Deliberating - Marnie or Martha?

[ladybirdees]

Have spent to long thinking about these names and can't see the wood for the trees ...what do you think?

[MarvellousMechanicalMouseOrgan]

Yep, Martha is a bit Amish, whereas Marnie is 60s New York.

[NinjaKangaroo]

Martha. Both aren't particularly to my taste, but Marnie sounds quite dated.

[ShadowFall]

Martha

[ThursdayLast]

Love both.
Were it me I'd go for Marnie I think

[somewhereinessex]

Martha - much better than Marnie. We know a very cool 10 year old Martha, not dowdy at all.

[MrsBungle]

I quite like Martha. I really like marnie.

[Marcipex]

Love Marnie, not keen on Martha tbh. I see her as dowdy too, sorry.

[sleepingbeautiful]

I vote Marnie. It seems like chic retro, where as Martha makes me think of a kitchen maid or a hen lol.

[winterhat]

Marnie can be short for Marina, which I also like.

[Alisvolatpropiis]

Marnie, better of the two. Martha is awful.

[Mumof3xx]

Marnie

[lumpolead]

love marnie. strong, unusual name but feminine too.

dislike martha - as bad as bertha for me

[smother]

Marnie or Martha both fab. Also like Marcie.

[extracrunchy]

I love both but would probably go with Marnie?

[TamerB]

No contest- definitely Martha.

[Saharap2]

Martha. I don't think its dowdy. I think its a nice pretty name!

[ladyquinoa]

Martha is a lovely steady stunning classic name. Marnie is a bit trashy sorry.

[ladyquinoa]

You could always call her Martha with the nickname marnie

[Beamur]

Both very lovely - Marnie is a name on the up.

[MattBaines]

Got to be Martha for me. Classic, lovely name.

[BrianTheMole]

Martha. Lovely name.