Isla, Mabel or Robyn?

[Peanutsmum19]

Which name is best for our baby girl?

I know Robyn is the female version but I still prefer Robin even for a girl (because a robin is an actual real thing).

So I would rank:

Robin
Robyn
Mabel

Isla

...I’d just like to clarify that I do know that a robin is a real thing....

(I just meant that I personally prefer "correct" spellings of things that are things, like Lily, Poppy, Robin, Wren, whereas Molly vs Mollie doesn't seem a big deal!)

I’m a Robyn and have always really liked my name if that helps :).

Also think Mabel is beautiful

I really like them all. I probably like Isla the most but Isla is the most popular so probably one of the other 2. Mabel is very cute and although others have said it’s popular I’ve never met one of any age.

Mabel reminds me of a cat

Mabel is my "guilty pleasure" name . I love it but am sure a child called Mabel would be teased where i live. The name i woukd most like to be called is Robyn.

Mabel

I'm afraid you can't call a child Mabel. It'd be cruel.

Of course it's not cruel. It's a perfectly normal name. It's not that unusual, either. I know about six and am related to two.

Naming a child Mabel isn't cruel. I've heard of at least baby girls born this year called Mabel (Why??) Mabel seems to be the new Amelia, Ellie, Isla, Nevaeh....

At least 10......

Robyn

Isla is a lovely name but if you're after something that isn't overly used, I'd avoid it - there are loads round here (SE London) and it's been popular for the past ten years if my DD's year at school is anything to go by.

Mabel and Robyn are fabulous names; I'm a fan on names that don't end with an 'uh' or 'ee' sound. Robyn is my favourite of the two.