Please or to access all these features

Cancer

Find advice & support if you or someone you know has been diagnosed with cancer

Should I have a preventive double mastectomy?

43 replies

TheRealMummyPig · 03/11/2026 03:15

I’m 45 and on HRT after going through early menopause. My menopause symptoms were horrific and I never want to experience that again. I have two children age 10 and 7. We have a strong family history of breast cancer with my mum diagnosed in her 60s with ER/PR/HER + breast cancer. My Mum’s sister was also diagnosed at the same age and all of my mums cousins and her aunt on same side have had BC including one who died in her 30s. I also have an uncle on dad’s side who died of prostate cancer in his 40s. I tested negative for the BRCA genes and was recommended annual mammograms with contrast. I had one a few years ago that resulted in a biopsy that was benign but very stressful.

I am really considering a double preventative mastectomy to help relieve the annual anxiety of mammograms as I feel it’s only a matter of time until I get BC too. I also can’t imagine having to come off HRT if I ever got BC. My symptoms were so debilitating. I know it’s a big decision to make. (I’d be paying privately obviously and would have to find a surgeon willing to perform it).

I just don’t know if I’m being too dramatic considering it.

OP posts:
Arregaithel · 03/11/2026 10:04

Maddy70 · 03/11/2026 09:58

If you don't carry the. BRAC gene I think that's overkill. I would just ensure you continue to be monitored well

Just for info @Maddy70, the BRCA1 and BRCA2 are not the only genes involved in breast cancer

Breast Cancer Gene Mutations Beyond BRCA | BCRF

Learn about BRCA1, BRCA2, and other breast cancer gene mutations that impact risk, prevention, and treatment. See how BCRF research drives progress.

https://www.bcrf.org/about-breast-cancer/other-breast-cancer-gene-mutations/

Marymanna · 03/11/2026 10:25

General population risk is 14% so 15% really isn't a big increase in risk.

I do understand though. I had a single mastectomy due to BC and ever since have wondered about having the other side done as well. I have an annual mammogram and MRI with contrast, alternating every six months so I get seen every six months which I find reassuring. Having said that the mammogram didn't pick up my cancer so still on the fence about whether it is worth even having them, but I trust my consultant and she thinks it outweighs the minimal risks of radiation.

Marymanna · 03/11/2026 10:27

The radiation from a mammogram is the same as 26 days of normal background radiation we all experience on earth, or one long-haul flight.

Minasama · 03/11/2026 10:29

Here I would take advice from a qualified doctor, but do regular checking and screening and cut out alcohol/smoking/processed foods/ make sure I lived a healthy life and wasn’t overweight which as well as being a risk factor makes it harder to spot a lump early.

Beeast cancer can be treated if caught early.

Is the BRCA gene the only one that causes cancer? If you are negative for it I wouldn’t do major surgery personally but would be alert.

IndigoNZ1 · 03/11/2026 11:10

I’d do it, if I were you. I got breast cancer at the same age as you are now and my kids are now the same age as yours. Cancer is awful, especially at a relatively young age and with young kids. I had a double mastectomy and then later a full hysterectomy (for another reason). I’m very happy that I now can’t get ovarian, endometrial, or cervical cancer. But, in case you weren’t aware: a double mastectomy doesn’t eliminate all risk of breast cancer - they have to leave a bit of tissue behind and it can still come back in that or the skin. Also, I found the recovery relatively easy and wasn’t that attached to my breasts, but it may be different for you. Good luck with whatever you decide!

Mumtoabillion · 03/11/2026 12:01

Marymanna · 03/11/2026 10:27

The radiation from a mammogram is the same as 26 days of normal background radiation we all experience on earth, or one long-haul flight.

Edited

Hi @Marymannaso just to be completely clear, you're disagreeing with the poster who said that mammograms can increase the risk of cancer ?

Asking because as far as I know, I'll just be on regular mammograms when I'm through treatment and of course now Wonder if it would be better to ask for a different screening method.

nauvemova · 03/11/2026 12:04

@Mumtoabillion are you trip neg? How old are you? But I really wouldn’t worry about the cancer risk of mammograms, I don’t know why that poster mentioned it. It’s negligible in the scheme of things.

AlliuminBloom · 03/11/2026 12:13

nauvemova · 03/11/2026 08:06

I don’t really understand OP, how you can be negative for genetic risk but also at an increased risk, I’m not sure they’d even offer preventive surgery in those circumstances. Your worries are very valid, but I think you need to talk to a professional who can give you a more accurate picture of your risk profile, it’s something they can mathematically quantify, to weigh up risk and benefit of intervention.

People talk about the BRCA gene test as if everything was already known about it and was totally black and white. Medicine/Science is far from that! Everyone has the BRCA genes, it’s not a pure positive/negative. There are mutations that are known to increase the BC risk, which presumably OP does not have any of, but there can be other mutations that just have not been proven / found out or there could be other genes that are causing cancer, that science has not discovered yet. The family risk remains regardless of the gene tests. Only if OPs mother was proven to have a BRCA mutation, that OP doesn’t have (didn’t inherit) , would science consider the risk reduced.

IHadaMarvelousTimeRuiningEverything · 03/11/2026 13:32

Im brca2 and my risk of getting bc was 55% and I had the preventative op in January this year. Im on the other side now, back at the gym and I havent looked back. I had a call back a couple of years ago after my annual surveillance mri, following which I had a guided biopsy. I was so cross with myself, knowing, if it had turned out to be bad news, that I could have prevented it. Fortunately it was good news but it gave me the kick up the bum I needed to proceed with the op.

Everyone ive spoken to that has had bc has told me they'd wished they could have had preventative surgery to avoid treatment.

It's a tough decision but one I'm glad I made.

.

ToastSafeFromMothsAndDogs · 03/11/2026 14:36

curious79 · 03/11/2026 08:06

Ironically, mammograms increase your risk of cancer. They don’t actually do them in some countries, Sweden for a start I think.

You could listen to some of the podcasts hosted by Chris Wark of Chris Beat Cancer. He has interviewed many breast cancer survivors and also Dr Kirsty Funk who is a breast cancer specialist and majors on all the factors you can manage to help prevention. It’s all the stuff we know matters like reduce your weight, do exercise, eat a very clean diet meaning lots of fruit and vegetables, minimal dairy (ideally none) and minimal meat (red, white etc - maybe once pcm) - a lot of us think we have a healthy diet when realistically we don’t when you look at some of the very deep research in this area

I’m BRCA1 and I’ve had a double mastectomy. If you’re going private, I would recommend the surgeon Professor Kefah Mokbel (Princess Grace Hospital London). He is amazing. Indeed, I think it could be worth you going to him for a consultation just to talk about whether he would recommend it for you. I know that may seem like Turkey’s voting for Christmas, but I really don’t think he would recommend the surgery unless he really thought you needed it. He has a very busy practice so wouldn’t need to drum up the business. Including reconstruction at the time, which you can do for preventative, this would end up costing about 40 K +

Edited

Nonsense, in Sweden we have a mammogram every 3 years from 40. So 10 years earlier than in the UK. About 95% of eligible women participate. Survival rates are higher here, unsurprisingly.

nauvemova · 03/11/2026 14:40

ToastSafeFromMothsAndDogs · 03/11/2026 14:36

Nonsense, in Sweden we have a mammogram every 3 years from 40. So 10 years earlier than in the UK. About 95% of eligible women participate. Survival rates are higher here, unsurprisingly.

Do you check for dense breasts? I’ve read 50% of women over 40 can still have dense breasts, I’m just shy of 40 and my lump didn’t show on a mammogram.

nauvemova · 03/11/2026 14:41

And wow that’s an amazing participation rate, I’m sure I read ours was only 60% ish.

BreakfastClub80 · 03/11/2026 14:52

I’ve had breast cancer, as did my sister. Neither of us has tested positive for BRCA gene nor others that they test for currently. So one thing I have learned is that there are new genes being discovered as relevant all the time. Thus, I can see the risk to you is obviously high given your family history.

I think you need to see a specialist, and discuss all the facts. Following my BC, I’m now on medication to eliminate oestrogen and in your case I’d want to know whether you could stay on HRT afterwards too. I’m not sure whether the mastectomy would be all they’d recommend.

Ultimately, no it’s not too drastic a decision. It’s fairly rational given your circumstances and current medical practice.

Mumtoabillion · 03/11/2026 15:53

@nauvemova hi, no I'm not triple negative. My HER2 was positive. Just turned 60. Had never heard mammograms could be bad for you. Somewhere along the chemo process I had bad constipation and -when I asked if they'd scan my bowels- one of the docs said he didn't want any unnecessary scans so maybe this is why I'm starting to wonder what / or if some scans are not good for us. goodness knows.

ToastSafeFromMothsAndDogs · 03/11/2026 16:35

nauvemova · 03/11/2026 14:40

Do you check for dense breasts? I’ve read 50% of women over 40 can still have dense breasts, I’m just shy of 40 and my lump didn’t show on a mammogram.

I don't know, but I suppose there’s awareness within the system that abnormalities can be harder to see or missed in mammograms in women with denser breasts, and that that applies to a higher percentage in the lower age category? But better to catch the cases which can be caught?

Restlessdreams1994 · 03/11/2026 17:04

ToastSafeFromMothsAndDogs · 03/11/2026 16:35

I don't know, but I suppose there’s awareness within the system that abnormalities can be harder to see or missed in mammograms in women with denser breasts, and that that applies to a higher percentage in the lower age category? But better to catch the cases which can be caught?

I have radiologically dense breasts and my cancer wasn’t detected on mammograms initially. I was told if I opted for lumpectomy then I’d have to have annual MRIs for screening rather than mammograms because they couldn’t be sure a mammogram would detect a recurrence.

CrazyMidget · 03/11/2026 17:47

Hi OP, I am pretty much exactly in your shoes. HUGE family history of breast cancer. Every woman on my maternal side, including my mum and her mum, has died of it going back to 1849. (Before 1837, records did not state cause of death.) In addition, there is a great-aunt who died of pancreatic cancer at 27. Given this, and given that the ages at diagnosis are all over the place, the pattern strongly suggests BRCA2.

I was so, so, SO worried. I had the genetic testing, as did my sister. We both came up negative. This strongly suggests that my mother would have tested negative, too.

So, it's a conundrum. Are we negative because we did not get the gene? Or are we negative because we have a mutation that is not yet known?

It's worth remembering that the vast majority of families with a huge breast cancer history test negative for all known mutations. An example of this is the Nolan sisters.

I have seen oncologists about prevention, and one of them said to consider that you can have issues with prophylactic mastectomies and reconstruction, like with any surgical procedure, so that's something to consider.

Honestly, I was all for the idea. But then I calmed down a bit, and what I get is MRIs in addition to mammograms. I have a complicating factor in that my breast density is at the Extreme end - i.e. in the most dense ten per cent, so mammograms can't see much. I believe my mother had this also, as they couldn't see her 3.5cm tumour on the mammo film, even when they knew where it was.

If you don't know your breast density, I would ask your doctor what it is - they should be able to see your mammo film and can tell from that. Because if you have dense breasts, and this family history, that should qualify you for MRIs.

You can also take tamoxifen or anastrozole as chemo-prevention.

It's extremely hard having this hanging over you. I know exactly how you feel. If I were you, I would go back to your doctor and tell them that most families with a big history don't have a mutation, so you don't find the negative test very reassuring. Ask if you can get annual MRIs.

wordsfromthebathroom · 03/11/2026 17:52

Maybe explore this a bit more with your GP. I think your risk is actually not that high/much higher than general population so it might be overkill. You might even have a lower chance overall given your healthy lifestyle. Remember surgery is dangerous too and can cause new issues.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page