thisisnotwhoyouthink's baby name shortlist

[thisisnotwhoyouthink]

Here's the shortlist of baby names I'm considering that I generated with Mumsnet's Baby Name Finder. Let me know what you think.

Girls
Ashlee
Charlotte
Eleri
Georgina
Scarlett

Am liking this short list function!!

TBH I never really got into the whole baby name thing, boys were really easy, but we are struggling now we are having a girl!!

Middle names might be Rose, Grace or maybe (after my closest sister..) Jane.

What combos do you like? What sounds horrible? Any suggestions for similar names/combos?

We only have five weeks left and with the boys we had decided and finalised with in the FIRST five weeks!!!

I like Charlotte, Eleri and Georgina best. Scarlett makes me think of Gone With The Wind- I like it, but it's a bit too 'dramatic' for me.
Not crazy about Ashlee.

Ashlee - no
Scarlett- I can never get over the fact that it has the word SCAR in it, sorry
Charlotte - nice with good nn possible
Eleri - doesn't excite me
Georgina - like it and not overly used like Charlotte

Don't like any of them sorry

what about

Josephine Jane
Lydia Jane
Olivia Grace
Lily Rose
Mary Rose
Amelia Rose
Lydia Rose
Ella Rose
Kitty Rose
etc etc

Ashlee- Horrid
Charlotte- Nice
Eleri- Loooooooovely- mispronounced a lot-the correct pronounciation is Elerry not Ellery.
Georgina- OK
Scarlett- I like it.

I like Charlotte best and then Scarlett. Dislike Ashlee.

I LOVE Scarlett

Scarlett Rose is fab name

Charlotte is great

Out of those I like Georgina, Charlotte and Scarlett, dislike the others.

Apart from Ashlee, all are very good. Georgina is my sister's name. She gets called Georgy a lot. Charlotte is a very pretty name. Eleri Jane a good combination. Charlotte Rose - extremely pretty. Rose goes with all of them as a middle name.

Charlotte is the nicest. Not keen on Eleri and definitely not on Scarlett since it's a) a surname (Scarlett O'Hara was actually called Kate if I recall correctly and Scarlett was her mother's maiden name) and b) it reminds me of the phrase scarlet woman, which is not really very savoury.

Only Charlotte and Georgina. Eleri is too close to celery.

Charlotte, Eleri and Scarlett are my favourites.

Do you know that Grace and Rose are unbelievably popular as middle names? Personally this would put me off these (otherwise very nice) names.
What about Sian (Welsh form of Jane)?