Maddie or Olivia?

[ShawnMendes]

Madeleine would be on the BC.

DTD Maddie and Olivia.

Maddie!

I never understood the appeal of Olivia.

Love them both! I'd probably go with Olivia though :-)

I love Madeline and Olivia. Don't like Maddie - sounds common.

Olivia :)

Both nice.
I prefer Madeleine, though

Madeleine before Olivia. OLivia before Maddie. Far far too many i.e. ending names about as it is.

I like Madeline more, but I've taught two and they have both been...erm spirited

I like Madeleine more than Olivia, but Liv more than Maddie, so I'm no help.

I'd probably pick Olivia simply based on my dislike of Maddie.

Olivinne combination of the two

ladylunch
Olivileine? Maddivia, Olileine, Maddia? Molivia? ;)

Olivia nn Livvy

I knew identical twins at school who's names were madeleine and Olivia. Everyone called them maddie and livvy.

I like both of them but have to agree with a pp they've both been done to death, there are so many of them in the 0-5 age group especially and it's really going to date them one day. DH and I have 2 Maddies (one Madeleine and one Madison) and two Olivias in among our nieces and cousins' kids, our neighbour's dd is Maddie and her niece is Olivia. Same with the Joshs and Jakes for boys. Sorry, OP, not helpful I know.

Madeleine's really not done to death in the UK though. It ranks in the 170s for popularity. Olivia, by comparison is always in the upper half of the top 10.

Doesn't the OP mean she is having twin girls 'DTD' so she wants to use Maddie (Madeleine) AND Olivia?

Both lovely IMO