Edgar vs Eugene nn Gene

[Pictureperfect3rdtime]

Which one would take your vote? I prefer Eugene nn gene. Edgar is lovely as a full name but do not like Ed/Eddy nn.

Eugene is an appalling name.

Edgar is great but you may well get Ed/Eddie.

Sorry, both are awful.

Edwin is my fav name.

Edgar

Really don’t like the other two, they make me think of slimey guys in bars

Edgar. nn Egg (this life)

I have an Edgar :) We get lots of compliments on it. We were going to call him Ted as a nickname, but I found I actually quite like Eddy and it suits him. Highly recommend.