Lucy or Heidi

[Clairee84]

Which do you prefer?

I feel like Lucy would be an easier choice but I’ve always loved Heidi :)

Any middle names to go nicely?

I like both! Middle name suggestions:

Lucy Alexandra
Lucy Elizabeth
Lucy Caroline
Lucy Elinor
Lucy Clementine
Lucy Adelaide
Lucy Jemima
Lucy Violet

Heidi Rebecca
Heidi Olivia
Heidi Charlotte
Heidi Juliet
Heidi Louisa
Heidi Natalia
Heidi Madeleine

Heidi

Heidi
Heidi Grace
Heidi Amelia
Heidi Louise
Heidi Elizabeth
Heidi Rose
Heidi Violet
Heidi Lily
Heidi Jade

Definitely Heidi

I much prefer Lucy.

Lucy Marianne
Lucy Charlotte
Lucy Emmeline
Lucy Jasmine
Lucy Victoria
Lucy Autumn
Lucy Jennifer
Lucy Alexandra
Lucy Rowena
Lucy Nadia
Lucy Olivia
Lucy Rebecca
Lucy Cordelia
Lucy Harriet
Lucy Aurelia

Not keen on either (to be fair, I rarely like y/ie ending names - I generally find them a bit "cute"), but of the two I much prefer Lucy - it seems more classic to me.

Middle names are hard to suggest because it would depend on how many syllables your surname is/what initial it starts with.

Both are really great choices.

I think I prefer Lucy

I agree with @IamnotwhouthinkIam that Lucy has a more classic feel to it

Popularity wise Lucy is on a massive downward slope too so actually will probably sound much more unusual than Heidi in years to come (Heidi is currently lower in charts but is gradually rising whereas Lucy is rapidly falling)

Lucy by a million miles, it's lovely.

Heidi is horrible, it's so twee it makes my teeth itch.

Lucy is a classic.

Lucy by miles. Lucy is much classier.

Lucy Matilda
Lucy Morwenna
Lucy Jane
Lucy Caroline
Lucy Frances
Lucy Jacqueline
Lucy Primrose
Lucy Catherine

Thank you everyone. And thanks for the middle name suggestions too :)

Lucy

Heidi is lovely!! Different but not too out there and it sounds beautiful.

Heidi Marie
Heidi Louise
Heidi Hope
Heidi Kate
Heidi April

Some of them might not be your taste, I also think Heidi Lucy sounds nice :)

Heidi

Lucy for sure.
It's on my list too.

Ah I love this my sister is called Lucy and my mum Heidi! I love the name Heidi, I've never met another that my DM

Lucie
SPELT the French way

Heidi.

Lucy is one of those names which is lovely, and totally lovely and classic on paper, but it's actually a bit twee.

Heidi is amazing.

Heidi

Lucy is ok but a bit prissy

DS1 would’ve been Lucy if he’d been a girl. I love Heidi too though.

Sorry, I’m not much help!

Lucy