Help! A girls name after 3 boys…

[Honey2]

I always thought it would be easy to name a little girl after having to come up with 3 boys names. But I’m really struggling!

This is my short list -

Imogen
Heidi
Esme
Amber
Anya

Not very short! Any thoughts? Don’t want something likely to be really common.

Thanks xx

I really like Amber.

I like them all.

But Imogen or Heidi for me from your list.

I also like Phoebe and Matilda.

@itsgettingweird ahhh I think they are my top 2! Do you have a preference?

Imogen! So many girls names end in an ee or uh sound that I prefer those which don't.

Amber and Esme for me
Never liked Heidi
Imogen is quite popular
Anya is a little harsh sounding for me

Other ideas:
Amara
Maya

Imogen is lovely and has an elegant Shakespearean feel - but is quite popular (as is pretty Esme).

International Anya is beautiful though and not overused.

Amber is okay (don't love or hate), but Heidi is not my taste, sorry (I don't know why but I find it a bit cutesy sounding).

Other similar suggestions - May, Lara, Nina, Cora, Sylvie.

I like your list my dd is Imogen so that’s my favourite, she’s 15 now but it was popular for about 5 years after her birth. I work in a school and for the first time in 5 years there isn’t an Imogen in ks2.
I also like Heidi and Anya from your list.

I like them all. Imogen is probably my favourite, I've heard Esme is very popular.

@IggyAce thanks - looking in naming site Imogen seemed to peak in 2010 and then fall. I don’t mind a few in the same school - just not 2 in every class! I think it’s my fav so far.

@IamnotwhouthinkIam thanks for your comments, we are actually thinking it May, Mae or Rae for the middle name.

I really like the name Imogen

Oh I love Imogen. If I'd had a second girl, she'd have been Imogen Hope.

Imogen is my favourite on your list. It's a beautiful name.

I also likea the names Jemima, Tabitha, Samantha, Annika, Tallulah

I really like them all... except Imogen which I really dislike...such a frumpy, ugly name

I love Imogen and Amber. Always disliked Heidi for some reason.

Amber
Anya
Esme…in that order, I personally don’t like the other 2

Imogen and Heidi are my favourites, both are lovely names.
I like Amber too.
But not keen on Esme or Anya.

Of your list, I like Amber best.

Definitely Imogen it's lovely. What are your boys names to give an idea of how they'd all go together

I like Heidi best; esme and Anya are ok. I think Amber is a bit dated and Imogen I’ve never been able to get on board with but lots think it’s lovely

@platerspinner my boys are Alex, Isaac and Ruben….

Imogen is a lovely name. I also like Lydia, Claudia, Grace, Lottie, Clara, Florence, Eva, Hannah x

Imogen - love, but not keen on Imo, Immy, Ginny etc.
Heidi - bit twee, cute for a little girl, ot great for a woman. See also: Daisy
Esme - pretty, but a bit overdone and possible pronunciation issues.
Amber - like, but has a slightly dated feel to it, a bit like Hazel.
Anya - ok, nicer than Anna

• Sorry, not Hazel, Heather

[quote Honey2]@platerspinner my boys are Alex, Isaac and Ruben….[/quote]
Oh Imogen fits perfectly!

Imogen 100%