or something. Then she'll say, what kind? What colour? What brand do you like? Probably best if you find the thing you want and send me the link so I can get exactly the right one.

Then she says what would your DP like? And I can't give a vague answer, that won't do. She will ask me weekly until she gets something specific, then she'll want me to send her a link so she gets exactly the right thing.

"What about DP's dad?" ...you get the idea.

Then DP comes to me - in a panic, two weeks before Christmas - asking what he should get for my mum. He says no to the first few suggestions because they're either generic or too personal (apparently jewellery is inappropriate). Then he asks what I would like for Christmas. This year I told him a particular perfume and he kept forgetting the name of it, so he asked me to send him a link. Sigh.

Basically I've ended up doing the cognitive labour of coming up with Christmas presents for every single person in my family, including myself. I don't remember the last time I unwrapped a surprise on Christmas day and not only does it add extra stress in the lead up to Christmas, it is decidedly less magical.

Why can't people just walk round town and look for inspiration? Search online for something that jumps out at you? Think of your interests and hobbies and go from there? "I saw this and thought of you" is so much nicer than "here's that specific thing you chose for yourself". Just the act of making a bit more effort means so much.

Apologies for the essay but it is making me both stressed and unreasonably sad, and I don't feel like I can address it without sounding like a brat. It has to be the ultimate first world problem.

OP posts:
Leavemetonguetied · Today 07:24

Maybe your mum is fed up with gift giving?

But overall I agree. DH's mum just tells us what she wants. I find it very assuming. It'll be "I want a bottle of X perfume and it has to be the special edition bottle"

What is the point? I find that gifts are only nice when they've come with the thought of finding them.

essasas · Today 07:24

I love thinking of and buying things for the children in the family, but in my experience no adult just wants random stuff they may or may not like.

I enjoy buying things blind for my husband because I obviously know what he likes and what we as a family definitely don't need in the house.

Newmama4321 · Today 07:37

I totally agree OP, it’s like just exchanging money when you’re choosing your own presents so we may as well save the bother and not do it!

cuddlebear · Today 07:39

Just respond to all these questions with “a surprise” and refuse to elaborate.

Manythingsgoingon · Today 07:43

I have the same issue with my in laws for every birthday and Christmas. The constant messages asking for the list, me having to get my husband and child to choose something, me choosing something quickly which is most often not what I actually want. I hate it and find it so stressful on top of everything else. It’s always months in advance. My husband doesn’t do his list until the last minute and I get harangued every day about it. I’m angry just writing about it 🤣

LukaModricsMidriff · Today 07:49

No one does the thinking as you do it all for them! Take a step back and hope for the best?

Bfnagain · Today 07:58

I don’t have much money and although I’d love a thoughtful surprise, I find that most gifts I’m bought aren’t actually great and then I feel sad because there’s some lovely things I could have got for half the price that would’ve been so loved and used and it’s my only chance to get something nice and it’s gone. So tbh I’m all for sending a link. I can see how if you have more money though you’d be less precious about a treat and so the thought and a surprise would be more important to you. It’s also that you’re doing the work for everyone.
for me the worst bit of people asking for a list is when, like your dh, they reject the first few things you say. It really gets my back up that they won’t do the labour themselves but are telling me I haven’t done it good enough or met their particular (not specified to me) criteria.

I think you can tell dm at least that you’d like a surprise, she may feel more confident taking a risk then, maybe she’s just nervous. And warn dh now that you’re not helping this year

Magnificentkitteh · Today 07:59

I get this too, I even get a load of angst re where to buy it from, whether their trust pilot is good enough and whether its worth signing up to their newsletter for 10% off. Is exhausting. Mil has moved on to asking teen DD directly and this year they've agreed on cash for precisely this reason, and mil and I have decided we'll treat each other to a meal out over Christmas. I hate gift giving, especially at Christmas when it's overwhelming

Surelythistime · Today 08:00

My mum is the opposite and two weeks (if I’m lucky) before Christmas will starting asking what the teens want … and by that time mostly everything a teen would ask for is sold out Confused

Mydogisagentleman · Today 08:00

We can't have a walk around our town for ideas.
Unless you want to choose from Primark, poundland or b and m bargains.
It's dire and parking charges are outrageous

Magnificentkitteh · Today 08:01

Oh and being told your ideas are too boring (for yourself or DC) so you can never actually get what you actually want/need.

SickandTiredofEverything · Today 08:11

I can see both sides. Personally I love being given a link as it’s a task off my to do list and something I can be sure they want but I hate being asked myself for a list for me and the family. I would say in your case, tell your mum ‘a surprise’ and when she asks about your DP tell her to ask him. Likewise your DP’s dad - ask DP. Then for your mum from DP, give him a few suggestions and if he turns them down just shrug and say ok, choose yourself then. (Tbh the bar is so low for men im impressed he is sorting it himself rather than asking you to though I shouldn’t)

HeddaGarbled · Today 08:19

Write a short list for yourself and send it to everyone. Tell them to liaise with each other.

Tell everyone else to write and disseminate their own lists.

SmokeyRidge · Today 08:22

I wish the trend of "gift giving" would end. There are no end of entitled and ungrateful people on here complaining about "gifts". Does anyone look in the dictionary to see what the definition of "gift" is?

gift
1 of 3
noun
ˈgift

Synonyms of gift

Simple Definition

A Simple Definition is available from our Learner's Dictionary to help you understand the meaning faster.

1
: a notable capacity, talent, or endowment
2
: something voluntarily transferred by one person to another without compensation
3
: the act, right, or power of giving

HollyGolightly4 · Today 08:34

I feel the same about secret santa when it's prescribed. I don't want to choose from a list of retailers and buy you a voucher 🫠

Iamnofool · Today 08:42

I actually hate the whole Christmas present thing. It takes the joy out of it. Neither I nor my adult children need anything, or if we do, it is so specific that we would do better sourcing it ourselves. If you give a voucher or a link to an” experience” , it has still got to be bought or arranged. It’s all a faff. A surprise is lovely but only if it is something you want.

Linetta · Today 08:43

I used to have this problem. In the end I suggested to my DP and parents and PIL that we have a present amnesty at Christmas. No presents exchanged between us. They agreed (MIL was particularly relieved), but I think I'd have pushed for it even if they were reluctant. I think I said something about Christmas being too commercialised. I'm sure you can come up with lots of acceptable reasons. We still do presents for kids.

It saves me a lot of work and annoyance at Christmas. You have to announce it early enough so that they haven't bought you a present yet, though, and remind them in the autumn every year until it becomes second nature.

We still exchange birthday presents. And I still quietly do Christmas presents with my sister, because we love buying nice (surprise) presents for each other.

ShesNotRightThatOne · Today 08:56

100 agree!

It’s a transfer of stress that becomes your issue. If it’s any consolation I too get those weekly messages from my mother and now that I’ve figured out what I would like for Christmas the msg has changed to ‘have you picked one yet’.

Not to be ungrateful but it feels relentless. I have suggested not bothering with presents as tbh I’d prefer to buy it myself in my own time with no rush ‘to get it in time for Christmas’ and pick it up in the sales. That didn’t go down well.

When husband / mother now asks what each other wants I play dumb, finally recommending they talk or text one another.

Playing dumb has never come in so handy, second year in and I have noticed an improvement- for bdays etc too.

caringcarer · Today 09:14

Make an Amazon wishlist put on about 6 things you'd like. Send to Mum saying you'd love any of these.

Bestbeforenow · Today 09:16

Similar op - could have written this word for word.

FennelSnack · Today 09:21

Ah this one comes up every year and people have very varied opinions.

My first thought OP is that you could cut down on the number of presents. Does your DP need to give your mum a present separately to you? Just get him to do his family and you do your family and make everything joint. Does your mum need to give something to your DP's dad? So many permutations.

I'm always happy to give suggestions but they tend to be lazy ones- my husband will always be happy with a bottle of wine, my daughter will always be happy with some new stationery etc. I don't put much thought into it- any brilliant ideas I save for my own present giving. If people want to think up something really special they can do it themselves. I also don't give suggestions to family that are actually the things my kids want most because I know from experience that it goes wrong, eg DS really wants a specific lego set which I know would be in budget, I send my mum the link at her request, then on Christmas Day it turns out she bought something completely different and nobody has bought the only thing DS actually really wanted. Annoying.

caringcarer · Today 09:21

I must admit to askingy DD for links to gifts for DGC. I love a long way from them and only visit once a year and DD visits me twice a year and she brings DGC once a year to visit me. I don't know what they have or what they'd really like. I know they both love Lego but I don't know which sets they already have. My DD kindly sends me a link for a large Lego set each and some books they'd like for reading. I get them a T shirt, gloves, felt pens, chocolate Santa and a few bits or pieces for their stockings I can manage on my own.

TheVexatiousGrapefruit · Today 09:25

‘Cognitive labour’?
Frankly I’d prefer to offer suggestions than get something that’s way off or even ‘not quite right’. I love getting repeats of little luxuries I wouldn’t buy for myself through the year.

We’ve seriously reduced the presents though, now the DC are adults, and it’s close family only. I try for something thoughtful but inexpensive to unwrap, plus a monetary gift for our DC. So if it lands badly it’s not a big deal.

sparklingwaves · Today 09:51

I think it's quite normal- as the person who knows everyone the best, people come to you for ideas... I just have a rolling list that I add to during the year so I have enough ideas for everyone and can send them near Christmas/birthdays. We don't tend to buy lots of things during the year other than clothes/essentials, so they always have a list of things they'd like...

Enigma54 · Today 09:59

Mydogisagentleman · Today 08:00

We can't have a walk around our town for ideas.
Unless you want to choose from Primark, poundland or b and m bargains.
It's dire and parking charges are outrageous

Same here. What’s a “ town?” 🤔
Takes the stress out of shopping I suppose, having so few shops to choose from.

Swipe left for the next trending thread