What does everyone think of these names

[Rosbo]

Carmen for a girl
and Hugh for a boy?

[toomuchmonthatendofthemoney]

Carmen is a very pretty name and sorry, makes me think a)mad opera wifie or b)carmen miranda and mad fruitbowl hat. But i do like it!

Hugh, Hugh Barney McGrew Custard Dibble and...

Hugh is ok but not inspiring imo. does it sit nicely with surname?

[BabieWabbit]

Love Carmen...It's one of my favorite names, I Think Hugh is lovely too

[Rosbo]

well surname is smith.
goes with anything really, except Romy, the name I really liked for a girl!

[Servalan]

Carmen - fab, fab, fab

Hugh is OK (don't have any strong opinions either way)

[SlartyBartFast]

like hugh
not keen on carmen

[snice]

What about Romilly Smith?

[ObsidianBlackbirdMcNight]

Carmen is nice. Hugh is not particularly exciting or offensive, like John. So if that's what you are going for that's not bad!

[bringmesunshine]

Don't like Carmen. Hugh....a bit bland I think personally.

[SlartyBartFast]

hugh is a good scottish name, for john i think??

[MrsMattie]

Not keen on Hugh at all. Conjures up posh Hugh Grant types.

Carmen is beautiful.

[CrackerOfNuts]

Not keen on either tbh.

[PestoMonster]

I don't like either of them, sorry. Carmen reminds me of Carmen-Miranda with fruit on her head and Hugh, well, just no, really.

[loler]

Why doesn't Romy Smith work? I prefer I think it's a prettier name than Carmen.

[ChippyMinton]

Love Romilly (there's a TV news reporter called Romilly Weeks IIRC) and Romy (Romy & Michelle's High School Reunion - movie)
Quite like Hugh spelt Huw

[claraquitetirednow]

Hugh no but Huey yes, Hugo yes.

[pointydog]

Shug - nickname for Hugh

[choosyfloosy]

What's wrong with Romy?

Love Romilly too.

Just personally I don't fancy Carmen Smith as a name but that's just me and I would no doubt like it once I got to know the person.

Hugh I am not tremendously keen on but it's fine. Nice with Smith.

[Shitemum]

Carmen Smith reminds me of the film 'Carmen Jones'
Really sorry but don't think Carmen and Smith sit well together. It's like the Carmen is a desperate attempt to jazz up the Smith iyswim. No offense...
I would go for something with more syllables.

[LynetteScavo]

I love Hugh for a boy... went to school with a real cow called Carmen, so that has clouded my judgement.

[dizzydixies]

love them both

[treacletart]

Carmen's great.

I like Hugo better than Hugh - I think more than one syllable is better with Smith

[stripeytiger]

I like Carmen. Hugh....not sure, but its a sound, sensible name, can't be shortened but could be lengthened to Hughie