Spelling help needed!

[AlpacaMeBags]

DD is nearly 3 weeks old. We've decided on a name for her but can't make a decision about spelling.

She's called Maia/Maya - pronounced My-a.

Originally we'd gone with Maia (my preference -i prefer the history of it and I think Maya could end up May-a) but people seem confused by the spelling.

Which would you go for?

Maia

I would pronounce Maia (My-ah) to rhyme with Gaia
I would pronounce Mia (me-ah) like Mia Farrow
And for Maya I would be tempted to say May-uh but I would probably ask first

I'd pronounce Maia as My-ah, and Maya as May-ah.

The only option which would have no confusion is Mya.

Both Maia and Maya look like they sound different to different people. Mya is just Mya imo.

Maia which is very pretty and surely is the traditional spelling.
It is not uncommon where I live, and not hard to say.

And if you are unsure, still, perhaps go with ..
Miranda
Mara
Mary
Minerva
Moira