Barnaby or Hamish?

[Mclaren37]

Which do you prefer for DS2? If neither then what else?

I wanted Barnaby for DS but DP vetoed so out of the two, Barnaby is my favourite

Barnaby

LOVE Hamish

I like both and know of at least one successful Barnaby.

I have a Hamish. I have a photo of him next to the St. Andrews cat, Hamish McHamish.

Barnaby nice, but if shortened to Barney makes me think 'Rubble'

Barnaby. I love the name Barney.

Don't like Hamish, always found it a bit wispy

Banish.

Greendale there’s nothing wispy about Hamish, he’s a strapping man in a kilt.

Banish??? autocorrect clearly prefers Barnaby!

Love them both-find it very difficult to choose but at a push I would pick Barnaby

Hamish.

Or Ba(r)nish-combine the two