Sophie?

[bogie]

I really thought I was having another boy, but I have just found out its another girl we had a shortlist
Lydia
Mia
Hazel
Imogen
Rose/Rosie

Now Dp thinks he doesn't really want any of them and he quite likes Sophie or Abigail we already have a Justin and a Phoebe.

I think Sophie is v popular now. I already know two of them born over the past couple of years.

Love the name Hazel, have a friend who had a Hazel last year. beautiful name.

Justin
Phoebe
Sophie

Sound fine together, though personally I would avoid giving siblings names where a phoneme recurs (in this case the -ee ending).

I think you need another two syllabled name, and probably a name less usual than Sophie since Justin and Phoebe are a bit less common IMO.

Justin
Phoebe
Muriel

I really want willow now
Justin
Phoebe
Willow

Sounds better imo but dp not keen
I will start working on it I am sure I canchange his mind.