Struggling to narrow down boys list

[123whatwillitbe]

So far we with like..

George
Arthur
Edward
Reuben
Wilfred

Love Henry, Thomas and James also but can't use them unfortunately.
Any feedback will be great, thankyou.

Phillip
Alexander
Geoffrey
Peter
Oliver

Forgot Hugo, my only concern with this is I'm not sure it flows with our one syllable surname that begins with a G (pretent the surname is graves for example)
Dh also quite likes hugh and Ralph but I'm really not sure about these, any thoughts?

I like Hugo but there are rather a lot of them around. Ralph is lovely.

I like all the ones are your list apart from Hugo! Arthur and Reuben seem to be on an upward trend at the moment.
I really don't like Hugh and Ralph, they're very abrupt names.
Based on your others, what about:
William
Samuel
Benjamin
Albert
Daniel
Alexander
Matthew
Oliver
Joseph / Joe
Charlie

Of your list, my favourite is Edward. Lovely name.

George - fine
Arthur - ok but I wouldn't choose it
Edward - lots of Teddy's around, but otherwise fine.
Reuben - sounds wet and drippy
Wilfred - fine

Reuben and Ralph have more of a 2021 trendy vibe, whereas your other names are gorgeous and classic

I like Wilfred Hugh Edward George and Arthur best

In vague order of preference -
Arthur - love it and think it will stick around as a modern classic
Edward - it’s a classic. Nice and varied short forms
Reuben - it’s very now but it’s a great name, and it’s always been around

Still nice but slightly less keen on George, and deffo less keen on Wilfred. I think they both sound more little boyish to me - as Wilfred will inevitably be Wilf or Freddie

Other thoughts - Rory, Daniel, John, Robert, Walter

Really like Hugh
Don’t mind Hugo (but it’s very now)

Bloody hate Ralph, it is just so wet and sounds like a small dog barking (sorry!) - Rafe is alright though.

1.Hugh - classy, traditional and underused now
8.Ralph - reminds me of the slang for vomiting and feels a bit geeky imo
5.Hugo - fine as a nn for Hugh otherwise it's a bit too trendy/posh
6.George - classic but too pudding like for me (Georgy- Porgy)
4.Arthur - quite trendy now, but a nice name with a cool history
2.Edward - lovely classic, will never go out of fashion, lots of nn choice
7.Reuben - don't like the sound of this for some reason
3.Wilfred - retro/vintage cool and l love the fun nn Wolfie

Edward is my favourite from your list, just so versatile.

I don't like Hugo but I think Hugh would be a great choice - a short, simple underused classic.

I love George and Edward - two of my favourites. I like Arthur and Wilfred too. Not a fan of Reuben or Thomas .

Arthur and Wilfred are lovely!