Second baby girl name

[Mummytutoo]

Stuck on baby girl names for second girl! First born called Katie. Current options for second are
Emily
Imogen,
Holly,
Charlotte,
Chloe,
Amy

Struggling this time round and don't have long to go!

Definitely Imogen! Imogen is beautiful.

I love Amy, Charlotte, Chloe and Emily.
If your first is Katie I think Amy and Katie are wonderful. If you first is Katherine/variation, I think Katherine & Charlotte are wonderful

Anyway you got wonderful list.

Emily

As you already have a Katie I think I'd stay away from other -ee sounding names. I like Imogen, what about Emma (instead of Emily)?

Love Holly and Charlotte.

Emily is lovely

I like Holly best

Imogen or Charlotte for sure! The rest are okay, but Imogen and Charlotte are lovely!

I'm personally not mad keen on Imogen or Chloe but I think they others are lovely and I think they all work well with Katie.

My baby is called Charlotte and we love the name! You have to accept she might want to be Lottie or Charley when old enough to decide though.

Also I have 2 nieces who are sisters and they are Katie and Ellie.

Emily - cute but very overdone
Imogen - I can never really get used to this because it reminds me too much of "innocent" but it's classic.
Holly - cute, it's on our list.
Charlotte - not a fan, seems slightly out of fashion.
Chloe - this also seems a bit 90s but it's fine.
Amy - feels very 90s and dated.

I would pick Holly.

Then Imogen, Emily, Chloe, Amy (no real preference).

Then Charlotte.

My favourites would be Emily or Holly

Of that lot I would go for Imogen or Emily - both very popular (Imogen lately and Emily for a while) but fairly classic like Katie.

Charlotte is lovely but really has been done to death, and two two-syllable names ending in y is too twee / matchy matchy

Constance
Caroline
Marianne
Lois
Anna / Hannah / Annalise
Clare
Juliet
Louise
Ida
Stella
Frances
Beatrice nn Bea
Penelope

Might all be options

Love Imogen and Holly. Have you considered Anna?

I agree with previous poster, it really comes down to whether Katie is the given name or a nickname.

If it's a given name, I'd avoid anything that is too sophisticated by comparison.
As pp said Katherine/Charlotte (or Imogen or Emily even) have the same sort of vibe.

Katie (as a given name) gels better, to me anyway!, with Amy or Chloe.

Good luck!

I think Amy, Charlotte or Emily go best with Katie but the others are ok too. I don't like Imogen purely because the one I know goes by Imo and it's just such an ugly nn. I wonder if the two names ending in "ee" is a bit too much though?
Katie & Alice
Katie & Anna
Katie & Emma
Katie & Sarah
Katie & Hannah
Katie & Laura
Katie & Lydia
Katie & Stella
Katie & Megan

She is officially a Katherine, so may well go by Kate or Katherine when she's older and can choose