Help settle an argument

[Amylivida]

My DH can't agree on a name and baby girl is due soon, we've narrowed it down to two favourites each,
Mine: Lucy and Matilda
His: Isla and Evie

What do you think of these names?

I love Matilda- congratulations on your pregnancy!

Lucy is the best.

Rest are too popular.

I like Lucy best followed by Isla. (I'm Scottish so it's a good traditional name here.)

Matilda has me humming "revolting children" (the musical!) and for me Evie is a Pokémon.

Whichever sits best with the initial of her surname or whichever flows best with surname. They're all so popular so your DD will very likely be Lucy B or Isla M etc.

Isla may be popular but defo my fave! Although I don't know any Isla's I do know Lucy's & Evie's

Lucy, without a doubt.

Lucy is the only one I like.

It's my husband's favourite name but I refused to use it for our daughters on the grounds that we already had a cat with that name!

Probably Lucy as the others are v popular
With maybe Lucia as a full name, which she might like when she’s older

Second choice Matilda - which I personally like better as more grown up.

Matilda was v popular a while back, but not as relentlessly done to death as the other two Avoid Evie in particular - some classes are two thirds girls called Eve/Eva/Evie/Evelyn/Ava with along with all the Ellies means you practically have to number them. All the other girls will be called Isla, Isabella and Isabel.

Names that might be similar but not so overdone

Lois
Zoe
Nancy
Cassia nn Cassie
Miranda
Marina (nn Marnie if you want)
Jessica nn Jessie
Stella
Estella
Clara

I definitely like your choices better, especially Lucy. I kind of like Evie but I don't think I would use it as a full name - she might prefer to be Eve (which I really like) when she's older.

Lucy is so nice. Definitely my favourite.

Isla and Evie are also good names but very overdone at the moment.

Not a fan of Matilda...can't stand Tilly or Tilda.

Lucy Isla Surname works really well.

Lucy

I prefer your choices. And if you don’t have a middle name already picked, I would go with Lucy Matilda if that works with your surname.

And the opposite to a PP, I LOVE the name Tilda. As both a nickname and a stand-alone name.

Lucy is the winner