Please or to access all these features

Childbirth

Share experiences and get support around labour, birth and recovery.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Bath/Bristol: Which is best RUH Bath, Mendip, or St Michaels?

7 replies

NewMama97 · 28/10/2026 13:02

Hello!

I just found out I'm pregnant with my first and I am trying to get all my ducks in a row. My closest birthing centre, at 15min, is RUH Bath Birthing Centre. Assuming I am low risk, I could also choose Mendip or St Michael's Midwife-led Unit, but they're a fair bit further away, at 35+ minutes. All the discussions I can find about them are from pre-2015, so, I was really hoping to hear people's experiences?

For me, I want as natural a birth as possible. A calm, quiet environment, minimal intervention, no coached pushing, etc, and the option of a water birth because I've read they have some great benefits. I love the calm, homey environment offered by the freestanding centres but an ambulance ride just feels too risky to me. Instead, I like the idea of the attached units with the adjacent hospital as a safety net just in case anything did go seriously wrong.

From the virtual tours, Mendip and St Michael's seem to have spacious birthing suites, and apparently double beds! So, they seem quite appealing on the surface. RUH the rooms do look nice though they seem a lot smaller, and every room seems to at least have a bath if I can't get the pool room; the biggest thing for me really is just how much closer it is. But are Mendip or St Michael's worth the extra distance?

I would love to know your experiences and which you would recommend, please? Especially if you've been to more than one of them! Thank you so much 🥰

OP posts:
PipMumsnet · 28/10/2026 15:19

Just bumping this for you OP.
MNHQ

Vickim03 · 28/10/2026 15:52

My choices were ruh or a smaller cottage hospital. I opted for the ruh and glad I did as I was checked locally (waters went before any contractions) and it wasn’t detected there that I was breech, I always opted to birth in Bath anyway as you never know what may happen and at least being there everything is to hand. Had I had gone to Paulton I would have had a breech baby via gas and air! And no prep for the baby being breech. if anything had gone wrong it would have been an ambulance trip…. I wasn’t a high risk pregnancy either. I had the option to transfer back to paulton but stayed. And by my second I was asked to go home the following day after a c section! They don’t keep you in for long…. You could take an actual tour to get a proper feel for the place if it helps. But I’d always air on the side of caution.. things can change quickly.

NewMama97 · 29/10/2026 11:46

Vickim03 · 28/10/2026 15:52

My choices were ruh or a smaller cottage hospital. I opted for the ruh and glad I did as I was checked locally (waters went before any contractions) and it wasn’t detected there that I was breech, I always opted to birth in Bath anyway as you never know what may happen and at least being there everything is to hand. Had I had gone to Paulton I would have had a breech baby via gas and air! And no prep for the baby being breech. if anything had gone wrong it would have been an ambulance trip…. I wasn’t a high risk pregnancy either. I had the option to transfer back to paulton but stayed. And by my second I was asked to go home the following day after a c section! They don’t keep you in for long…. You could take an actual tour to get a proper feel for the place if it helps. But I’d always air on the side of caution.. things can change quickly.

Sorry to hear you ended up having complications, hope you and your babies are all happy and healthy now ❤
That's really helpful, thank you! I didn't realise you could ask for a tour of the hospital. Is that something I ask my midwife to arrange?

OP posts:
Vickim03 · 29/10/2026 11:50

It was something offered at the time but we are talking 10 plus years ago.
there was no complications thankfully! Just a rush due to contractions coming quickly I was ready to push when they realised I needed a c section. Just would hate to think what could have happened if I wasn’t in the right place….

SallySunshine2026 · 13/11/2026 06:04

I (very recently) had an unexpected induction at RUH as my waters broke early, I cannot recommend it enough. I felt safe and supported throughout despite it being the outcome I least wanted, and the experience was actually very positve on the whole. Medical staff cannot be faulted. The birth centre is fairly cosy, I had a room with a nice big bath and fairy lights etc but access to all pain relief up to and including epidural. The midwives went through my birth preferences before we got started and were respectful of my ideas. I had the same choice of hospitals as you, I will pick RUH again for any future children :) hope this helps!

BlueSpottyLeopard · 13/11/2026 12:11

I don’t really rate RUH. I thought community midwife was brilliant but there was a massive disconnect once I was at RUH for my birth.

I was essentially pressured in to having an induction at 38 weeks because baby was big. I said I wasn’t sure but the consultant said there were big risks if baby got too big and booked me in for induction when I was undecided.

She also said baby would be so big I’d need to bring size 3-6 month clothes to the birth, I genuinely was made to feel like I was giving birth to some monster and I wouldn’t have that newborn baby experience. Turns out she was 8lb 4oz and was in newborn clothes and in 3-6 months at 13 weeks!

Id made it clear if I had an induction I would not want to have the balloon. All midwives I spoke to said this was fine they could do two pessaries then break my waters and I’d have the drip. Then after the pessary I’d dilated 3cm and was told next step is balloon which I refused. But the midwife just kinda shrugged and said a consultant would speak to me and said I’d have to have a c section. This was after I’d already been there 48 hours.

Consultant spoke to me about 16 hours later and said that I could have c section or just go home because the risks of a big baby weren’t really that big anyway… so I could just go into labour naturally. Which felt so invalidating after the reason I was there was because another consultant had made it out to be such a big risk.

I opted for c section in the end as I just wanted baby out at this point and I’d been in over 72 hours at this point.

After c section I then failed the wee test after my catheter came out - no one told me you need to drink loads of water etc.

I was then on a catheter for what I thought was 24 hours but then they decided I needed to be on it 48 hours.

There was an awful midwife involved in my care who demanded I March up the corridors, forced me to show her my tummy because I said I wanted my blood clotting injection in my thigh not tummy area and was just generally really aggressive and horrible. I took note of her name and fed it back in my feedback.

We were hoping to go home on day 6 of being in hospital and my husband went to the daily discharge meeting etc. but we never got discharged.

On day 7 they finally discharged us and as we were leaving another midwife called my mobile saying she was outside our house to see baby. I explained we were only just leaving the RUH and she asked if we had been readmitted I explained we had never left! So there was obviously some massive miscommunication somewhere and someone forgot to discharge us!

It all just felt like such a disorganised mess and that my preferences/notes weren’t being read or passed on.

I also really wanted to breastfeed and a midwife “tried” to help me but she took one look at my nipples and said “oh are they always like that” so apparently my nipples are abnormal! They then just got baby formula which was a massive mistake as once you accept formula they lost interested in me establishing breastfeeding. It was actually my amazing community midwives who organised for a breastfeeding consultant to come round and I managed to establish breastfeeding in about 30 seconds of her arriving at my house.

Just my honest experience of RUH. I felt so optimistic as the community care beforehand was brilliant but it all fell apart in the actual hospital.

Oh and they also didn’t give me some prescribed medication I relied on until 48 hours after arriving!! Supposed to have twice a day despite me asking plenty of midwives. Side effects of not taking it are vomiting so I also spent the first few days being sick!

This was all in 2025 so relatively recently.

BlueSpottyLeopard · 13/11/2026 12:17

Should add pregnant again now and opted for Salisbury instead this time slightly longer drive for us but didn’t want RUH again.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread