Help me narrow down my list

[Dinosaur19]

DS2 is due. We have gotten down to:

Ted/Teddy (would be Ted on birth certificate)
Jude
Otis
Beau
Reuben
Harry

Ds1 is Oscar.

All lovely names apart from Beau!

I really like Otis Beau Jude and Ted. I don't like Reuben

Oscar and rueben
Oscar and noah

Reuben🤦🏻‍♀️

Love Otis
Reuben is often misspelt.

I'm also one that likes all apart from Beau
Don't think Otis and Oscar are a problem but as pp said I'd make sure they have a different middle initial if you do use it.
Think Reuben Harry or Jude go best with Oscar.
Not keen on Ted/Teddy as a name on its own but like it as a nn personally but get you're point and that it's not everyone's taste to do it that way and is nothing wrong with Ted on its own I'm just not as keen.

Thanks all for your replies!

Ted/Teddy (would be Ted on birth certificate) - I quite like it as a nn for Theodore (or Edward) but I'm not keen on it as a full name
Jude - easily my favourite from your list and feels an excellent match for Oscar
Otis - I don't dislike the name but I don't like it with Oscar
Beau - sorry but I really dislike this. I think it will date badly and be very faddy
Reuben - second favourite. Roo is a cool nickname
Harry - I like it. It is a bit boring next to Oscar but it's ok

I know lots of Oscars (ranging in age from 5 to 17) but I still really like it as a name. I think Jude is the perfect pair with it but Reuben is a good second.
You don't ask for suggestions but Toby or Felix would also work I think.

Somehow I missed all the other posts.
Noah is ok but a bit meh now. I know loads and it is not in the same league as Oscar.