Two babies, Two names 😬 HELP!

[PerkyPearlHedgehog]

Hiya everyone,
I was wondering if you’d be able to help with naming our upcoming boy/girl twins!!!
We have managed to narrow it down to a shortlist for each however we seem to be a bit stuck. I’d really appreciate any feedback (good or bad!) and maybe any other suggestions although most we have already discounted for various reasons. Middle names will be Catherine and James.
Girls:
Anna
Harriet
Alice
Beatrice
Phoebe

Boys:
Benjamin
Isaac
Jack
Alexander
William

Thank you so much!

I think a three syllable first name would go better with Catherine. Or why not turn it round and habe Catherine as a first name. Catherine Alice would be my favourite.

You can’t have twins called Alice and Alexander

Ignore the middle names for now.
Choose the names you like best, make sure they go with each other and with the surname.

Alex and Alice are too similar.
Jack James is effectively James James.

Harriet and Benjamin

Anna and William

phoebe and alexander

Anna and Alexander

Harriet & Alexander for me

Anna Catherine and William James

Could James be used as first name? My favourite name!

Anna and James
Harriet and James

love

Phoebe & Isaac 😍

Anna and William

Phoebe and Benjamin for me!

Anna and Isaac.

I like your girls names a lot, I like Alice Catherine the most I think.

less keen on your boys names - jack and Isaac just feel a bit… uninspired? Every third child is called jack.. I’d go Alexander nn xander (but not with Alice) or William from the list. Alice and William are a bit of a meh combo too. So probably Beatrice or Phoebe and Alexander if those are the only boy choices..

Have you thought about other traditional boys names Henry, James, Edward, George , Timothy?

All nice.
I would choose John not Jack.

My faves
Anna Catherine
Phoebe Cathwrine
Alice Catherine
John James
Alexander James
William James

Anna and John
Phoebe and Alexander
Alice and William

I like Phoebe and Isaac

Alice and William

Girl - Anna or Phoebe

Boy - All fine, like Isaac best.

Loads of lovely options. I'm not keen on Alice and I'd swerve Beatrice, because that plus Catherine is a bit too royal.

William James was an American psychologist which is probably fine. Benjamin James sounds like a brand to me, though I am not sure. I would Google first name surname for them all to see if anything comes up.

Alice and Benjamin. My top names forever.

Harriet & Alexander are lovely together - Hattie & Alex so sweet!
All lovely names though so I don’t think you can go wrong - congratulations!

Anna and Benjamin

Anna and Alexander

I wouldn't go for Harriet and Alexander in case they became Harry and Alex/Ali.

Harriet or Alice with William.
Anna or Phoebe with Isaac.