Marnie or Beatrix?

[Namechangedonceagain]

Love both and can't decide! Help please!

Beatrix. But I like them both.

Beatrix is fab!

Beatrix

I think Marnie's going to date. Beatrix is lovely.

Beatrix

Love Marnie

Love Beatrix but to be honest Marnie doesn't feel like a proper name to me though I'm unable to explain why?!?

Marnie I like. Would prefer it to be a nickname for something, eg Marianne, but it's fine as a complete name.

Beatrix is fairly harsh as a pp said. Beer tricks. No. Beatrice is slightly nicer but I think they're both very of the moment.

Easy one - I love Beatrix and really dislike Marnie. Harsh sounds must be subjective because I think Marnie sounds harsh (and dull at the same time if that's possible.) Beatrix has everything going for it.

3rd Marnie thread recently, Hitchcock movie about a psychologically damaged woman.

Beatrix. Much nicer than mardy Marnie.

Marnie if you live somewhere with rhotic r sounds.

I have a daughter named Marnie. The reason we chose it was varied but mostly how it fit with our surname, an informal nickname type worked best as the surname is quite harsh

Marnie is a name that is suddenly popping up everywhere! I like that it's a clunky old name that's getting a revival. Not many nicknames for it though.

Beatrix is a great nod to Beatrix potter and Bea or Trixie are quite cool nicknames. Would it bother you that most people pronounce it 'beer-triss' but some people pronounce it 'Bee-Triss'? For me that was what really put me off.

I have a DD called Beatrix, it’s a very cool name.

Unsure why girls need ‘pretty’ names anyway . I hate fluffy names.

Beatrix! Bea for short (prounounced Bee).
My dd best friend is Beatrice and is Bea. Such a good name.

Marnie sounds like a poor man's Marie/Maria. Like a mash up of two other names. Just sounds a bit off. Just my opinion.

Beatrice is much nicer than trix. More elegant and flows better.

Marnie is meh.