Which name is best?!

[Rt23]

Hello! I’m expecting a baby girl at the end of summer and my husband and I have got down to two final names… which one would you go for?
Marnie or Margot?
The middle name will probably be Joy! Thanks!

As long as you don't mind both names rising significantly in popularity! There are so many of both in my local area all under 5.
Other M names to consider are
Merryn
Minnie
Marlowe
Meryl
Maya
Mahalia
Mindy

While I much prefer Marnie as a nn (for Marina, Marianne, Mariana etc), because as a given name it's slightly trendy, I still like it better than Margot which is extremely trendy now imo and rapidly rising, so will date more of the two I think.

Love Marnie
Both nice though

Margaret, called Margot for short. So much more flexible...

Marnie by a mile. I just cannot understand the appeal of Margot, I know mumsnet seems to love it but I really don’t like it at all.

Marnie is cuter on a baby but sounds like a nickname for an adult
Margot is more adaptable through life - and quite posh!

Margot.

Margot is frumpy, harsh and horrible. Also looks like Maggot. Marnie is much better.

Margot.

Margot is classy and cool.
Marnie is down-at-heel trailer park.

Margot.

Marnie by miles.

Margot is such an ugly name.

Margot - much classier and goes better with Joy. I wouldn’t go with the Margaux spelling, it’s a wine.

Wouldn't Margeaux be the plural of Margot?

Margaux Joy :)

I do not like the name Marnie.

@Benvolio

Wouldn't Margeaux be the plural of Margot?

Margaux

Wow real split opinion… helpful comments. thanks all!

I prefer Marnie and I've only ever met one who would be around 14 now.

Margot seems to be very popular atm, I keep hearing baby Margot's (or Nancy's) everywhere atm but I'm not a fan

Margot. I think Marnie will age badly

I love the Margaux spelling too!

Both names are lovely.

I really dislike both, sorry. I would go back to the drawing board.

Love Marnie.
Marnie Joy is lovely.

Margot is awful. As is the other spelling of it. Very 1970's hostess trolley esque imo.

I love Margot!

Marnie

Absolutely love Margot. If you're going to play with the spelling I would go Margo without the T. Margaux is like calling your child Chardonnay or Pinot.