Opinions: Freja or Freida (with a middle name Naomi)

[Isahlo]

Sister to Astrid.
Surname double barrelled but two very common short names (think Smith-Jones)

I thought I was set on Frieda, but I don’t think it goes as well with Naomi as Freja.
(Middle name is a non negotiable)

Any advice greatly received. (Am reluctant to anglicise Freja to Freya, as my family name didn’t work with our names, so would like to keep a bit of heritage going)
Thanks

I prefer Freja “with a j”

Frieda 100%

I prefer Freida (though I prefer the Frida spelling). Freja/Freya has been done to death and it feels a bit dull as a result.

Freida. I think I prefer it. Also your daughter would be forever having to specify ‘freja with a J’

I love Freja.
Frieda I'm unsure about, although it does go well with Astrid.
The popularity of Freja / Freya wouldn't bother me. I never taught one nor do I know any.

Difficult if you are in the UK as I think both will be misspelt (where as Astrid is straightforward). I think Frida is a much better known spelling here - would that work with your heritage? Frida/Freida Naomi sounds nice to me.

I think both sound good with Naomi and in reality the full name is not said often enough for their flow to have a strong influence in this case. I say choose the first name you like the best.

You shouldn't discount the name you love because the runner up name goes better with the middle name. The two are said aloud together, once every few months maybe? Cannot for the life of me remember the last time I had to tell anyone my middle name.

If in UK I'd go Freya for ease of pronunciation and spelling. Can be a pita being misspelt/ pronounced etc.

I have genetic Germanic/ Scandinavian girls names for my two as well!

Having said that if you're canvassing opinion, personally I'd prefer to be called Freja than Freida.

Freida Naomi!! Stunning combination x

Freja is a much nicer name than Freida.

Freya

Frieda Naomi is lovely. It sounds a lot fresher than Freja/Freya, but is still a known name.

Is the Freida spelling correct? I read it as Fry-da.
The Frida spelling is nicer.

Freja would be nice but there are so many Freyas that it seems dull and she'll be Freja-with-a-J or Frejja

Also prefer Frida rather than Freida.

Freak is a bit boring nowadays I think

I LOVE Naomi. Such an underused beautiful name. 😍 Does it have to be a middle name?

Astrid and Naomi go together really well.

Naomi Frida Smith-Jones. 💕

FYI Frieda Naomi sounds Jewish to me (I am Jewish and have both those names in my extended family). Probably not an issue for you but just to make you aware

I prefer Frida. I wouldn’t be sure it wasn’t Fry da or Fray da otherwise.

Freida Naomi rolls nicely of the tongue imo.

I like Freida with Astrid they go together without being obviously a set.

Freja is lovely.