Please or to access all these features

Christian Mumsnetters

This board exists primarily for the use of Christian Mumsnetters. Others are welcome to post but please be respectful. For theological debates, please visit our Philosophy/religion forum.

Not invited and I really don’t know how to handle it…

13 replies

howtohandleagain · 31/10/2026 19:05

I’m a Christian and part of a really lovely local church. I’ve been part of the church for 10+ years and have some great friends there. Over the last few months I’ve caught snippets here and there of women talking about a weekend retreat they were going on. Didn’t think much of it until the retreat came round about a month ago and on the Sunday, there were very few women present at church, in fact it was just me and 5 others. I then learned that it was a Christian retreat organised by one of the leader’s wives and someone I know quite well (within church) but it was ‘invite only’. I was really floored by this - if it was ‘invite only’, why were just 5 of us not invited?

The following weekend several of the women shared how impactful they’d found the retreat and one woman said the organiser had decided to invite ‘only the people God laid on her heart’.

I’ll be honest - this whole thing has really hurt me. I’m a pretty resilient person most of the time but these are women I have known well for 10+ years and all of a sudden I feel like I don’t know them at all. I even feel a bit humiliated, just like being back at school (we’re all in our 40s). There’s been no cross words, no issues between any of us - in fact most of the women who are my friends just assumed I was going too.

I have so many thoughts about this, specifically that it’s incredibly crass to invite most of the women in the church and exclude some. Even more strange that it was organised by the wife of one of the leaders. Anyone quite young in their faith could be really deeply hurt by this. Very suprised someone would do this and I don’t know how to react at all. Would you chat to the organiser and explain how hurtful that is?

OP posts:
AxolotlEars · 31/10/2026 19:08

That's shit.....so it wasn't organised by the actual church? Just organised by someone from the church and most of the women in the church were invited?

DadsMoulting · 31/10/2026 19:12

No, don’t chat to that woman. I have a feeling she very much enjoyed picking the majority and excluding a tiny group.
The fact that a number of your friends assumed you’d be going is key. It’s definitely her and not you. I am sorry you’re hurt by it. I would be too.

howtohandleagain · 31/10/2026 19:15

AxolotlEars · 31/10/2026 19:08

That's shit.....so it wasn't organised by the actual church? Just organised by someone from the church and most of the women in the church were invited?

Yes…the woman organising it is the wife of one of the elders though so not ‘officially church’ but it could be perceived that way.

I’m really mystified by it. I get on well with her and of course it’s made me second guess myself, wondering if I’ve somehow offended her.

OP posts:
FuzzyPuffling · 31/10/2026 19:17

I'd be really hurt too. It's very thoughtless, at best.
Church is the one place that should be inclusive, and this kind of behaviour is not what I would understand as being "Jesus-like".
I'm so sorry it's happened to you.
I would take some time to pray on it.

howtohandleagain · 31/10/2026 19:40

FuzzyPuffling · 31/10/2026 19:17

I'd be really hurt too. It's very thoughtless, at best.
Church is the one place that should be inclusive, and this kind of behaviour is not what I would understand as being "Jesus-like".
I'm so sorry it's happened to you.
I would take some time to pray on it.

Yes…I’ve been praying about it and trying to come to peace about it. I feel like I need to (nicely) say something, not so much for me but more on behalf of how badly it could have hurt others. I really dislike the idea that only those ‘God laid on her heart’ were invited as frankly, that’s just a load of nonsense!

If she wanted to have a retreat with close friends or a select few, then great, go for it. It’s just that it was a very small amount of women left behind and that’s the part that hurt.

OP posts:
Thegreatestoftheseislove · 31/10/2026 19:59

howtohandleagain · 31/10/2026 19:40

Yes…I’ve been praying about it and trying to come to peace about it. I feel like I need to (nicely) say something, not so much for me but more on behalf of how badly it could have hurt others. I really dislike the idea that only those ‘God laid on her heart’ were invited as frankly, that’s just a load of nonsense!

If she wanted to have a retreat with close friends or a select few, then great, go for it. It’s just that it was a very small amount of women left behind and that’s the part that hurt.

Edited

The organiser has already said that they arranged the retreat for people whom God had laid on her heart. That is personal to her and those who attended. I can see how this could potentially be hurtful but there may be other things happening about which you are not aware - and, bluntly, may not be any of your business?

To take Communion/break bread/attend the Lord's Table, we must do so with a 'pure' heart and not to be still holding onto any issue with a brother or sister in Christ. Therefore my advice would be to prayerfully and gently have a conversation to explain how their going on retreat made you feel.

When/if you speak with the organiser, I would advise that you should do so from your own personal perspective - how it made you feel. You have not been given a mandate nor authority to be the spokesperson for others and can only speak for yourself. Maybe you could organise another retreat for the New Year and open it up to all?

howtohandleagain · 31/10/2026 22:01

Thegreatestoftheseislove · 31/10/2026 19:59

The organiser has already said that they arranged the retreat for people whom God had laid on her heart. That is personal to her and those who attended. I can see how this could potentially be hurtful but there may be other things happening about which you are not aware - and, bluntly, may not be any of your business?

To take Communion/break bread/attend the Lord's Table, we must do so with a 'pure' heart and not to be still holding onto any issue with a brother or sister in Christ. Therefore my advice would be to prayerfully and gently have a conversation to explain how their going on retreat made you feel.

When/if you speak with the organiser, I would advise that you should do so from your own personal perspective - how it made you feel. You have not been given a mandate nor authority to be the spokesperson for others and can only speak for yourself. Maybe you could organise another retreat for the New Year and open it up to all?

I do (partly) see your point. It was made worse that women were invited to share (from the front) the following week if they’d been impacted by the retreat, so that was a bit awkward. Someone said to me afterwards, ‘we missed you being there’ and I said, ‘oh sorry, I wasn’t invited’. She then said ‘oh goodness, I didn’t realise - I’m sorry’.

Of course this lady can absolutely do whatever she wants and no one is under any obligation to invite anyone they don’t want to but a little discretion would have been nice.
Instead it was very much celebrated openly and that was tough. I’m very glad so many women (around 40) were so impacted by it though!

And yes, in time I’ll be able to let it go and make peace with it but I do think it’s important to ‘feel what you feel’ and then with God’s help move through it.

OP posts:
ChristmasStars · 31/10/2026 23:16

Awful. Getting the women to share from the front is just cruel.

I was in a church where this happened. I was included a couple of times but excluded for the majority. For a leader to be doing something so exclusive is pretty grim. It would be different if it really was just her 3 closest friends or something like that, but this clearly isn't. I remember well that feeling of being one of the few women at church on the Sunday. What made it worse was that my husband and I were part of the leadership team too but not part of that particular leader's in crowd.

Frankly I can look back and see that for this and several other reasons we should have left the church long before we did and gone somewhere more gracious and welcoming.

AxolotlEars · 01/11/2026 08:41

Once the women were invited to share from the front the following week, in my opinion, it makes it a 'church' supported event.

MargaretThursday · 01/11/2026 13:03

There's a few things I'd just suggest you think through:

You say you caught snippets here and there. Now I wonder whether the reason why so many went was that she invited a few, then people heard snippets and said "oh can I come too" and so she assumed it was generally known and anyone who hadn't spoken up wasn't interested.

It also depends whether it was a "I have booked for 20 people can you come" or a "I'm going on this date, if you want to join me, then the booking is XX".
The latter could well be that they hadn't realised how many were going until they were there.

If it was an event that is only once a year like the Orchard Women's Conference, then it might be she invited a group and then it happened that lots of other people went too, independently as they found when they were there.
I mean, we go to Spring Harvest with a group from church each year. Sometimes our group is small (10-12 people), sometimes it's above 60 people.
Sometimes we arrive and discover that there are lots of other people we know there.
One year (dh organises the group) when we were halfway there, we suddenly had a couple of additions to the WhatsApp group. We knew it was booked up, and dh was worried that somehow he'd missed two families who were going to be arriving to no accommodation. What had actually happened was they had booked independently, then as they were setting off, they were chatting to one of our group, so they added them to the WhatsApp group.

And also, are you sure it hasn't been in the notices. Along the lines of "A group of us are going to X, if you want to join us then the booking is here." Because as someone who does the notices, it is not infrequent that someone is complaining no one told them yet it's been in the notices for the last month, said from the front during the notices twice and an A3 poster on the front door.

I think you need to go and have a chat to the organiser, but I'd approach it as a "disappointed to not have been, how was it sorted to go" rather than a "I was left out" which is unlikely to have been deliberate.

Enjoyingautumn · 04/11/2026 09:51

It would be great to find how exactly God put this group on her heart and how He didn’t get round to forewarning her of the hurt that excluding a few people might cause, particularly when the event was followed by public testimonies.
If you’re upset, the others who were excluded probably were too.
I left my previous church because a female leader/voluntary women’s pastor clearly couldn’t stand me. She’d use the prayer meetings to make passive aggressive political statements as she obviously suspected I didn’t vote for the political party she thought I should be voting for 🤣. Nothing I said was ever right.
I’d been associated with that church for around 25 years and had lots of friends there, so it was a big thing to leave. She wasn’t the only reason I left, other things happened too, but I didn’t want to attend prayer meetings where the leader was using the prayer meeting in that way, or where a leader had so little respect for the holiness of God. Same with her being on the preaching rota.
However, I’m fortunate in that I live in an urban area, so it was fairly easy to find another church. My new pastor is a better spiritual fit for me than the previous ones were, so in a sense this leader did me a favour as God used the situation to push me out of the nest into a better church.
I also had a male friend who left the church a few years before me, having experienced similar things. He never told me who the person was, but it could have been the same woman.
The trouble with what you describe is that it tends not to be a one-off event. You’re now struggling with your feelings towards this woman, and are finding it difficult to move on. However, in the eyes of many she looks great, so she’s probably pleased with herself and could well feel encouraged to do the same again.
I don’t think it would be a bad idea to let the pastor or someone else who can speak to the pastor, know how you feel.
We go to church to be encouraged in the Lord, not hurt. Even if this woman is completely unaware of the hurt she has caused, she should be pulled up on it so that it doesn’t happen again, because she has done wrong. It isn’t a healthy way to go about doing things in a church and most churches would quickly spot the problems that might be caused by having retreats for the 90% of women. In our church, when there are weekends away, we’re always told we can approach leadership if we would like to go and are struggling with funding. At least there’s an awareness that people shouldn’t be excluded due to their personal circumstances.
I’m sorry you have had this happen, but I hope you can turn the situation around for good.

JoderTia · 12/11/2026 22:24

How unkind of her to do this. I too would be very hurt. What kind of church is it? The ‘God put this on my heart’ line seems very American to me- like something you’d hear in documentaries about Mormonism as the husband explains why he’s marrying yet another wife. It always seems a cop out- the person coming out with lines like this knows that what they’re doing is inexcusable so goes ‘but it’s God doing this, not me’ so no one can question it. Everyone else going along with it would prompt me to look for another church.

BringmeHigherLove · 14/11/2026 05:19

It would make me want to leave that church. Are you married? What does your husband think?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page