Romy or Eden for a girl?

[emeraldrainbow]

Thoughts?

I like Romy. How about Romilly with Romy as a potential nickname?

Not so keen on Eden. I know a lovely girl with the name (Catholic, not Jewish), but it still hasn't grown on me.

The Romy I know is short for Ramona. I think both are lovely.
Eden is very pretty.

Dd is Romy!

I have the Schneider association as well with Romy. Her actual name was Rosemarie afaik.

Eden is lovely! It is (obviously) a name with a lot of religious significance, which parents should consider (and appreciate) when naming a child Eden (at least in my opinion).

I know 2 Romy's and they are both boys do i'd personally go with Eden for a girl

Eden is nice. Not keen on Romy

Personally hate the name Eden. Not sure why.

Romy is fairly cute. Out of the two definitely hands down Romy is my preference.

Neither are really to my taste but I prefer Eden of the two

They are both beautiful names, in my opinion.

Romilly

Really like Romy but think Eden is pretty too.

The only Edens I know are from culturally quite hippie/ alternative families, and their names were definitely not inspired by religion of any stripe. The oldest would be in her early 30s at this point and the younger three are mid 20s and 4.

The Edens I know (four different families) have sisters Aria, Freya, Kismet, Tatum, and Lilac, and brothers Glenn, Bodhi, and Thor.

I have a Romy, she’s awesome 🤩 Get lots of compliments on her name. Only downside is that Boris Johnson named one of his children the same name. 🤮

I don’t like Eden due to the Garden of reference and Eve stealing the apple etc. just don’t like that for a girl.

In the USA?

My best mate is called Eden. Beautiful name. I know someone called Romy too and I do like that, but I prefer Eden.

Both lovely names , I have a Romy and she loves her name!

I know girls and boys with the name Eden, it’s very pretty.

I like them both.

how about Roma? Bit different but Remi?

Both lovely names. My favourite is Eden, I love Edie.

I like both of them, Eden makes me think of one of the Barbara Vine novels.

I think Mick Hucknall's daughter is called Romy, for some reason I assumed it was Italian because of his love of Italy. I had no idea it had German roots.

I know a Romy short for Rosamund, and the only Eden I know is a boy.