Which name would you choose

[Namechangin101]

Vincent (Vinnie) or Finlay?

Im set on one of these names so don't need any suggestions. Thanks

Thank you for all the replies! It seems that Finlay is preferred but very common. Its not a huge issue but we have a very common surname so worry there could be problems with other boys in school having the same name.

I know I said no suggestions but what do you think of Oscar?

I prefer Finlay to Oscar. If the name being common is an issue, you could use an unusual middle name.
e.g. John Xerxes Smith

I think Oscar or Vincent are much nicer than Finlay