Favourite old fashioned/traditional/vintage baby names?

[Froel1982]

Hello!

I am looking for name inspiration for baby number 2. I have an Eliza already, and would love something that fits with her name.

My taste is more classic traditional, but the hubby would probably go for something traditional but a bit more unusual (if that makes sense!) He doesn't seem to like the most popular traditional names. Any ideas? What are your favourites? For a boy or girl.

Wilfred
Alfred
Charles
Stanley
Percy
George
Albert
Benjamin
Samuel

Pearl
Hattie
Mabel
Millicent
Emmeline
Catherine/Kitty
Nancy

I like Charlotte and H/Eloise

For boys I like George, Robert, Magnus and Jack

Maisie
Josephine
Louisa
Dulcie
Phoebe
Patsy
Katie
Annie
Mabel
Sally
Abigail

Vincent
Timothy
Philip
Matthew
Daniel
David
Abel
Jeremy

Anne
Audrey
Charlotte
Caris
Elizabeth
Francine
Harriet
Margaret
Mary
Louise
Rose
Sally

Daniel
Edward
Joseph
George
Jack
Michael
Patrick

Maud
Verity
Hester

George
Gregory
Matthew

Polly
Martha
Frances

Patrick
Francis
Edgar

Emily
Rose
Rosamund
Edith
Maria
Margaret

vera
ida
ena
rene
wendy
cathleen
rose
ivy
edith
lynn
marguerite
patricia
elsie

wilfred
fredrick
arthur
albert
graham
ronald
reginald
victor
fraiser

Molly
Harriet
Dulcie

Herbie
Monty
Nicholas

It's a bit subjective to ask for our favourites when you have your own style.
Not everyone likes vintage names. Not that they are, but My favorite names could be Jayden and Chardonnay.
I can give you suggestions though on what you might like

Tom
Henry
George
Archie
Teddy
Dougie
Arthur
Cecil
Percy
Jeffrey
Vincent
Lawrence
Patrick
Trevor
Richard

Mabel
Alice
Gladys
Maud
Flora
Clara
Sarah
Helen
Violet
Peggy
Tessa
Rosa
Cassie
Olive
Julia
Miriam
Iris
Ivy
Jane
Martha
Mary
Maria
Catherine.
Vera
Winnie
Josie
Patty
Linda
Lois
Marlene

Peter.
Ray
Ralph

Janet
Gloria
Dolly.

Horace.
Maurice
Hector.
Ivan

Lucy
Penelope
Lottie

Arthur
Albert
Edward
Charles
Douglas

Charlotte
Daisy
Connie
Rachel

Not completely traditional but both my boys have traditional names and these are some that I like

Eunice
Forestine
Eudora
Diedre (pronounced the Irish way)
Elvira
Ethel
Aude
Enid
Flavia
Celeste nn CeCe
Estella
Fenella

Cedric
Gilbert
Ernest
Phineas
Herbert
Silas
Simeon

Alice
Mabel
Anna

Jude
Luke
Paul

Eliza is an traditional nickname now current/trendy again, so the first names that sprang to mind for me were similar Nell, May, Annie and Kitty (could be Helena/Eleanor, Mary/Maria, Anna and Catherine if you wanted longer versions for the BC).

Otherwise I think other retro/vintage names like Cora, Freda, Iris, Lillian, Florence, Clara, Vivien, Louisa, Josephine etc sound nice with Eliza.

For boys I would either go very timeless (so suits any sibset) like Edward, Thomas, James, Alexander, Charles, George, William etc

Or more traditional sounding - John, Robert, Frederick, Alfred, Henry, Phillip, Hugh, Wilfred etc

I like Beth and Tom

Dinah
Marjorie
Anne
Jane
Ruth

Eric
Edgar
Richard
Paul
Tristan

William
Thomas
George
Joshua
Theodore
Harry
James
Charles

Annabel
Beatrice
Nancy
Aubrey
Sophie
Charlotte
Alice
Constance
Rose
Grace

Eliza is lovely!

Felicity
Genevieve
Ruby
Charlotte
Amelia
Ella
Zara
Kate
Laura
Bridget
Olive
Clare
Emily
Francesca
Annabel
Alice
Juliet
Julia

Cameron
Caleb
Jonah
Jacob
Alexander
Adam
Jeremy
Benjamin
Reuben
Lucas
Elias
Fraser
Oliver
George
Henry
Leo

Going by 1904 top baby names - my favourites would be

Florence
Edith
Annie
Alice
Elizabeth
Elsie
Winifred
Kathleen
Mabel
Evelyn
Catherine
Minnie
Clara
Hannah
Martha
Marion
Bessie
Caroline
Rosina

William
George
Arthur
Ernest
Walter
Cyril

Opal
Carrie
Viola

Howard

Ernest
Stanley
Arthur
Alfred
William (Billy)
Joseph
Francis

Mabel
Ada
Ivy
Maisie
Molly
Clover
Jessie
Clara

Thank you so much for your responses, there are some really lovely ones that even my husband likes! I really appreciate it, my husband and I come from pretty big families who like the same sort of names as we do, so it's great to hear other peoples suggestions. Favourites so far are:

Boy
Rory
Douglas
Alexander
Robert

Girl
Harriet
Alice
Ruby
Lillian

I've cut it to my top 5/6 for both- love a traditional name!
Girls
Alice
Martha
Esther
Lydia
Kitty (can be a short for Kathryn if you prefer)
Elsie

Boys
Edward
Peter
Robert
George
Patrick