Final two names - Aidan or Isaac?

[PumpkinSoup21]

Which should we go for and why? Aidan or Isaac.
DS is three weeks old and I can’t decide which suits better.

Both lovely names.
I'd go for Aidan

I would definitely go for Aidan. I hear of a lot of toddlers called Hayden and Jayden and things, but not Aidan - which is tons nicer and more substantial.

Isaac is really nice too, but I know a lot of kids and teens with Jacob/Noah/Isaac type Old Testament names, so it feels a bit of its time for me (late 90s to early 2000s). Whereas Aidan had been used over a couple of generations now, without getting too popular.

Aiden

I prefer Aidan.

Isaac's seem to be everywhere and whilst it's a lovely name it's becoming a bit meh due to popularity

Aidan has a slight dated feel but that doesn't bother me, it's a lovely, and currently underused name

I love both but if had to choose I'd go for Aidan.

Isaac

Aidan

I've always liked Aidan.
Both nice names though imo.

Definitely Isaac, it's much nicer!

Aiden has become somewhat of a meme name recently.

Well the positive thing is there’s clearly love for both names!
@MondayYogurt - how do you mean a ‘meme name’?

Isaac

Aidan

I’m due in April and if it’s a boy It will likely be Aidan

I think they’re both nice, would probably go over Aidan first but: does one provide initials which are trickier to deal with than another?

Isaac

Hi op, just that it's a name phenomenon that has been discussed a lot on reddit and memes have been made about it.
AFAIK the same does not apply to Isaac as a name.

I work in a school and aidan is so popular there were 3 in reception class plus 2 kaiden’s

Aidan