Please or to access all these features

Cars

Welcome to Cars - check out our Discover page for more

Auto vs manual transmission how long did it take you to get used to it?

52 replies

twiddlingthumbs69 · 15/11/2026 20:30

I need a new car and am being badgered by DH to get a auto.

ive always said no but having looked at what’s available, manuals seem quite few and far between now. All newer models are auto.

did you make the switch and are you happy that you did?

did you get used to it quickly?

im worried about being ok with it as long as I’m thinking about it when driving but instinct could kick in if there was an emergency and id try and use a clutch?

maybe I’m overthinking the whole thing?thoughts?

OP posts:
Cuwins · 17/11/2026 02:38

I go between the 2 on a semi regular basis as my own car is a manual but the car I drive for work (approx once a fortnight but sometimes long drives) is an automatic, and a big vehicle compared to my tiny hatchback! I was really worried about it but actually haven’t had any issues- have now driven it 4 or so times (including into London which I had never done before) and it’s really nice to drive. I only pressed the brake thinking it was the clutch once, thankfully at very low speed while parking. And tried to move off once with my foot on the brake thinking it was the clutch and wondering why we weren’t moving! But I was pleasantly surprised

StarCourt · 17/11/2026 03:03

I’ve had an automatic now for nearly 3 years and love it after driving a manual for 35 years. It was quick and easy to get used to although at first I did want to keep changing gear even though there’s no gear stick. Just years of habit that soon went away.

UnoriginalPoster · 17/11/2026 03:18

I've never driven anything other than an automatic and have no plans to.

HoldMyWine · 17/11/2026 03:31

I switched to auto 2 years ago, reluctantly. I will never go back to manual.

VerbenaGirl · 17/11/2026 03:49

A lot quicker than I thought I would. It’s not the clutch I reach for, but I do sometimes try to change gear. I did my first emergency stop at the weekend with no problems. Still not quite sure how hill starts work, but they seem to! It is much easier to drive overall, especially on long runs. We found the same when buying - out of about 40 cars of the model we wanted, only a couple were manual. Before that we’d not considered automatic.

BigBadPotato · 17/11/2026 04:41

Five minutes, if that. Just make sure to tuck your left foot out of the way a bit, that helps. In a weird way I almost miss manual, but I don’t think I’d go back.

Glittertwins · 17/11/2026 05:58

I just kept my left foot out of the way so I didn’t use it for the brake instead of the now non existent clutch. Didn’t take long to get used to it and it’s certainly easier driving on unknown roads in the dark as I don’t need to change gears. I still drive the DCs’ manual car without problems.

Hellohah · 17/11/2026 06:13

Driving, like others have said is pretty instant.
I do feel like reversing may take some time to get in an automatic.
I've only driven one for a few days on holiday and reversed 3 times, but it was very strange to me and all 3 times, we were like a kangaroo backing into those spaces 😂

sinkcat · 17/11/2026 06:15

Really quickly. I thought I hated autos after one I had 20 years ago. Got one earlier this year and I love it - wish I had switched sooner.

i did a 5 hour motorway drive month or so after having in and the difference I felt on arrival after driving auto with adaptive cruise control vs my 13yo manual was immense.

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 17/11/2026 06:26

HarrietSchulenberg · 16/11/2026 22:54

I've driven automatics (hire cars) but prefer manuals. I particularly enjoy leaving automatics for dust at traffic lights and even my son's 19yo 1.2l Fiesta can beat one if I'm driving it. Automatics take all the fun out of driving.

Unless you’re beside an EV. My guilty pleasure is putting my foot down at the lights onto the motorway, when someone is bouncing away on their clutch beside me impatient to go.

I don’t even have to try. Instant torque is amazing.

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 17/11/2026 06:29

I learnt auto, switched to manual for 10 years, then back to auto and can still get in a manual and drive off with zero issues.

It takes very little to adjust to an auto but the muscle memory of a clutch & gearstick will never go either. Don’t worry too much.

Mumofyellows · 17/11/2026 06:37

I changed in August and got used to it really quickly, it was very weird for the first couple of drives but not I absolutely love it!

IzzyLeng · 17/11/2026 06:43

I’d never go back to a manual. I could drive an automatic perfectly safely after a minute, took me about a week before I could stop concentrating especially at junctions, etc. now it’s very natural.

had to drive dh manual car recently and stalled it 3x in six miles. Can’t drive a manual now 😆

SlipperyLizard · 17/11/2026 06:43

It takes a few minutes to get used to it, a few weeks to stop your hand hovering over a non existent gear stick or your left leg twitching.

I’m not sure how anyone is at risk of doing anything with their left foot apart from twitching it - you don’t brake with your left foot in a manual car, so you shouldn’t have any “muscle memory” that would move your left foot onto the brake, even in an emergency - just keep it planted on the floor where the clutch would have been.

I’ll never go back to manual.

UniquePinkSwan · 17/11/2026 07:08

Straight away. It’s far easier

JuanaSmith · 17/11/2026 07:23

We have a manual and an auto. It's not a problem. I just adjust based on what I'm driving. Also went back to manual after not having driven one for years and it was all fine within a couple of minutes.

MagnoliaParks · 17/11/2026 07:25

Less than 15 minutes. We now have a manual and automatic and I probably drive them both about the same amount. No adjustment period for switching between, but I do choose the automatic if I go anywhere where there might be traffic.

JustSawJohnny · 17/11/2026 12:29

Manual to auto is super easy.

They're like driving a dodgem!

Other way round is an absolute ball ache!

Nourishinghandcream · 17/11/2026 12:47

Took about 10-seconds and then I was a total convert.😃

My OH had been badgering me for yonks as he knew it would be easier with my (slight) disability but I resisted.
When I realised just how great it was, he set about changing his car to auto so both were the same.

Going back to a manual is ok, only once did I forget to dip the clutch at a roundabout.🫢

moominontherun · 17/11/2026 12:50

No time at all. We have both so I routinely go between auto and manual, sometimes both in the same day, with no issues.

MrsAvocet · 17/11/2026 13:00

I was forced to swap to an auto about 6 years ago after I had severe injuries to my left leg meaning I could no longer drive a manual. I was very against the idea initially probably partly because of the circumstances, but mainly because I had most of the commonly held and totally illogical prejudices against autos based on what they were like 40 years ago. 😂 However, I got over that pretty quickly and now even though I am recovered enough to drive a manual I don't think I will ever buy another. My next car will almost certainly be an EV in fact.
There are a few things you need to get used to. Personally I didn't have any problems trying to use my left foot but of course that was down to the fact that I couldn't - it is something most people will have to get used to. I do still occasionally move my hand as if to change gear as I approach a roundabout though. The other main thing I noticed is that I needed to brake more as you can't rely on engine braking to the same degree as in a manual. It also took me a bit of time to trust it when overtaking. My car has a DSG box and you can change gear manually if you want to and at first I did change down manually before overtaking but I soon learned that actually it wasn't necessary - the technology does its job very well.

MabelAnderson · 17/11/2026 14:12

twiddlingthumbs69 · 15/11/2026 20:30

I need a new car and am being badgered by DH to get a auto.

ive always said no but having looked at what’s available, manuals seem quite few and far between now. All newer models are auto.

did you make the switch and are you happy that you did?

did you get used to it quickly?

im worried about being ok with it as long as I’m thinking about it when driving but instinct could kick in if there was an emergency and id try and use a clutch?

maybe I’m overthinking the whole thing?thoughts?

Friend had a crash a few months ago doing just this. Muscle memory meant she hit the “clutch” and instead accelerated into a car. Nobody hurt thankfully.
It’s a very common situation if you have been driving a manual for a long time and switch to an automatic. Some people seem to find it easier than others, my brother has changed with no problems, but in your place I would book a half a dozen lessons in an automatic to get a feel for it and adjust.

BCBird · 17/11/2026 14:45

It is so easy. I drove a manual for 30 years. When I needed a new car j decided to get automatic. It really is a piece of 🎂

BCBird · 17/11/2026 14:46

The dealer told me to put my left foot on the ledge and leave it there as u don't need it.

Hoppinggreen · 17/11/2026 14:48

My car is electric, so similar, and I go between that and DH and DS manual cars with no difficulty at all
The key is to only use your right foot