Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

PIL not seeing their GS over Christmas

258 replies

Dontcallmebby · 15/11/2026 18:02

Today I asked my PIL about Christmas as we try to make plans so everyone sees our 6 year old (only grandchild on both sides). PIL seemed a bit sheepish and said they're planning on going to DHs brother & SILs parents 2 hours away for 4 days over Christmas. What are your thoughts on this?

OP posts:
MajorProcrastination · Yesterday 12:51

It's fine. I don't know why that would be weird.

Your child doesn't have to see all of his grandparents on Christmas Day.

My grandparents lived 4 hours away when I was a child, both sets. Some years one or the other pair would stay with us, some years it would be a great grandparent, some years it was just us. They all had other grandchildren and children who lived all over the place but even if they hadn't, there's no set rule that everyone has to see everyone on Christmas Day.

We've never seen my stepdaughter on Christmas Day, we've always done Christmas with her a day early so she has a full day with each parent.

My sister and I live local to my parents so we all have Christmas together (with grandchildren, parents in law etc) but my brothers live 3-4 hours away in different directions and if my parents wanted to go to them that would be totally fine. If they stay home or go to their in laws who are another 3-5 hours in different directions that's also absolutely fine! It's all fine! Everyone can Christmas wherever they want to Christmas!

Do you expect your parents to have to stay local for every Christmas forever? They're grown ups, they can go anywhere. If they're very local to you they probably see your child often throughout the year, which is lovely and gives plenty of options for a non-Christmas Day festive gathering and Christmassy treats and days out.

EmmaB1309 · Yesterday 12:56

It’s not really an issue I don’t think. Presumably they were invited and said yes. I’m sure they can can see DS before they leave or after they get back. When some family members live further away there’s always a chance they won’t get to see everyone. Unless there is a huge back story here. Not everyone’s priority is seeing children over Christmas.

Nomura · Yesterday 13:00

Everyone is compelled to see your dc because he's the only grandchild on both sides over Xmas? haven't the last 6 Xmas's been enough, where do these posters come from?

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · Yesterday 13:01

Apologies if you have answered this, and I’ve missed it, @Dontcallmebby - but are your ILs usually involved, present grandparents? If they spend quality time with your son, and are good grandparents most of the time, then it doesn’t seem unreasonable for them to spend some time with another part of the family, whereas if Christmas is the only time they bother with being grandparents, then missing it this year would be unreasonable.

Could you invite them round for a bit of a celebration before they go away? Tell your son that they are coming for a Christmas party before they go away, and make it special for him and them?

SandyCastles · Yesterday 13:02

Don't you ever host anyone yourselves?

Cherrytree86 · Yesterday 13:07

OP - They should cancel and stay home in order to see your child on Christmas Day

Boopsi · Yesterday 13:11

Given how many people on MN complain about their PiL and having to see them over Christmas, I suspect there will be some envy towards your situation!

I do understand it’s a little sad, but it does mean less stress for you re: catering and hosting, and leaves it open for you to go away over Christmas one year if you want to. Don’t underestimate how helpful that might turn out to be one day!

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · Yesterday 13:11

I hate the idea that all Christmas gets togethers have to be crammed into the three core days.

It's bouncing around too quickly between places that makes it a stress, not the people. Plus the expectation that you'll have repeats of the same meal over and over.

Just do something different on a different day. The loveliest christmas traditions are the most random.

Honestyatalltimes · Yesterday 13:16

Absolutely no issue whatsoever as long as there is an arrangement to get together at some point over the festive season. It doesn't end until the first week in January. Your pil have done nothing wrong.

Oxo01 · Yesterday 13:18

BigBrownBoogyingBear · 15/11/2026 21:49

I wonder if they have been invited to stay with DIL's parents because DH's brother and his wife are going to announce a pregnancy and want both sets of parents to be there??

Or maybe I'm just inventing things 🤣

My thoughts exactly !

DitzyDerbyBabe86 · Yesterday 13:19

I feel like your issue may really be that your husbands parents are closer to your SIL’s parents, than to your own parents?

Stompythedinosaur · Yesterday 13:25

I think it's pretty normal to take turns which part of the family you spent Christmas with.

Surely your ds won't be disappointed unless to phrase it in a way that makes him disappointed?

Babyrhinoo · Yesterday 13:28

Dontcallmebby · 15/11/2026 20:41

To be honest, I think I would check if I was planning on doing something different to usual but that's just me. It's why I wanted to get others views on it and I can a absolutely see they differ to mine. I'm understanding their view a bit more now.

Different to what though? It doesn’t sound like you really do anything or invite them over for Christmas? It doesn’t sound like you have a Christmas tradition with them where you do a set thing on a set day so I’m not sure what the problem is?

CatSquirrelDuck · Yesterday 13:28

Dontcallmebby · 15/11/2026 18:20

It's not so much they're seeing their other son and his wife (they all live on the same street), it's more their all travelling together to stay with his wife's family.

Edited

So what? What you're implying is what infuriates a huge percentage of people: that children come first, that people with children come first. They don't. Other people exist and many people want to see their loved ones that aren't necessarily little children (siblings, parents, extended family) at the holidays, too.

Your complaint is no different from people who think people with children should get all priority at holidays and term breaks for time off ... that's not fair to literally everyone else with loved ones.

Revisiontimetable · Yesterday 13:33

So in previous years...

Dh's brother goes off to see his in laws with SIL, on Xmas morning. His own parents pop in for Christmas presents before he goes. DH brother's family then presumably eat lunch with the in-laws.
DH parents then see you Christmas eve or the night of Christmas day.
What do the in laws usually do for their own Christmas Dinner?

OP, who cooks YOUR Christmas dinner?

My suspicious is it's your mum...

If you want in laws coming to you for Christmas you have to graduate into the adult slot in the family and HOST. Invite them for Christmas Dinner and invite your mum too and then you get to enjoy being the centre of a family. Celebrations don't happen by themselves, they involve work.

mumumental · Yesterday 13:34

I think it’s an individual choice.

Tryagain26 · Yesterday 13:37

What is wrong with it? I would've read anything into it at all. They can see him before or after their trip their son and his wife.
There is no law that says grandparents are not allowed to have Christmas away from their grandchildren!

Tryagain26 · Yesterday 13:38

Dontcallmebby · 15/11/2026 18:07

We all live in the city but they're going to stay with their DIL's parents 2 hours away. I thought it a little strange but maybe not?

No of course it's not strange. Why shouldn't they spend time with their son and his wife at Christmas?

TheRoyalEyeroll · Yesterday 13:49

Op, I think I’d be more concerned that they’d made the plans but not contacted you to say they’d be away for Christmas but wanted to make plans to see DGS before they left. I’d be upset that they don’t appear to have thought of him.

TheRoyalEyeroll · Yesterday 13:53

Realorsurreal · 15/11/2026 18:31

That is very weird of your mum.

No it’s not. It’s perfectly normal.

Perhaps it’s you who’s the weird one.

DisforDarkChocolate · Yesterday 14:01

It's sweet that he's sad but just plan something good for before Christmas you can all do together.

BlueFlowerOwl · Yesterday 14:02

I love my in laws and my extended family but what I wouldn't give for them to tell me they were going away for Christmas 😂

StreetFighter16 · Yesterday 14:15

I am of the opinion that this should be perfectly normal. Christmas is a day that we celebrate Jesus being born. It has become ridiculous that people get this worked up about grown adults doing something they want to and have been asked to so as not to upset the parents of a child who likely doesn’t even care when they see their Grandparents. What is the alternative? They stay at home so they don’t offend you? And see you for an hour or two on Christmas Day as opposed to be being welcomed somewhere for days and being cooked for? No brainer. If you were so desperate for their company you should have invited them for lunch or asked them to stay over or something. I’m not saying you should have to do that but you can’t hold them at arms lengths and then be annoyed in November that they have made plans for Christmas! Ludicrous.

mindutopia · Yesterday 14:26

Completely fine. I would consider the 2+ weeks around Christmas to be ‘Christmas time’. I don’t ever expect to see family just for Christmas or Boxing Day. Anytime leading up to New Year’s Day is fair game.

willitevergetwarm · Yesterday 14:32

poor in laws, can't do anything right

Swipe left for the next trending thread