Thoughts on this combos?

[PoemBeatrice]

we are considering these names:
August Roland Hart
Cedric Amaury Storm
Magnus Roland
Cecily Beatrice
Charlotte Idony
Juliet Melusine Flora

Try hard to be ‘special’ and ‘unique’ in the way teenagers do. Of course I can imagine that someone just likes them - but if you ask other people’s opinions then you presumably want to hear if others just don’t like them.

I had accidentally cleared by browsing data in weekly computer manteinance, and my login and password are deleted. It's me PoemBeatrice.

Kanaloa, you're wrong about me. I'm 27.

Why would rugby and football over tennis and cricket mean no class or culture?

Private school certainly has nothing to do with class or culture either, it's money and attitude.

What an odd comment.

No I meant common decency and basic respect to other people..... If you want to call rolling with pigs a culture then sure
So because I gave a half hashed idea of "posh", none of which was offensive, I have no common decency or basic respect and like to roll with pigs. Okaaaaay then

I like Cecily Beatrice and Magnus Roland.

I also like Melusine (which is a name, I have heard of it - and it's really not much flowerier than Melanie or Melissa) and Charlotte, but not in those combinations. I never understand the love for Juliet - the story is so bleakly tragic. Cedric would work in continental Europe, but not in the UK, I think. Adding Amaury and Storm makes it a hell of a burden as a name, tbh.

August, given its meaning, goes a bit far IMO (though I think Magnus OK - not sure why, I'm aware it's a bit contradictory). And you'll have a lot of people pronouncing it like the month.

It wasn't meant as a definitive answer, although according to OP my opinion shows I have no class or culture (she def doesn't understand the definition of that one), no common decency and I like to roll with pigs.

For those wondering about Melusine, she was a woman in folklore, said to be half fish, or half serpent. There are lots of different versions of the tale, but a common one is that she marries a man but makes him promise not to see her bathing, and when he breaks the promise, she flies away through the window. She was said to have been the ancestor of the Luxembourg royal house, and through them of the Plantagenets.

I think "try hard" is about the laziest insult on the name board Tbf. Anything left of the top 50 is accused of being try hard, pretentious etc., as if people liking different things means they must be pretending to be someone else. But whom? If I'm trying hard to come across as someone else who'd name their kids Persephone and Amadeus then surely that suggests some people are allowed to like those names. Why not me?

If you like Roland, how about Orlando (same name)?

I don't like Storm- makes me think of the Gladiators (you may be too young to remember them) and thus strikes me as a girl's name.

The rest are lovely, although nb no one really thinks about middle names for more than 5 minutes after they're chosen so focus on the first name.

I think "try hard" is about the laziest insult on the name board Tbf. Anything left of the top 50 is accused of being try hard, pretentious etc., as if people liking different things means they must be pretending to be someone else. But whom? If I'm trying hard to come across as someone else who'd name their kids Persephone and Amadeus then surely that suggests some people are allowed to like those names. Why not me?

Well said I agree with you and don't understand why people accuse others of
´trying hard' when all they're doing is liking a name?!

Magnus Roland

juliet melusine flora

August - love
Cedric - haaaaaaate
Magnus - cool hipstery name of the moment
Cecily - a bit wet but not as awful as Cecil on a man
Charlotte - pedestrian
Juliet - lovely

I love Magnus and Juliet. Magnus makes me think of Magnus Maximus/Macsen Wledig. I quite like Cecily too.

Thanks to PP who explained about Melusine - knew the name rang a bell! I quite like it and Idony.

August is fine, not to my taste but nothing wrong with it. Same with Beatrice, Flora and Charlotte.

Cecily Juliet would be a nice combination. Juliet Cecily too but I think Cecily Juliet flows better.

You might like Clarissa, Larissa, Marisa and Marissa? Ooh and Iseult, Isolde or Sabrina? (My fantasy twin girls are Alys Juliet and Mari Sabrina)

Some of the middle names you have are unusual but they won't be used much day to day unless the child wants to use them. Most of the time at school and work they'll be Juliet Surname or Magnus Surname.

Are you planning on saying it SED-rick OR SEE-drick? That would alter my opinion... I really like the latter, but the former is, as PPs have said, a bit weedy-sounding and 'meh'