Narrowed it down now can't decide!

[Violetandpurple]

Matilda - always loved and love the nn options
Alice - love that it's timeless and suits all ages but unsure if I love it or just know it pleases people?
Maisie - it's very pretty and love that I could use May as a nn as that's a family name but using May as a first name doesn't match our surname

I know many feel Maisie is too cutesy but I personally don't get that vibe from it, especially with the different names around these days.

So which do you prefer?

Love Matilda and Maisie.

I'm a teacher - never taught a Maisie and only taught one Matilda.

Maisie

Matilda's are ten a penny in my area so it lost its appeal long ago even though it was a nice ice always been fond of

Alice is nice but it doesn't sound like you really want to use it

Maisie is lovely and I like May and the family connection

Alice is beautiful

Matilda

LOVE Matilda and like Alice. Maisie is quite wet and meh for me, but if you get different vibes from
It that’s what counts.

I have a Mathilda and only met a couple of others. Only one other at her largeish secondary school. She's never ever been Tilly. She's Mathilda mostly or Tilda occasionally. Her v good friends sometimes call her Matty.

Matilda

Alice gets my vote

Alice. We almost had an Alice, but went with Alba.

Instead of a Tilly you can go for Tilda. Matilda and Alice are my dds middle names so I like both not keen on Maisie but it’s a perfectly fine name.

Alice is my favourite! Matilda and Maisie are cute for small kids but not fond of them for adults.

Alice or Matilda. Both lovely names.

Definitely not Maisie, it's so twee and cutesy it makes my teeth itch.

Matilda