What name out of this shortlist??

[buckyou]

We keep going round the houses with names! I'm not convinced with any of them TBH so any alternatives welcome!

Joseph
Arthur
Oscar
Edward

??

Joseph for me, but only if you like Joe.

Daniel
Robert
Thomas
Alexander
George

I love Joseph and Joe. Oscar is cute but very popular. I'm not keen on Arthur at all, just makes me think of eastenders, and in my mind Edwards are a bit thick and posh... (I am SURE they aren't but this is the image that immediately comes to mind). What about George? Or Henry?

I quite like Arthur and Edward

Anthony
Frederick
Stanley
Matthew
Jonathan

Arthur by a very long way, also like the nn Art, Artie.

Oscar is my least favourite, not at all to my taste.

I wanted Edward (Ted) for DS but DH vetoed. After that I would say Arthur, Joseph, Oscar, in that order.

Arthur or Edward.

Both truly great names!

Joseph

Edward or Joseph, really dislike Oscar and Arthur

Joseph or Edward

Love them all apart from Oscar.

How about Rupert? Or Roo for short?

How about...

Harvey
Rupert
Jeremy
Hugh
Charlie

I've always loved them!

I really like Oscar. It is very popular but starting to go down in popularity slightly now, and it feels less trendy-posh than Arthur (lots of yummy mummies with Arthurs round my way at the moment).

Don't get me wrong, I really like Arthur too but I just think Oscar is lovely - strong, sturdy and unpretentious. Edward too (Teddy!) I'm least keen on Joseph.

How about Caspar? Ivor? Tobias? Henry?

Oscar or Arthur

Joseph

I love them all. They've all been on my list at some point.

In order of favourite to least favourite:

1. Edward (because I love the nickname Ned, but also like Ed and Eddie)

1. Joseph (love the nickname Joe, and this one is particularly uncommon where I live - I don't know any Josephs personally!)

1. Oscar

1. Arthur

Arthur & Edward.
I hear a lot of Josephs and Oscars. - good names but overused imo.

Alexander/Xander would be my suggestion. I didn't get to use them from my list.

Love Edward, Arthur and Oscar. I have one of those and two were on shortlist for next baby but was a girl. Mine are grown up now.

I really like them all. Favourite is Edward.

I like Edward and Joseph, both excellent classic names.

Arthur is OK but a bit fusty. Unlike Jooni above, I think of Oscar as pretentious TBH.

Arthur for sure.

Love Arthur and Edward although the latter is VERY common near me with nickname Ted/Teddy.

Arthur and Oscar are lovely! I also like Edward. Not overly keen on Joseph but it's nice enough.

How about:

Theodore
Benedict
Sebastian
Felix