Which girls name from these two

[Jetsmummy123]

Please help us decide

Elizabeth nn Lizzy or Libby
Anna nn Annie

I’m Elizabeth Anne and my daughter is Annie. Great names OP ;)

I like Anna (no nickname needed imo) or Libby

Anna Elizabeth is perfect.

Anna

Elizabeth/Libby

Id pick Elizabeth / Libby, I think Libby is such a lovely nickname - I prefer a longer name with lots of nickname options.
Anna is also a very pretty name.

Elizabeth

Elizabeth but no diminutive (Lizzie or Libby are not nicknames)

As a PP said, "Why is MN obsessed with "nicknames"

Both lovely , I would go for Anna/ Annie

Annie

They aren’t nicknames. They are a shortened version of the full name.

Anna

Elizabeth.

Anna is okay but Annie is dismal,

Elizabeth... Beth, Betty, Eliza, Liz, Lizzy, Lizbet Liza.... so many more variations.

Anna and this.

Anna but not Annie.
If Annie, then Elizabeth nn Libby.

Anne Elizabeth - "Anne E/ Annie"

Elizabeth.

I wouldn't shorten it.

I like Eliza and would have loved it for Dd, but I didn’t think of it at the time. I do love Anna Elizabeth, so classic.

My 20yo DD has a good friend Libby and one of my good friends is Lizzie.

Anna

Annie

Both lovely but I’m biased!

They’re both lovely!

I might be a little biased in favour of Anna so that one would get my vote. But Elizabeth is nice as well… wait until you meet her and try which one feels right / suits her better?

Elizabeth is actually quite beautiful but Liz is such an ugly nickname. It’s a personal choice but i chose a short name for a reason. I pretty much dislike all nicknames (Liz, Sam, Jo, Becky, Dave, Andy, Phil etc). What’s the point of a name if it just gets changed to something else.

Anna, but I wouldn't use Annie as a nickname.

Anna but I would ditch the nick name.
Eliza - also without a nick name.