Edie or Penny (middle name Elizabeth)?

[MummyofMunchkins123]

Have asked before but due date now very close so final opinions/suggestions please. Also love Edith. 😍

Edith Elizabeth, nickname Edie would get my vote.

Edith Elizabeth or Penny Elizabeth both lovely

Edith nn Edie would be my vote.

I like Penny but would always put Penelope on bc.

Edith Elizabeth, to be known as Edie.

I am not at all keen on Penny. Edie is lovely.

Edith will likely end up as Edie anyway!

Due you like Penelope (NN Penny?) as that is beautiful. Penelope Elizabeth is a fab name!!

Either Edith Elizabeth or Penelope Elizabeth are lovely.
Hard choice

Penny is much nicer.

Edie Elizabeth is wonderful. Edith Elizabeth too lispy imo.

Penelope with nn penny

Penny and the Queen’s name make me think of coins.

Edie isn’t a name by itself.

Edith Elizabeth would be my vote.

Edith Elizabeth

Not really keen on Edith but like Edie and think Edie Elizabeth sounds lovely

I love Edie Elizabeth. It flows better than Edith IMO.

And ignore people saying its not a real name. Lots of names weren't names once. And I'm 100% certain that my niece, who's name is Edie, has a real name. I mean its on her birth certificate. And her baptism certificate. And her passport. And, well everything.

Edie dislike Penny

I love Edie ; short for Edith . Quite like Penelope too .
Elizabeth is good with either.

I really love Edie but I would worry some ppl might pronounce it Eddie, which is a name I really dislike.

Edie.

What about Elsie, I'm aware it's a bit of a marmite name but I think it suits all ages.

Not keen on Edie but it is better than Edith and Eden is definitely not my taste. Even if I liked Edie, it falls into the vowel-heavy short names trend so seems a bit samey.

Penny is fine but I'd probably put Penelope on the bc. If she is only ever going to be Penny, it's up to you.

Elizabeth is nice as a mn.

How does the first name sound with the surname?

Thanks for your comments. Not keen on Penelope, it would be just Penny. Elsie nice too. X

I love both!

All sound ok with surname.

Great choices @MummyofMunchkins123
Edie Elizabeth sounds amazing

Edie. Edie is cool. Don’t like Edith it’s a bit prim and dull sounding.