Lawrence - not one I'd choose
Bartholemew - like it
Jonah - like it (and Noah)
Luke - prtty common where I am
Bryce (well my dad is Bruce, so its similar)- sounds like a surname not one I'd pick
Gabriel (tried last time - DH said NO) - I really like it
Barnaby - Fab (quite a cute name I think)
Jeremiah (Jem) - Equally fab
Nathaniel ( I like Nate, or Natt, rather than Nathan)....another good one
Evan - not sure, I'm not keen on names that can be first names or surnames
Nicholas - traditional
Noah - YEAH!!!
Irving - Berlin? Washington? Makes me think of catch 22 not keen at all
Reuben - Fab
Charles (I really like Charlie, but DH says NO and it is pretty common)- what about Edward (eddie) instead?
Sylvester (hmm, brings to mind a cat or a M'coy)- I agree
Rory (tried last time - DH hates but I still like) love it.
What about
Benedict
Dominic (dom or Nic)
Theo (dore)
Myles
Daniel
Aaron
Jacob (Jake)
Good luck with the naming