Maisie, Holly, or Penelope

[LolaBumble]

Finding it super tricky to think of a baby name! We already have a Poppy. I love Penelope but I worry Penny would be to close to Poppy…

Holly is my favourite of the three. Lovely name.

The only one I like is Penelope but I agree that Penny is too close to Poppy.

I love all three. I think you could get away with Penelope with Poppy, maybe you could use Nell for short?

My favourite is Holly.

Definitely Penelope. We are awash with Maisies and Hollys

They're ok. But don't particularly like any of the three very much

I feel like Poppy and Holly are quite similar too, maybe the plant theme and double letter-y ending?
maisie, meh, I can’t get past that mouse!
Poppy and Heidi
Poppy and Freya
Poppy and Maeve
Poppy and Clara
Poppy and Nina
Poppy and Nancy

Penelope and call her Nelly.

Poppy and ..
Iris
Daisy
Maisie

Holly is my favourite, beautiful name. Maisie is also nice

I love all these ❤️ I think Holly is my favourite followed by Maisie

I love Penelope, a beautiful name and there are SO many Maisies and Hollys. Not that there's anything wrong with that and they're popular for a reason, but a little Penelope would be so refreshing in comparison.

Maisie always sounds like it is short for something to me?

Penelope is my favourite but yes, Penny and Poppy is a bit much.

Holly is nice, if a little bland, but I also think it’s too similar to Poppy.

Maisie is as pedestrian a name as you can get, sorry!

Adelaide
Annabelle
Nora
Sadie
Isabella
Ada
Daphne
Edie

Yes, Poppy and Penny is too twee.

I love Holly. Maisie is too cutesy for me.

I love the name Holly. All the Hollys I know are great.

I really dislike Penelope and Penny for short.

Maisie is quite cute. But Holly is the best.

Penelope is lovely, or another name with a similar vibe is Philippa.

Yes I think Poppy and Penny would be too close for sisters, very twee but then I also think Poppy and Holly is a bit twee too.
So that leaves Maisie which is a perfectly nice name and has a similar cutsie vibe as Poppy

I like Maisie best

Penelope.

Penelope by a long way. Poppy and Penny aren't too cutesie in my view and I am a fusspot about such things.

Penelope is the nicest by far imo. Just go with that and don't call her Penny? Can you shorten to Nell? Not sure it's a traditional shortening of Penelope but maybe. There's also Pen, but that's not so nice

Penelope is on the rise. I’ve heard 3 different Penelope’s under 3 in the last 2 weeks - SE/Greater London. It is a nice name though.

I like the suggestions above of Poppy and Freya or Poppy and Nancy.

Nancy is lovely

Thank you for all your replies! 🫶🫶 given me a lot to think about

A few suggestions for Freya and I do love this name as well!! Feels like such a massive decision, agonising over it much more than with my first x