Coleman Xtreme or Icey-Tek?

[AGnu]

Someone tell me which one we want? I can't decide! We're planning to start camping for up to a week at a time & don't want to have to go shopping every day. I've finally convinced DH we really do need something bigger & better than our tiny thing that might manage to stay cold for a weekend if half the contents are frozen. I'm being v indecisive & our trip is fast approaching. Anyone want to choose for me?!

I love my Icey Tek.

But think I am paying for its looks, as reviews and perfomance of the Xreme are also really good.

The Xtreme also has a handle, if that helps, bit the Icey Tek has a flat solid surface which i useful for putting things on.

The Xtreme is much cheaper.

Especially when you factor in delivery costs.

So..I love my Icey Tek because I love it, (and it does do a stupendous job) but I suspect that the Xtreme is as good for much less money.

I doubt you will find many people that can give you an honest comparison of both. I've got the Coleman XTreme 50QT and we are really happy with it, if that helps. For extended camps we always take a few extra ice blocks as most sites have a freezer you can recharge them in.